[Macie Lightfoot]

Originally Posted by rk3388

RUSSELL HAD A BETTER CHANCE WITH NATALIE THAN PRETTY MUCH ANYONE ELSE.
If he brought jayson i think he would of won, and if he brought someone from the other tribe to f3 it would be 100% them winning, not a single chance

Really? He had a better chance with the biggest social butterfly in a social game? He had the best chance to win when going against the girl who he noticed GETS IN SOCIALLY WITH THE OTHER TRIBE?! : joker: Seriously you don't have a clue about the game if you think that's the case.

[Roy Mars III]

Favourite: Heroes v.s. Villains (only bad thing about it was the winner)

Least: Fiji (I liked Yau-Man but everything else was terrible. Especially when Dreamz when back on his promise. Earl was a good player, but probably also the most boring winner ever. Also just a boring season in general, really)

[rk3388]

favorite: survivor australian outback.
Least: Survivor South Pacific

[Marc]

Most: FvF and HvV

Least: Palau, Fiji

[swinearefine]

Most: China or Pearl Islands
Least: Samoa

Haven't seen Redemption Island or South Pacific (and never will)

[LemonJam]

Faves:
1. Pearl Islands
2. China
3. Panama
4. Vanuatu
5. Gabon

Least:
1. Redemption Island
2. Palau
3. Fiji
4. Thailand
5. Samoa

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by troynuncdicit

He said it himself that he kept Natalie around so she could get in good with the other tribe. He acknowledged that she's a Jury threat and decided to keep her anyway. How can you say THAT makes him deserving of the win? Natalie saw the easiest and most straightforward way to win the game: hide behind Russell, the most unlikable person in the game. My god, the end of Samoa was obvious before the merge just with Russell choosing Natalie over Liz, that was the end all of all end alls. Just as Courtney and Sandra was a season later, Russell didn't learn from his mistake. Russell's game was self destructive. There's nothing impressive about making 40 alliances and backstabbing all of them. If you do that and think you even stand a chance at the Jury, you're a fool. There's no possible argument to say Russell played a good game when he shows many times that he lacks understand of the game's basics.

Answer my question.

Let me ask you this. Lets say if Russell wasn't there, you honestly believe that Natalie would have made it to the finals when her tribe was down in numbers?

[Macie Lightfoot]

Well one can't say for sure because if Russell wasn't there, Natalie would have a different strategy, whatever it may be. But Natalie's social game was superb, far ahead of anyone else in Samoa. She integrated herself well within Galu, having a back up plan with a female alliance and having a say in Erik's boot. Natalie definitely held her own and it wasn't all because of Russell.

[Marc]

I just watched parvati's double hidden immunity idol play, it's so good!!! Every single time I love it!

[SoBig]

Favourite: Cook Islands, Heroes vs Villians, Samoa and South Pacific.

Least: Borneo, The Australian Outback and Gabon

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by troynuncdicit

Well one can't say for sure because if Russell wasn't there, Natalie would have a different strategy, whatever it may be. But Natalie's social game was superb, far ahead of anyone else in Samoa. She integrated herself well within Galu, having a back up plan with a female alliance and having a say in Erik's boot. Natalie definitely held her own and it wasn't all because of Russell.

Had everything to do with Russell. She was his lap dog. Russell controlled his own fate, Natalie didn't. Everyone that Russell wanted voted off, went home in both HvV and Samoa. He controlled the whole game.

If Russell wasn't there Natalie would have been one of the first to go.

Natalie wasn't a terrible player, but she wasn't a great one either.

[lostalex]

Look, stop arguing, Natalie was a weak player, that's WHY she made it to the final. Everyone knows that bringing a weak player to the final increases your chances of winning, and the the only reason that Natalie made the final was because Russell saw her as a weak player and thought "there's no way anyone would vote for her over me". So he CARRIED her to the end.

Obviously Russell underestimated the jury's hate for him. That jury would have voted for Osama Bin Laden over him they hated him so much.

[lostalex]

Favorite: season 16: Fans Vs. Favs
Worst: season 6: The Amazon

[Marc]

Might watch Samoa again

[Roy Mars III]

How can you dislike the Amazon?

Actually forgot about that one, probably me favourite season actually. Rob C. is one of the best

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by SoBig

Favourite: Cook Islands, Heroes vs Villians, Samoa and South Pacific.

Least: Borneo, The Australian Outback and Gabon

omg, australian outback basically DEFINED survivor for all seasons to come, it was good. and i know Gabon wasn't popular, but i rewatched it recently, and i think the funniest and best tribal council ever came from Gabon, the tribal where Crystal was screaming into the camera during the vote about how much she hated Randy, and then Randy looked all smug cause he thought he had an Immunity idol, but it turned out to be a fake idol and jeff threw it in the fire. OMG it was amazing. Also Bob was probably the most likable winner ever. He really was an amazing, intelligent, kind, decent man. I loved Bob!

[lostalex]

Originally Posted by Roy Mars III

How can you dislike the Amazon?

Actually forgot about that one, probably me favourite season actually. Rob C. is one of the best

I was bored the whole time. no great characters.

[Marc]

I liked the game changing seasons. Samoa was great for the Shambo involvement and Russell/Natalie. I loved Cook Island for the multiethnic split and Exile Island for the.. Exile Island

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by lostalex

omg, australian outback basically DEFINED survivor for all seasons to come, it was good. and i know Gabon wasn't popular, but i rewatched it recently, and i think the funniest and best tribal council ever came from Gabon, the tribal where Crystal was screaming into the camera during the vote about how much she hated Randy, and then Randy looked all smug cause he thought he had an Immunity idol, but it turned out to be a fake idol and jeff threw it in the fire. OMG it was amazing.

Gabon is a great season, with probably the second worst winner ever though

[lostalex]

Youtube video

lmao.

[Marc]

I've never seen so many differing views on a TV Show, even when BB is on people tend to understand each other

[Roy Mars III]

the fake idols thing was great, ill admit that, but Bob was so bad at the game overall though(well I guess not so bad, he did win lol). He just stumbled around being the old guy. Nice guy and all, but not a player I like. I like the morally bankrupt people who will stab anyone in the back to get ahead.

Randy, that evil lawyer lady, and Kenny were the heroes of the season

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by lostalex

Look, stop arguing, Natalie was a weak player, that's WHY she made it to the final. Everyone knows that bringing a weak player to the final increases your chances of winning, and the the only reason that Natalie made the final was because Russell saw her as a weak player and thought "there's no way anyone would vote for her over me". So he CARRIED her to the end.

Obviously Russell underestimated the jury's hate for him. That jury would have voted for Osama Bin Laden over him they hated him so much.

100% truth.

You finally made a post that I agree with.

[Marc]

Crystal was a let down in Gabon, thought she'd own everything

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by Roy Mars III

How can you dislike the Amazon?

Actually forgot about that one, probably me favourite season actually. Rob C. is one of the best

Amazon was a terrible season. Should have put that in my list actually.