[Livia]

Originally Posted by fruit_cake

this, good post, Livia!

How sweet, thank you, FC.

[MeMyselfAndI]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Katie is a lot more interesting than Rachel ever was...

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

[Novo]

Originally Posted by Jords

But if youre clearly not gonna win it why waste time?

TreyC wasn't going to win it either.. she was in the same position as Katie

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

...well, no it's not, or else it would be called the 'Singing Factor'. I suggest you Google for the definition of the phrase 'X Factor', because it's not just the name of a TV show, it has definition - maybe then you'll understand why it's not just a singing competition, and it incorporates a lot of other factors.

So it looks like you're the stupid one here, darling. But then we always knew that

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Cheryl said she would go last in the decisions. Not the same as abstaining.

Katie is at least a fighter with passion. TreyC is kinda cold and lacks the drive and ambition. Neither will be a success but IMHO Katie is a far greater asset to the show in drama terms.

But as soon as she said that Dermot made it clear Louis would have the deciding vote.

What kind of fighter gives up, sits on the floor and says 'sod it' half way thru a song like some petulant 9 year old.

[Novo]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

its a ****ing singing contest...

get that in your head, i know you've came from big brother but surely your not that stupid.

Rachel was a better singer than Katie..

Get it in your ****ing head that it's not just about the singing, the X factor has never been just about singing the judges have mentioned this countless times.. I am not sure what you class good tv... 12 ****ing bores with no personality what's so ever singing depressing love songs like your ****e idol leona lewis

[Livia]

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Novo

Get it in your ****ing head that it's not just about the singing, the X factor has never been just about singing the judges have mentioned this countless times.. I am not sure what you class good tv... 12 ****ing bores with no personality what's so ever singing depressing love songs like your ****e idol leona lewis

Class.

Originally Posted by Livia

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there

[Novo]

Originally Posted by Livia

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

She clearly has a lot more then all the other acts put together because everyone seems to be talking about her

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Class.



She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there

i dont think she has stage pressence.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Jack_

She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there

Yeah, she's still there. Down in the bottom two... same again next week I reckon. You're in the minority I reckon.

[rosebay11]

The whole thing - going to the mentor 2nd - and then ignoring her seemed very weird, I must say. Pity Treyc is gone, IMO.

[BB_Eye]

Originally Posted by Livia

But she did end up abstaining. She said that she would take it to deadlock but I didn't hear one word of protest from her when they decided to allow her to abstain and throw Treyc out. Funny that.

Katie is desperate to be famous but she doesn't have the skills, the talent or the personality despite her repeatedly telling us how quirky she is and how this is "really her". People see through her and that's why she's not popular with the public. Being desperate isn't the same thing as being a fighter with passion. If she's so passionate about her "art" why does she keep forgetting her words?

I think she is talented, but it's apparent to me that she just doesn't put the necessary work in and that she isn't taking it seriously enough. Some "passion".

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

uugh katie is a ugly ****ing freaky dramaqueen bitch

Charming, would you say that to her face?.

It must be worrying for her mom to hear all this abuse aimed at her daughter and then turn up to Xtra Factor like it's alright, Katie has chosen to be on the show but I would feel the same if I had a son or daughter in that position.. I may dislike someone e.g. Paije based on personality even though I do like his performances but I don't hate the guy or start getting personal.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Jack_

She clearly does - stage presence, image and personality. All three traits she definitely has. Her vocal talent isn't the strongest, but it's certainly not awful. So looks like she does have the 'X Factor' after all, hence why she's still there

Shes still there because the judges bum her. Nothing more.

The public dont seem to have taken to her 'x factor'

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Novo

She clearly has a lot more then all the other acts put together because everyone seems to be talking about her

Yes, but were mostly saying negative stuff. Clearly.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Livia

How come then, if its all about having the X Factor, Katie is still in it? Because she clearly doesn't have it.

Katies been grabbing headlines and getting people talking since her first audition. So she clearly has something...passion, desperation..whatever, its SOMETHING.

Meanwhile, TreyC hovers in the background unnoticed.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfandI

uugh katie is a ugly ****ing freaky dramaqueen bitch

harsh much?

And no way is she ugly anyway

[Novo]

Originally Posted by Livia

Yes, but were mostly saying negative stuff. Clearly.

Doesn't matter really they are all still talking about her she is making all the headlines

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Novo

She clearly has a lot more then all the other acts put together because everyone seems to be talking about her

Originally Posted by Zippy

Katies been grabbing headlines and getting people talking since her first audition. So she clearly has something...passion, desperation..whatever, its SOMETHING.

Meanwhile, TreyC hovers in the background unnoticed.

THANK YOU. This is the point. Dullards do not get press attention. So she clearly has stage presence and personality.

Originally Posted by Livia

Yeah, she's still there. Down in the bottom two... same again next week I reckon. You're in the minority I reckon.

I blame the press.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Novo

Doesn't matter really they are all still talking about her she is making all the headlines

Yeah, so did Gary Glitter. Didn't mean he was popular.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Livia

Yes, but were mostly saying negative stuff. Clearly.

Forums can count for good and bad press and like Simon says it's better than having nothing, at least she's making an impact even if you dislike her.. TreyC should have made more of an impact hence why some forgot who she was and Cheryl should have focused on her more.

[GiRTh]

The fix stories have started lol
Daily Mail

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

The fix stories have started lol
Daily Mail

The Daily Fail starts things off then

[Novo]

Originally Posted by Livia

Yeah, so did Gary Glitter. Didn't mean he was popular.

Can't really compare Gary glitter to Katie FFS He is a Peado and Katie is a singer on the X factor