[Jords]

Idk about you lot,
but, for me, Simon, Louis & Cheryl made 2 bad choices each.
But, thats only me prefering others,
but for sure, they all made 1 bad choice each.

Cheryl - Joe over Ethan/Duane
Simon - Olly over Nicole/Treyc
Louis - J+E over De-Tour/Harmony Hood

I also think Llyod and Kandy Rain were bad choices,
and I dont like Danyl so him too, but thats me being picky there,
lmao.

But for me, Danni picked the 3 I thought were best,
and she has gone from having the 3rd strongest group,
to the first. What do ya think?

Danii ftw!

[Harry!]

Dannii is wise and so is her sister. Good luck Dannii.

[Stephanie]

i was suprised, danni made very good choices.

[teabag.]

i think dannii is the best judge actually

[Marsh.]

I agree Louis is on another planet to everyone else, John and Edward? Give me a break.
(no wonder most of his bands sack him - i'm sure even Girls Aloud did at one stage).
I don't think Cheryl has a very strong category this year anyway so it doesn't matter and Simon madea bad choice with the teacher because he is too OTT. Dannii's category has the most talent.

[ss00]

she's been the best judge even last year..

[Jords]

[rquote=2624478&tid=148510&author=ss00]she's been the best judge even last year..[/rquote]

See her first year,
never thought highly of her as a judge,
liked her as a person, but was a bit mehhh.
But now she is my favourite,
really knows what shes on about,
and isnt over dramatic like Cheryl,
altho I like Cheryl too,
Dannii is better imo.

[Maia]

I usually dislike Dannii, but she's made the best decisions this year I'd say.

[30stone]

Uh Danni put through Rachel??

For Danni - Rachel < Despina.
For Simon - Olly = Treyc not sure about that one.
For Cheryl - Rikki < Duane
For Louis - J&E < Project A


So for me Simon made the best choices.

[Jords]

[rquote=2624491&tid=148510&author=30stone]Uh Danni put through Rachel??

For Danni - Rachel < Despina.
For Simon - Olly = Treyc not sure about that one.
For Cheryl - Rikki < Duane
For Louis - J&E < Project A


So for me Simon made the best choices.[/rquote]

Rachel is very good,
for me Rachel = Despina, toss up between them too.

[30stone]

Despina has the looks and the voice though.

More of "the x factor"

[ss00]

i dont get whats wit the dislike on rachel... she's really gud... for me.. its... stacy <<< Despina.

[30stone]

Stacy has one of the most powerful voices.
Rachels voice is pretty average.

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

Dannii is my favourite judge, or well the only one I like really. But Producers and Simon have a final say on it all.

[Z]

I think they all made bad choices.

Dannii should have put Despina through, but at the same time, she put through three very talented girl singers, so somebody was going to lose out, I just don't think it should have been Despina.
Louis put through those muppet twins, and I can't see Miss Frank or Kandy Rain surviving more than a month tops - John and Edward will undoubtedly make the final despite being a pair of prime twerps.
Simon made the weakest choices, I think. I'm sure the three guys will turn out to be amazing; Simon always seems to make weird choices who turn out amazing, but I think Daniel and Nicole should have made it through along with Jamie.
Cheryl's choices took the mick though, but that category was pretty weak anyway.

Dannii will surely win!?

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

[rquote=2624459&tid=148510&author=Harry.]Dannii is wise and so is her sister. Good luck Dannii.[/rquote]

What show is that with Kenan in it?

[Braden]

i love danni

[Jords]

[rquote=2624510&tid=148510&author=ss00]i dont get whats wit the dislike on rachel... she's really gud... for me.. its... stacy <<< Despina.[/rquote]

If Im honest,
in terms of good voice,
Lucie beats all the girls,
and Stacey=Rachel=Despina.

In terms of personality/likability,
Stacey beats all the girls,
Lucie(maybe slighlty more)=Rachel=Despina

Lucie & Stacey both should go through,
as they have individually a higher quality,
Despina = Rachel, it comes to who Dannii thinks
can become better.

[Harry!]

[rquote=2624532&tid=148510&author=Sir_Diary_of_Room us][rquote=2624459&tid=148510&author=Harry.]Dannii is wise and so is her sister. Good luck Dannii.[/rquote]

What show is that with Kenan in it?[/rquote]

Kenan

[Stephanie]

[rquote=2624659&tid=148510&author=Harry.][rquote=2624532&tid=148510&author=Sir_Diary_of_Room us][rquote=2624459&tid=148510&author=Harry.]Dannii is wise and so is her sister. Good luck Dannii.[/rquote]

What show is that with Kenan in it?[/rquote]

Kenan [/rquote]
the only show i know with a kenan is kenan and kel LOL.

[Sir_Diary_of_Roomus]

[rquote=2624659&tid=148510&author=Harry.][rquote=2624532&tid=148510&author=Sir_Diary_of_Room us][rquote=2624459&tid=148510&author=Harry.]Dannii is wise and so is her sister. Good luck Dannii.[/rquote]

What show is that with Kenan in it?[/rquote]

Kenan [/rquote]

Looks like Kenan Thompson, in your sig.

[Tom4784]

Dannii's got the strongest group, At the moment I'd say Lucie or Stacey's gonna win but the last two years have shown that early favourites don't always win. LLoyd and Joe will go far just because of their looks and the fact mothers are gonna eat 'em up. Olly and Danyl won't last too long and if britain's got any sense John and Edward will get booted the ***** out early.

I don't think we'll get a successful artist this year though.

[KKBL]

[rquote=2624845&tid=148510&author=Dezzy]Dannii's got the strongest group, At the moment I'd say Lucie or Stacey's gonna win but the last two years have shown that early favourites don't always win. LLoyd and Joe will go far just because of their looks and the fact mothers are gonna eat 'em up. Olly and Danyl won't last too long and if britain's got any sense John and Edward will get booted the **** out early.

I don't think we'll get a successful artist this year though.[/rquote]
The only reason Llyod got further then bootcamp was because of his looks.
But Joe?eh,I dont think so.He'll defenitely get the mothers vote though

[MeMyselfAndI]

If you heard Harmony Hood they were awful singers, Kandy Rain were GOOD singers, therefore Kandy Rain deserve to be in the final 12s. De-Tour however should be instead of John and Edward, BUT Loius put a risk thinking John and Edward would go futher than De-Tour in the competition, which i think is true, i think De-Tour would go out in the 1st week. Also De-Tour were really offputting by there faces they pulled while singing.

Simon had the over 25s, all of them were worthy finalists. However Simon knew Treyc and Nicole would not make it as far as Olly would in the competition, as Olly could be considered more entertaining and more personality than them, although Treyc had an AMAZING voice, probably better than Olly's she had zero personality, so she would not get as far as Olly(Olly danced and had a bubbly personality) Also Nicole just is'nt as likeable as Olly.

You're right about Cheryl though, i would say Joe and Rikki were very Dumb decisions. Joe and Rikki are both less popular than Ethan and Duane. Also Rikki is an average singer, and Joe is a just above average singer, with Ethan and Duane being better than them in everyway( YES INCLUDDING PERSONALITY!)

[Jords]

[rquote=2629958&tid=148510&author=Bigbrofan085]If you heard Harmony Hood they were awful singers, Kandy Rain were GOOD singers, therefore Kandy Rain deserve to be in the final 12s. De-Tour however should be instead of John and Edward, BUT Loius put a risk thinking John and Edward would go futher than De-Tour in the competition, which i think is true, i think De-Tour would go out in the 1st week. Also De-Tour were really offputting by there faces they pulled while singing.

Simon had the over 25s, all of them were worthy finalists. However Simon knew Treyc and Nicole would not make it as far as Olly would in the competition, as Olly could be considered more entertaining and more personality than them, although Treyc had an AMAZING voice, probably better than Olly's she had zero personality, so she would not get as far as Olly(Olly danced and had a bubbly personality) Also Nicole just is'nt as likeable as Olly.

You're right about Cheryl though, i would say Joe and Rikki were very Dumb decisions. Joe and Rikki are both less popular than Ethan and Duane. Also Rikki is an average singer, and Joe is a just above average singer, with Ethan and Duane being better than them in everyway( YES INCLUDDING PERSONALITY!)
[/rquote]

Kandy Rain arnt bad,
but I just found Harmony Hood really different,
the show should have some variation,
but now I think about it,
Miss Frank and Kandy Rain are quite different girl groups,
so it might work out well.

Personality should be considered when picking finalists,
but when Nicole and Treyc have voices like that,
for me, they beat Olly's personality.
I also think olly is very cocky,
and I think they all show perosnality when actually on the show.