[M X]

heidi montag, decent? ;O
you can't compare her to britney spears.

[MrGaryy]

blonde. autotuned to hell. album written by some of the biggest producers around. electropop music.

see the connection yet?

[M X]

heidi montag; untalented, face lifts best friend, total wannabee.
britney spears; international icon, princess of pop, 100 million albums sold.

*nods*

[Stu]

That's because Britney has been groomed that way though. So much of it is to do with hype and image. But when you take away all that and get straight down to the music there really is not that much fundamentally different between the two.

[Billy]

Originally Posted by Fom

Can't believe people are sticking up for her as well... seriously, let anyone record something in a studio and shove a bit of auto tune on... and you lot would love it.

Oh stop being such a snob. We aren't sticking up for "her", but her songs aren't any worse than Cheryl Cole, Britney etc.

[MrGaryy]

right so just ignore all the similarities they do have I just stated then. Heidi is just an unsuccessful Britney. neither are particularly talented, neither produce or have any say in the music they release. The only thing separating the two is that Britney has been more successful, which really has **** all to do with it.

[M X]

i 100% disagree. if we want to talk about talent.

Britney live singing

Youtube video

Heidi live singing

Youtube video

[MrGaryy]

pity Britney doesn't sing live then. pity she barely even sings on her records.

[M X]

Originally Posted by MrGaryy

pity Britney doesn't sing live then. pity she barely even sings on her records.

yup, but that's bitchy and irrelevant.

[Billy]

So? Britney doesnt sing live does she? The music she makes could easily be the same tracks that Heidi has on that album. Britney is only superior cos she has a huge label backing her and has been hyped for years.

[M X]

I didn't bring Britney up.

[Billy]

I didn't say you did.

[M X]

Yeah, I know.

[Fom]

To be honest I don't like Britney either... they are all as bad as each other. The only time I have listened to Britney is in a club and that's because its been completely mashed up.

[Arneldo]

Originally Posted by MichaelSpears

yup, but that's bitchy and irrelevant.

This has nothing to do with this topic but I just want to saw:

OMFG, I LOVE YOUR SIG/AV. JOHN-PAUL AND CRAIG 4EVA <3 Hollyoaks has been shite since they left *tear*

*tries to find his old JP sing*



Oh, and Heidi Montag is a talentess hag with the face like Pug dog with botox.

[MarkWaldorf]

Difference is Britney worked to get where she is today and has been through a hell of a lot of **** because of it. Heidi faked her life on a reality show and record deals, magazine shoots and fame was just handed to her because of it.

Britney IS talented. She sings well, she dances well and she also plays the piano and composes despite what some like to think. She may not, vocally, be Mariah Carey but she knows her limits and she has an extremely sweet voice. Anyone who denies that Britney is talented just because of the music style she sticks to is just being petty.

[Jessica.]

[M X]

Mark pretty much summed that up!!

[Billy]

Originally Posted by MarkWaldorf

Difference is Britney worked to get where she is today and has been through a hell of a lot of **** because of it. Heidi faked her life on a reality show and record deals, magazine shoots and fame was just handed to her because of it.

Britney IS talented. She sings well, she dances well and she also plays the piano and composes despite what some like to think. She may not, vocally, be Mariah Carey but she knows her limits and she has an extremely sweet voice. Anyone who denies that Britney is talented just because of the music style she sticks to is just being petty.

Yeah but does any of that have anything to do with what's being said? People are slagging her off and saying oh she's **** etc when she may be, but this kinda stuff could easily be on Britneys album (who I like), and although Britney has all those talents she doesn't always use them, which is fairn enough really.

What's meant in this topic (I think, at least by me anyways) is that people are saying that the album is **** and she's talentless when it's just because it's Heidi, not to do with the music. The music is pretty good, if you like that kinda stuff.

[xDramatick]

I can see the Heidi/Britney comparisons but at least Britney's talented and is a performer/has a contract for a REASON.

Heidi's talentless. She's a complete mockery. Her music can't even be classed as her music, considering they're barely her vocals let alone any artistry. It just has her name on it. There are thousands of other musicians who would kill for, and actually deserve her budget, promotion and the chance of being successful.

Ahh I really, really can't stand her.

[M X]

I do like her kind of music, but honestly, in my opinion Superficial is an awful album. It sounds cheap and she really shows herself to be a wannabee Britney. It's my opnion, and you're entitled to yours.

[setanta]

She should do a cover of I'm a Barbie Girl. State of her. Such a sad illustration of the times we live in.

[mkdfan]

I heard the album online, hated it.

I looove pop music but it just had very dated beats and all the songs sounded the same.

[Simone.]

Originally Posted by mkdfan

I heard the album online, hated it.

I looove pop music but it just had very dated beats and all the songs sounded the same.

I just listened to it on itunes & it's seriously unbearable.
Can't even tell the difference between the songs, It's as if one song is a constant loop.

[Fom]

I do believe Britney has worked for it a lot more and when she was younger she was very talented! Not so much now, but she has earned it!