About Us ThisisBigBrother.com

Macie Lightfoot · 18-05-2014, 04:11 AM

I'm not putting her in the game category, I'm just stating the flaw in your logic that how much a HM is talked about doesn't determine if they're good or bad. Like, Jade often conducted herself in really gross ways on both series. On CBB specifically, she was a bully and although she may not have been consciously racist, she made a lot of explicitly racist comments to the point where her intentions didn't matter. But by your logic, just because she was talked about she was brilliant? **** that. And just because Aaron and Dexter were talked about a lot doesn't make them brilliant. Aaron just whined in the bathroom and gave his girlfriend the could shoulder and Dexter just alternated between mastermind and wounded animal. That's not brilliance, that's anything but.

and lmfao at you thinking I like "nice" people just because I don't like Aaron or Dexter. Like, just going off my signature I wouldn't call Narinder, Sandy, Adele, Tim, Federico, Jason, Derek, Susie, Laura, Charlie, Sophia, Lisa, or Ben nice, and that's like 1/3 of the people in my signature. But nevertheless whenever someone disagrees with your opinions you think that they're not watching the show correctly, and if you're really going to criticize someone's viewing methodology, don't be rude. There's no rules as to how to watch reality TV and pick contestants to support. I support the people who I like watching and that's that. Obviously if a HM makes me nauseous and constantly wanting to X out of my live stream/youtube window I'm not going to want them around any longer. It's not hard to understand.

Videostar · 18-05-2014, 04:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by troynuncdicit

I'm not putting her in the game category, I'm just stating the flaw in your logic that how much a HM is talked about doesn't determine if they're good or bad. Like, Jade often conducted herself in really gross ways on both series. On CBB specifically, she was a bully and although she may not have been consciously racist, she made a lot of explicitly racist comments to the point where her intentions didn't matter. But by your logic, just because she was talked about she was brilliant? **** that. And just because Aaron and Dexter were talked about a lot doesn't make them brilliant. Aaron just whined in the bathroom and gave his girlfriend the could shoulder and Dexter just alternated between mastermind and wounded animal. That's not brilliance, that's anything but.

and lmfao at you thinking I like "nice" people just because I don't like Aaron or Dexter. Like, just going off my signature I wouldn't call Narinder, Sandy, Adele, Tim, Federico, Jason, Derek, Susie, Laura, Charlie, Sophia, Lisa, or Ben nice, and that's like 1/3 of the people in my signature. But nevertheless whenever someone disagrees with your opinions you think that they're not watching the show correctly, and if you're really going to criticize someone's viewing methodology, don't be rude. There's no rules as to how to watch reality TV and pick contestants to support. I support the people who I like watching and that's that. Obviously if a HM makes me nauseous and constantly wanting to X out of my live stream/youtube window I'm not going to want them around any longer. It's not hard to understand.

Point taken with your favourite HM's from the past, it's good to meet someone else that liked Sandy.

but you also assumed that I thought "Shilpa had it coming" in those horrible attacks from Jade, so maybe we both assumed wrongly.

Jade was mainly bad, in both shows she was on, but that doesn't mean she was a bad HM, she was talked about more than anyother HM in her year, including the top two and Alex who I supported, are you seriously telling me that HM's (no matter how they behave) who get talked about most on these forums and who cause the most interest aren't really good entertainment value and so aren't brilliant HM's?.