[nanaimo]

Was the mentor ever asked second in a situation like that or is this a first?

[Jack_]

Katie is a lot more interesting than Rachel ever was...

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Katie is a lot more interesting than Rachel ever was...

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

...well, no it's not, or else it would be called the 'Singing Factor'. I suggest you Google for the definition of the phrase 'X Factor', because it's not just the name of a TV show, it has definition - maybe then you'll understand why it's not just a singing competition, and it incorporates a lot of other factors.

So it looks like you're the stupid one here, darling. But then we always knew that

[Novo]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

Get it in your ****ing head that it's not just about the singing, the X factor has never been just about singing the judges have mentioned this countless times.. I am not sure what you class good tv... 12 ****ing bores with no personality what's so ever singing depressing love songs like your ****e idol leona lewis

[Novo]

Katie is keeping this show alive all by herself at the minute.. should be honoured with some kind of medal or trophy.. all the viewers are tuning in to see what she does next like tonight for example " You know what just sod it " and sitting down.. Next week bottom two with Rebecca or Matt give her a little bit of a test but let's face it the judges will save her because they need her on the show

[Angus]

Originally Posted by Novo

Katie is keeping this show alive all by herself at the minute.. should be honoured with some kind of medal or trophy.. all the viewers are tuning in to see what she does next like tonight for example " You know what just sod it " and sitting down.. Next week bottom two with Rebecca or Matt give her a little bit of a test but let's face it the judges will save her because they need her on the show

Yeah, next week when she's in the bottom 2 again, why bother doing the sing off at all? - she should just stand there and not attempt to sing (which she can't do anyway), perhaps with a generous helping of waterworks, a panic attack or two, and Simon & Co can keep her in because she's "so very interesting".

[Mystic Mock]

the reason they didnt do the bottom 3 was because katie was bottom of the votes i think.

[fruit_cake]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

the reason they didnt do the bottom 3 was because katie was bottom of the votes i think.

she's probably going to be bottom every week from now on too

[bbfan1991]

Oh well at least whilst being disappointed TreyC is dignified and won't hold anything against Katie or the judges, some can be outraged on their own behalf or wave Gamu was robbed flags in the air.

[Livia]

Outrageous Treyc has gone after the pig's ear Katie made of her song. Again. I really can't see why some people think Katie's entertaining. Maybe some people find desperation coupled with a lack of commitment enchanting qualities.

It seems they change the rules too. What happened to taking it to deadlock? Why was Cheryl allowed to abstain like that?

[MeMyselfAndI]

It's patheic.. uuugh see i just hate ****ig Cheryl

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

It's patheic.. uuugh see i just hate ****ig Cheryl

Again, you've changed your tune - two months ago you 'loved her'. Kids these days

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Again, you've changed your tune - two months ago you 'loved her'. Kids these days

- Loius was my favouite judge, the only one who actually judges it as a singing competitions.

- Dannii is the best judge

Katie forgot her words she is so **** lmao

[Mystic Mock]

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

this

[Jords]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

Thats a good point too, actually.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Jords

Thats a good point too, actually.

Not Katie's fault Simon wants to keep her for the PR for the show and Louis kept her in for whatever reason, Cheryl couldn't choose between her two acts and could have sent it to deadlck but it's all show for the controversy.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

Hate is a strong word dislike more better, Katie deserves criticism but some go way too far IMO and get personal which must be hurtful, we hardly know the girl and can only judge by what the papers print which some can be rubbish of course..

Katie knows that is part of the package of doing the show but she's just a contestant on a TV show and theres worst stuff going on elsewhere in the world?, hate.. give me a break.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

Hate is a strong word dislike more better, Katie deserves criticism but some go way too far IMO and get personal which must be hurtful, we hardly know the girl and can only judge by what the papers print which some can be rubbish of course..

Katie knows that is part of the package of doing the show but she's just a contestant on a TV show and theres worst stuff going on elsewhere in the world?, hate.. give me a break.

shes reaching hate,on digital spy the website broke down temporarily and threads have been merged here because most people are hating her.

[Novo]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

i think its cruel that the judges keep saving katie as the public are gonna hate her more and more.

Not really

If your not in it you can't win it

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Novo

Not really

If your not in it you can't win it

But if youre clearly not gonna win it why waste time?

[Novo]

Originally Posted by Jords

But if youre clearly not gonna win it why waste time?

TreyC wasn't going to win it either.. she was in the same position as Katie

[Zippy]

Cheryl said she would go last in the decisions. Not the same as abstaining.

Katie is at least a fighter with passion. TreyC is kinda cold and lacks the drive and ambition. Neither will be a success but IMHO Katie is a far greater asset to the show in drama terms.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Cheryl said she would go last in the decisions. Not the same as abstaining.

Katie is at least a fighter with passion. TreyC is kinda cold and lacks the drive and ambition. Neither will be a success but IMHO Katie is a far greater asset to the show in drama terms.

But she did end up abstaining. She said that she would take it to deadlock but I didn't hear one word of protest from her when they decided to allow her to abstain and throw Treyc out. Funny that.

Katie is desperate to be famous but she doesn't have the skills, the talent or the personality despite her repeatedly telling us how quirky she is and how this is "really her". People see through her and that's why she's not popular with the public. Being desperate isn't the same thing as being a fighter with passion. If she's so passionate about her "art" why does she keep forgetting her words?