[johnx]

She's been sittin there lookin dis-interested for last few weeks.Her comments are even duller and more pointless than usual delivered in a simpering fashion.Looks like shes medicated or something-has'nt been the same since since that ridiculous Piers Morgan interview was broadcast.

[KG.]

She's just been full of wind, don't worry though, she released the majority of it on last weeks live show.

[robb]

Originally Posted by johnx

She's been sittin there lookin dis-interested for last few weeks.Her comments are even duller and more pointless than usual delivered in a simpering fashion.Looks like shes medicated or something-has'nt been the same since since that ridiculous Piers Morgan interview was broadcast.

She looks uninterested until Simon speaks to her.........

Her comment about Crocodile Rock star Paije sums her up.....'I'm not familiar with that song, but you sort of made it your own'.....yeah, thanks for that!!

[Mystic Mock]

cheryl only loves it when her sugar daddy talks to her.

[johnx]

Something sinister about the Simon/Cheryl dynamic.She's like his mind controlled puppet.In that Morgan interview she talked about how he could almost read her mind-cos he has her brainwashed.

[johnx]

Originally Posted by robb

She looks uninterested until Simon speaks to her.........

Her comment about Crocodile Rock star Paije sums her up.....'I'm not familiar with that song, but you sort of made it your own'.....yeah, thanks for that!!

Shes a judge on a singing contest and doesnt know a well known song like that-it was hardly frickin obscure.Just cos Will I Am has'nt produced it.As Jay Kay said the other week what do Cheryl and Dani know about music that qualifies them to judge anyone.

[Z]

Originally Posted by johnx

Shes a judge on a singing contest and doesnt know a well known song like that-it was hardly frickin obscure.Just cos Will I Am has'nt produced it.As Jay Kay said the other week what do Cheryl and Dani know about music that qualifies them to judge anyone.

Depends on what you listen to though; I couldn't have named many Elton John songs either to be honest - it was a bit silly of her to admit she wasn't familiar with the song, but personally I'm not judging her for it 'cause I didn't know it either. I still think "Elton John week" was a silly idea, they should stick with the broader themes.

[johnx]

If you want to judge a music talent show dont spend all your time listenin to the black eyed bloody peas and r'n'b.

[Z]

Originally Posted by johnx

If you want to judge a music talent show dont spend all your time listenin to the black eyed bloody peas and r'n'b.

None of them are hired based on their music taste though; they're hired to (well, allegedly) pass judgment on performances based on singing, visually how entertaining they are etc...

[Beastie]

Wise words from Zee.

I didn't mind Elton John week.. however I do agree they should have "broader themes".

Also Louis's comment about Paije singing "Crocodide Rock" he was like "It's from 1971 or something"

Err.. Yeah Louis.. a lot of Elton's songs are old-ish! I thought Paije did a good job!

Also yes.. Dannii would not give Matt "Crocodile Rock" because Paije is the only one who has the "personality" to pull the "fun" songs off!

[johnx]

Originally Posted by Zee

None of them are hired based on their music taste though; they're hired to (well, allegedly) pass judgment on performances based on singing, visually how entertaining they are etc...

Surely your knowledge of music should be above that of your average 14 year old to be a judge.Im not asking for much here-I thought they liked music.Maybe they dont.

[Jordan.]

Ive noticed mainly on Xtra Factor, her and Simon dont even listen to anything Dannii or Louis say they are always having their own little conversations and then last week Cheryl drawing a picture whislt they were taking a call, wtf. It just looks unprofessional.

In the words of Cheryl:

[Z]

Originally Posted by johnx

Surely your knowledge of music should be above that of your average 14 year old to be a judge.Im not asking for much here-I thought they liked music.Maybe they dont.

To be honest, the X Factor is a nearly endless source of disbelief - very little shocks me anymore on the show, I just try to watch it without allowing myself to be bothered now.

[tate]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Ive noticed mainly on Xtra Factor, her and Simon dont even listen to anything Dannii or Louis say they are always having their own little conversations and then last week Cheryl drawing a picture whislt they were taking a call, wtf. It just looks unprofessional.

In the words of Cheryl:

I find that really rude when they do that, ver unprofessional and and so so irritating

unfortunately as she has Cowell in her pocket she no longer needs to show and interest or speak any sense, he will never get rid of her so she can just swing the lead and cash her cheque at the end of it. He doesnt seem interested this year either to me

Louise and Dannii seem to work much harder with their acts and, certainly in Danniis case, provide constructive comments and try and help other artists to improve but unfortunately Cowell will more than likely dispose of her prior to the next series which will further make them 2 the most irritating couple ahead of Adrian Chiles and Christine Bleakley and provide no one to really talk sense and take this serious

[james130]

Get her off.
I do like Cheryl but not as a judge.
Danni and Simon would do for me.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by KG.

She's just been full of wind, don't worry though, she released the majority of it on last weeks live show.

Nope I havnt seen her looking bored!