[setanta]

Can somebody please tell me why Christina Aguilera is winning here? Are you all on glue?

[MrGaryy]

because she ***** all over the majority of that list.

[Zac]

[rquote=2603735&tid=148046&author=.Andy.]The lady?

sure about that[/rquote]

Duh yeah¡
Old rumour.

[MassiveTruck]

Christina Aguilara 17
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 9
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 12
Bjork 13 (+)
Kylie 6
Beyonce 11 (-)
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 10
Annie Lennox 11

[setanta]

[rquote=2603747&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy]because she ***** all over the majority of that list.[/rquote]

You're having a laugh right?

[MrGaryy]

[rquote=2603766&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603747&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy]because she ***** all over the majority of that list.[/rquote]

You're having a laugh right?[/rquote]

clearly not. Unless of course you disagree and think that the five time Grammy winner who directs her videos writes her albums and sings live is inferior to Britney Spears, Madonna, Janet Jackson and Kylie who are merely a name?

[Shaun]

Christina Aguilara 17
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 9
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 12
Bjork 13
Kylie 5 (-)
Beyonce 11
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 11 (+)
Annie Lennox 11

[Novo]

Christina Aguilara 17
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 10 (+)
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 12
Bjork 13
Kylie 4 (-)
Beyonce 11
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 11
Annie Lennox 11

[Shaun]

If i were to rank those listed, it'd go:

Dusty Springfield > Annie Lennox > Joni Mitchell > Kate Bush > Beyonce > Madonna > Britney > Christina > P!nk > PJ Harvey > Bjork > Grace Jones > Janet > Kylie.

[Shaun]

I TAKE IT BACK.

put christina ahead of madonna. i went mad for a moment.

[Shaun]

[abusive u2us from Gary had no part in this sudden change of heart]

[Lauren]

Christina Aguilara 17
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 10
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 12
Bjork 13
Kylie 3 (-)
Beyonce 12 (+)
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 11
Annie Lennox 11

[MrGaryy]

*walks in, inspecting the place*

All seems to be in order here.

anywhoo on with preceedings

Christina Aguilera 18
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 10
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 12
Bjork 13
Kylie 2 (-)
Beyonce 12 (+)
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 11
Annie Lennox 11

[setanta]

[rquote=2603908&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy][rquote=2603766&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603747&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy]because she ***** all over the majority of that list.[/rquote]

You're having a laugh right?[/rquote]

clearly not. Unless of course you disagree and think that the five time Grammy winner who directs her videos writes her albums and sings live is inferior to Britney Spears, Madonna, Janet Jackson and Kylie who are merely a name?[/rquote]

Madonna is just a name? Are you mental? Christina is just a slapper who changes her style in accordance with Britney. Everything she does is about one step behind Britney, and sure I don't even like Britney to begin with.

She can sing but don't be fooled into thinking that she's in control of all of the writing and producing. They all slap their names on songs now. You'd need a brain to do it really and she isn't in possession of one.

[MrGaryy]

[rquote=2604040&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603908&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy][rquote=2603766&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603747&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy]because she ***** all over the majority of that list.[/rquote]

You're having a laugh right?[/rquote]

clearly not. Unless of course you disagree and think that the five time Grammy winner who directs her videos writes her albums and sings live is inferior to Britney Spears, Madonna, Janet Jackson and Kylie who are merely a name?[/rquote]

Madonna is just a name? Are you mental? Christina is just a slapper who changes her style in accordance with Britney. Everything she does is about one step behind Britney, and sure I don't even like Britney to begin with.

She can sing but don't be fooled into thinking that she's in control of all of the writing and producing. They all slap their names on songs now. You'd need a brain to do it really and she isn't in possession of one.[/rquote]

with all due respect I think i know a tad more than you do. I;m not some passing fan who buys the odd CD. I track that woman's every move every song that leaks I have it every show she appears on I have it every magazine she is in I have it. I know she has total creative control because if you think her label would have let her change her style so drastically each album, let her stray away from her cookie cutter image you're fooled.

In regards to Britney - when did she produce a 2 disk album throwback to the 30s and 40s? When did Britney write a whole album? When did Britney record one of the most emotional songs about her fathers domestic violence, in tears all in one take? When did Britney decide to go head first into electronica working with artists like Le Tigre, Ladytron and Sia?

slapper? She's happily married with a son, is rarely pictured out at night - I know this because she hasnt left her house in 2 weeks other than for groceries.

[Alf]

[rquote=2604047&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy][rquote=2604040&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603908&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy][rquote=2603766&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603747&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy]because she ***** all over the majority of that list.[/rquote]

You're having a laugh right?[/rquote]

clearly not. Unless of course you disagree and think that the five time Grammy winner who directs her videos writes her albums and sings live is inferior to Britney Spears, Madonna, Janet Jackson and Kylie who are merely a name?[/rquote]

Madonna is just a name? Are you mental? Christina is just a slapper who changes her style in accordance with Britney. Everything she does is about one step behind Britney, and sure I don't even like Britney to begin with.

She can sing but don't be fooled into thinking that she's in control of all of the writing and producing. They all slap their names on songs now. You'd need a brain to do it really and she isn't in possession of one.[/rquote]

with all due respect I think i know a tad more than you do. I;m not some passing fan who buys the odd CD. I track that woman's every move every song that leaks I have it every show she appears on I have it every magazine she is in I have it. I know she has total creative control because if you think her label would have let her change her style so drastically each album, let her stray away from her cookie cutter image you're fooled.

In regards to Britney - when did she produce a 2 disk album throwback to the 30s and 40s? When did Britney write a whole album? When did Britney record one of the most emotional songs about her fathers domestic violence, in tears all in one take? When did Britney decide to go head first into electronica working with artists like Le Tigre, Ladytron and Sia?

slapper? She's happily married with a son, is rarely pictured out at night - I know this because she hasnt left her house in 2 weeks other than for groceries.[/rquote]
<object width="560" height="340"><param name="movie" value="http://www.youtube.com/v/GDlUWur3kEE&hl=en&fs=1&"></param><param name="allowFullScreen" value="true"></param><param name="allowscriptaccess" value="always"></param><embed src="http://www.youtube.com/v/GDlUWur3kEE&hl=en&fs=1&" type="application/x-shockwave-flash" allowscriptaccess="always" allowfullscreen="true" width="560" height="340"></embed></object>

[setanta]

[rquote=2604047&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy][rquote=2604040&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603908&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy][rquote=2603766&tid=148046&author=setanta][rquote=2603747&tid=148046&author=MrGaryy]because she ***** all over the majority of that list.[/rquote]

You're having a laugh right?[/rquote]

clearly not. Unless of course you disagree and think that the five time Grammy winner who directs her videos writes her albums and sings live is inferior to Britney Spears, Madonna, Janet Jackson and Kylie who are merely a name?[/rquote]

Madonna is just a name? Are you mental? Christina is just a slapper who changes her style in accordance with Britney. Everything she does is about one step behind Britney, and sure I don't even like Britney to begin with.

She can sing but don't be fooled into thinking that she's in control of all of the writing and producing. They all slap their names on songs now. You'd need a brain to do it really and she isn't in possession of one.[/rquote]

with all due respect I think i know a tad more than you do. I;m not some passing fan who buys the odd CD. I track that woman's every move every song that leaks I have it every show she appears on I have it every magazine she is in I have it. I know she has total creative control because if you think her label would have let her change her style so drastically each album, let her stray away from her cookie cutter image you're fooled.

In regards to Britney - when did she produce a 2 disk album throwback to the 30s and 40s? When did Britney write a whole album? When did Britney record one of the most emotional songs about her fathers domestic violence, in tears all in one take? When did Britney decide to go head first into electronica working with artists like Le Tigre, Ladytron and Sia?

slapper? She's happily married with a son, is rarely pictured out at night - I know this because she hasnt left her house in 2 weeks other than for groceries.[/rquote]

You track her through magazines? Eh? Of course she has an element of control... that's why she's cleaned her act at exactly the same time that Britney decided to. She's dull and once a slapper always a slapper. She knows that she got loadsa bad press when she slapped it up so she's toning it down now..zzzz.

[MrGaryy]

Hell no, I track her through every means I have mostly her forums which provide any paparazzi shots that come through and are filled with fans more hardcore than I am.

You clearly are clueless on the subject as otherwise you would know that in 2007 Britney was a complete wreck she had her kids taken away from her, she was sectioned she was completely crazy. In 2007 Christina had been married for 2 years with a baby on the way. In 2004 Britney was off in pink wigs, getting hitched in Vegas, getting pregnant twice to a total scumbag. I 2004 Christina met her future husband and took a long break from working two come back 2 years later with a number one album.

So I don;t know where you're getting your 'that's why she's cleaned her act at exactly the same time that Britney decided to' argument from, but you are very much mistaken.

and she does have an element of control yes, a very large one. She wrote every track on her last album and every track on the album before bar 1. She chose to go in the old classic jazz and soul route because it was what inspired her when she was young and similarly she wanted to do electronica this album because its what she likes to listen to today. She directed her the music video for Candyman, for which she won an award for.

I don't care if you don't like her just don't attempt to argue with me about something you quite obviously know nothing about.

[setanta]

I think she's just media savvy but she's really not liked in the show business world. Had numerous spats with many other celebs and in interviews she just spews out the usual rubbish like Britney. Nothing to her at all.

And she wrote every track along with 2 or 3 other lads. All a bit suss to me.

[MassiveTruck]

Christina Aguilera 18
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 10
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 12
Bjork 14 (+)
Kylie 2
Beyonce 11 (-)
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 11
Annie Lennox 11

[arsenalforever]

Cat Power
Arthena Franklin
PJ Harvey
Fraincois Hardy
Maggie Bell
Linda thompson
Emmylou harris
Dolly Parton
Linda Ronstandt
Gillian Welch
Shelby lynne

[NettoSuperstar!]

Dolly Parton over Patsy Cline

[arsenalforever]

[rquote=2604171&tid=148046&author=NettoSuperstar!]Dolly Parton over Patsy Cline[/rquote]

yep dolly parton has written some great tunes but is looked down upon cause she did a few commercial songs in the 70's and 80's

[MrGaryy]

[rquote=2604068&tid=148046&author=setanta]I think she's just media savvy but she's really not liked in the show business world. Had numerous spats with many other celebs and in interviews she just spews out the usual rubbish like Britney. Nothing to her at all.

And she wrote every track along with 2 or 3 other lads. All a bit suss to me.[/rquote]

ugh you're so full of crap. Yah of course she has co writers most artists do. The fact is all songs are based on her own experiences. You know nothing, you're just arguing for the sake of it.

and yeah, cos I'm sure you've seen so many of her interviews.

[Shaun]

Christina Aguilera 18
Britney Spears 9
Madonna 10
Janet Jackson 5
Kate Bush 13 (+)
Bjork 14
Kylie 1 (-)
Beyonce 11
PJ Harvey 10
Grace Jones 10
Pink 13
Dusty Springfield 10
Joni Mitchell 11
Annie Lennox 11