[Soldier Boy]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

so now you are sharing blatant antisemitic stuff

I'd like to see you justify in what way what Liam shared is in any way antisemitic, let alone "blatantly" antisemitic. I'll be baffled if you even try. I'm sure you won't; easier to just drop a bomb and walk away than actually try to dig into any sort of nuance. Right? Yes I believe that's the current script isn't it.

[bitontheslide]

i don't need to justify my comments to anyone or reply on demand for that matter

[LeatherTrumpet]

[Soldier Boy]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

i don't need to justify my comments to anyone or reply on demand for that matter

No you don't and you'll see that I predicted that you wouldn't - because you can't.

So instead I'll just describe what I saw and you can tell me that I'm wrong (or not, as you say you don't have to do anything).

1) Liam posted a video of someone suggesting/advocating/threatening/perhaps promising(?) genocide of a civilian population as an inevitability.

2) You called him antisemitic, because the person in that video happened to be Jewish.

3) It was suggested that you couldn't justify that remark

4) You incredulously refused to justify the remark, with a silly air of "I could if I wanted to but I don't so there".


Have I missed the mark?

As a note to mods: I would suggest that dropping an accusation of antisemitism (and yes, you could apply this to any other -ism or -phobe) without any attempt whatsoever to justify the reasoning for saying it (I'm not advocating a ban on saying it, just that people show their working, so to speak) should be considered a baseless personal insult and thus a violation of forum rules. Just a thought.

[arista]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Spoof from USA.


Used to be on the Daily Show
but that show was stopped
after Trevor Noah
left.
And they never got a replacement
just temps


It is all Trevor's fault

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Soldier Boy

No you don't and you'll see that I predicted that you wouldn't - because you can't.

So instead I'll just describe what I saw and you can tell me that I'm wrong (or not, as you say you don't have to do anything).

1) Liam posted a video of someone suggesting/advocating/threatening/perhaps promising(?) genocide of a civilian population as an inevitability.

2) You called him antisemitic, because the person in that video happened to be Jewish.

3) It was suggested that you couldn't justify that remark

4) You incredulously refused to justify the remark, with a silly air of "I could if I wanted to but I don't so there".


Have I missed the mark?

As a note to mods: I would suggest that dropping an accusation of antisemitism (and yes, you could apply this to any other -ism or -phobe) without any attempt whatsoever to justify the reasoning for saying it (I'm not advocating a ban on saying it, just that people show their working, so to speak) should be considered a baseless personal insult and thus a violation of forum rules. Just a thought.

After I don't know how many times now and over years too as to myself.

Your last paragraph is one I endorse 100%
Absolutely.

Plus I saw nothing at all to justify terming what Liam posted as of anything remotely antisemitic
It's become an easy accusation to throw out however it is an inflammatory, incitive and dangerous accusation to make

[arista]

Arrest this Punk
Lock him up for 3 months
Criminal Damage

[Smear red paint over the Foreign Office and weapons firm's HQ]

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...al-damage.html

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Soldier Boy

No you don't and you'll see that I predicted that you wouldn't - because you can't.

So instead I'll just describe what I saw and you can tell me that I'm wrong (or not, as you say you don't have to do anything).

1) Liam posted a video of someone suggesting/advocating/threatening/perhaps promising(?) genocide of a civilian population as an inevitability.

2) You called him antisemitic, because the person in that video happened to be Jewish.

3) It was suggested that you couldn't justify that remark

4) You incredulously refused to justify the remark, with a silly air of "I could if I wanted to but I don't so there".


Have I missed the mark?

As a note to mods: I would suggest that dropping an accusation of antisemitism (and yes, you could apply this to any other -ism or -phobe) without any attempt whatsoever to justify the reasoning for saying it (I'm not advocating a ban on saying it, just that people show their working, so to speak) should be considered a baseless personal insult and thus a violation of forum rules. Just a thought.

Treat other forum members with respect. Posts which insult or direct profanity towards another member, will be deleted, or edited out. This may lead to a forum warnings, infractions and posting bans

is in the rules



also in the rules is this

Racism/homophobia/xenophobia/discrimination of any sort won't be tolerated.

so if Liam broke any rules i think mods would've already acted




but honestly i don't like to mini-mod myself (just saying be nice and keep things professional in here, and we don't have to give our mods too much work to do)

[arista]

Palestine Burning
in New Xmas Ad.


https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...nian-flag.html

[arista]

[arista]

Arrest this Punk

[Oliver_W]

Originally Posted by arista

Palestine Burning
in New Xmas Ad.


https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...nian-flag.html

Omg

That was OBVIOUSLY unintentional, as those are just traditional Christmassy colours...

But the timing etc just makes it so morbidly funny.

[arista]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

Omg

That was OBVIOUSLY unintentional, as those are just traditional Christmassy colours...

But the timing etc just makes it so morbidly funny.

Yes filmed in August

[Oliver_W]

An argument for that video being antisemetic could be:

A random woman who has nothing to do with the Israeli government is being used as propaganda to drive the narrative that all Zionists want Palestine destroyed. She didn't ask to be the face of Zionism, so using a random Jewish woman as a poster girl is antisemitic.

That's not what I actually think, I don't have an opinion on that video in all honesty. But it's not hard to actually come up with a justification for a viewpoint.

[Stu]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

Why don't you fu ck off and stop hounding me on every post. I repeat, i will say what i want.

And if you say daft bollocks you can't back up, people will pull you up on it.

This is kind of what sitting at the dinner table with the rest of the adults entails.

You were absolutely murdered and it was fully deserved in this case.

Anyway, onto more anti-semitism...

It's a bit pointless trying to balance out people's algorithms and the thread's own (largely one-man-on-a-mission) internal algorithm when waiting for my dinner to cook, I know, but trust me people will look back on their absolute hubris of being partisan and privy to this genocide whilst literal human rights scholars were whistleblowing as to the magnitude of what was going on.

[LeatherTrumpet]

Youtube video

[Niamh.]

Well If Ben Shapiro says it........

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by arista

Palestine Burning
in New Xmas Ad.


https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/art...nian-flag.html

dont be so ridiculous.......

[LeatherTrumpet]

Originally Posted by Cherie

dont be so ridiculous.......

The lack of balls in corporates is just that, ridiculous

[LeatherTrumpet]

[LeatherTrumpet]

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Oh boy

[LeatherTrumpet]

[Soldier Boy]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

Why don't you fu ck off and stop hounding me on every post. I repeat, i will say what i want.

If you can't debate stay out of the debates forum, and if I want to respond to your posts and call them out for what they are I will. As I've had to say to others before -- if you're going to get weepy about being "hounded" then stick to chat & games and the Big Bro section. Or don't. It's your call but if you're posting in a debates forum, expect to be disagreed with, expect to be asked to justify your posts, and expect to be called out for it if you refuse.

[arista]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet