[Kazanne]

Why are people blaming Simon for Lucie's demise? Isn't it the public who pick up the phones and vote,J&E and Lucie were in the bottom two,Simon has just explained he didn't think either could win and it was fairer to take it to the public vote,so it'd the PUBLICS fault,the show is for the public to pick winners,If he had got rid of J&E he would have been called for that and vice versa,Blame the public for not voting,If this show had been a straight forward vote with no judges,she would have gone anyway,I also wanted rid of J&E the reason they are still there is down to th PUBLIC.

[InOne]

St Simon is without sin.

[Rory]

Because it was ultimately his hypocritical decision that sent Lucie home. He preaches it being a singing competition, but lets the obviously stronger singer just walk home.

[Adamw92]

Simon knew fine well that Lucie would go, he did it on purpose after weeks of hating on the twins and saying its supposed to be about singing then he goes and does that, its a complete joke!

[Tom]

Simon did what is best for his show. Lucie was never going to win anyway, Jedward generate more headlines and this creates even more

It happens every year and people think its something new. Its ridiculous

Last year with Daniel, series 4 with Same Difference, series 3 with McDonald brothers and Chico in 2005.

[teabag.]

i agree! people need to get over it and realise lucie obviously wasnt popular! she wouldnt of won so whats the issue!!
if everyone suddenly lucie now why didnt you all fecking vote for her!

[Stephanie]

lucie would have gone sometime anyway, might aswell let her go now than keep her hanging with false hope.

[LemonJam]

Originally Posted by kazanne

Isn't it the public who pick up the phones and vote.

I'd say it was more the mentally disabled but whatever.

[LemonJam]

Originally Posted by teabag.

i agree! people need to get over it and realise lucie obviously wasnt popular! she wouldnt of won so whats the issue!!
if everyone suddenly lucie now why didnt you all fecking vote for her!

We can't vote for every ****ing act to make sure John and Edward go, some of us have homes to keep up.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Adamw92

Simon knew fine well that Lucie would go, he did it on purpose after weeks of hating on the twins and saying its supposed to be about singing then he goes and does that, its a complete joke!

No he didn't he has just said he thought it would have been Lucie that stayed so don't second guess people,Lucie was obviously not as popular as you think or else she wouldn't have been in the bottom two would she?but if it makes you feel better don't blame the public ,blame Simon eh?

[Rory]

Originally Posted by Stephanie

lucie would have gone sometime anyway, might aswell let her go now than keep her hanging with false hope.

I could never live with myself if, in a face-off, John and Edward beat me. Lucie should have at least left with dignity.

[Rory]

Originally Posted by kazanne

No he didn't he has just said he thought it would have been Lucie that stayed so don't second guess people,Lucie was obviously not as popular as you think or else she wouldn't have been in the bottom two would she?but if it makes you feel better don't blame the public ,blame Simon eh?

Danyl was obviously not as popular as you think or else he wouldn't have been in the bottom two would he?

The bottom two is nothing to judge by, love. People just assume their act is safe and don't vote some weeks.

If you're saying Lucie is unpopular, say the same for your beloved Danyl.

kthnxbye.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Rory

I could never live with myself if, in a face-off, John and Edward beat me. Lucie should have at least left with dignity.

Yeah poor girl

[Fom]

It is Simons fault though, the whole point of the judges vote is to stop acts going out because the public make a mistake. Tonight I believe they did... and Simon being a biased twit, abused his powers.

[Rory]

Originally Posted by Fom

It is Simons fault though, the whole point of the judges vote is to stop acts going out because the public make a mistake. Tonight I believe they did... and Simon being a biased twit, abused his powers.

Spot on.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Rory

Danyl was obviously not as popular as you think or else he wouldn't have been in the bottom two would he?

The bottom two is nothing to judge by, love. People just assume their act is safe and don't vote some weeks.

If you're saying Lucie is unpopular, say the same for your beloved Danyl.

kthnxbye.

Oh dear,At least I didn't throw wobbly when Danyl was in the bottom two,it happens LOVE,Lucie got the least votes,you need to accept that,chill out it's a TV program,If Danyl goes next week that will be fine,it's a competition isn't it?and I will be happy for anyone who wins it and what had Danyl to do with Lucie going home?or are you going to blame him for that aswell,LOL

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by LemonJam

We can't vote for every ****ing act to make sure John and Edward go, some of us have homes to keep up.

lol!!! that REALLY made me laugh!!!!

[Jordan.]

I agree but from all the stick and hate hes been giving to John and Edward surely he would of sent them home. Anyway im not bothered i didnt really like Lucie

[Jack_]

I have to agree with Tom here.

Simon is a very clever man and he knows what he's doing. This will create so much controversy it's untrue. Ratings will catapult through the roof next week, and so will voting, meaning more cash for Simon.

So while you're all being pissed off at him, he'll be laughing all the way to the bank. Have to hand it to him really.

[Rory]

Originally Posted by kazanne

Oh dear,At least I didn't throw wobbly when Danyl was in the bottom two,it happens LOVE,Lucie got the least votes,you need to accept that,chill out it's a TV program,If Danyl goes next week that will be fine,it's a competition isn't it?and I will be happy for anyone who wins it and what had Danyl to do with Lucie going home?or are you going to blame him for that aswell,LOL

True.

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by kazanne

Why are people blaming Simon for Lucie's demise? Isn't it the public who pick up the phones and vote,J&E and Lucie were in the bottom two,Simon has just explained he didn't think either could win and it was fairer to take it to the public vote,so it'd the PUBLICS fault,the show is for the public to pick winners,If he had got rid of J&E he would have been called for that and vice versa,Blame the public for not voting,If this show had been a straight forward vote with no judges,she would have gone anyway,I also wanted rid of J&E the reason they are still there is down to th PUBLIC.

The public that is the teeny boppers. Their numbers seem to be increasing by the week - either that or they are spending all their pocket money on multiple voting. The meaning of the word talent is unfortunately lost on them. In the future - maybe x-factor should be re-scheduled to CITV/CBBC. It seems they have hijacked the show. Don't think I care much any more.