[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

She wasn't either of those. It's obvious she has the fans, as she's been safe every week apart from that one. She's shown also she can actually be versatile unlike Rebecca.

Cher = jack of all trades master of none

Simple as

[bbfan1991]

Well we've established that whether it's for the good or bad reasons Cher will definetly be remembered more than Rebecca.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

Well we've established that whether it's for the good or bad reasons Cher will definetly be remembered more than Rebecca.

Well Rebecca's gonna be signed and Cher will be back on street corners, so I doubt she will

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well Rebecca's gonna be signed and Cher will be back on street corners, so I doubt she will

There's been at least five people now who said they'd like to work/collarborate with Cher, has anyone said that about Rebecca?

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well Rebecca's gonna be signed and Cher will be back on street corners, so I doubt she will

Funny that when Cher will be getting a record deal, if Rebecca is to last in music then she needs to show more personality IMO.. it's not enough just being a good singer, she's a lovely girl but it's a tough business and you need oomph to last and a bit of attitude.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

There's been at least five people now who said they'd like to work/collarborate with Cher, has anyone said that about Rebecca?

Yep, not only has Simon said, he's sign her in a heartbeat, Nicole Scertzinger (or however the hell you spell her name) has said she would. Adele wrote her a letter saying she'd love to work with her. And pretty much 90% of all ex contestants have said they want her to win, because she's the most talented and so humbling

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Yep, not only has Simon said, he's sign her in a heartbeat, Nicole Scertzinger (or however the hell you spell her name) has said she would. Adele wrote her a letter saying she'd love to work with her. And pretty much 90% of all ex contestants have said they want her to win, because she's the most talented and so humbling

Nicole said she'd like to duet with Cher, and already has it planned So has Tinchy Stryder, Aston from JLS said he's a great fan, and also JLS want to work with her, Jay-Z wants to make her a star, Kate Moss wants to work with her, And Will.I.Am also wants to duet with her. I've seen no-one say Rebecca, Olly thinks it's gonna be a toss up between Cher and Matt... not seen about anyone else

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Rebecca, Matt and Mary doing something up tempo rofl, well atleast they can finally show some sort of versatility finally.

Well at least they will be SINGING and in tune.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

Nicole said she'd like to duet with Cher, and already has it planned So has Tinchy Stryder, Aston from JLS said he's a great fan, and also JLS want to work with her, Jay-Z wants to make her a star, Kate Moss wants to work with her, And Will.I.Am also wants to duet with her. I've seen no-one say Rebecca, Olly thinks it's gonna be a toss up between Cher and Matt... not seen about anyone else

How can she have it planned if she's gonna go out this week f/
Kate Moss is a model, so I really don't see how that would work and that's the Wil.I.Am that's just created one of the worst albums of the decade? Well, that would suit Cher to a tee. And obviously you haven't seen it because you don't look for it.

And I'm pretty sure Olly Murs is moron, who at one point was supporting Wagner, clearly, he's as fickle as you

[bbfan1991]

They will ALL be forgotten by next year anyway.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

Where's the spark of personality?.. i've been waiting all series for it to emerge from her.

Well you can bet your bottom dollar Rebeccas personality is genuine and nice ,what personality has Cher got?lol all I see is an arrogant,jumped up little chav,who thinks she is better than anyone else.

[Boothy]

No personality is better than s**t personality.

Cher is so far up her own arse it's untrue. She'd only inflate her ego by winning the show and probably do herself more harm than good by doing so. Rebecca is more talented than Cher and a nicer person.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by Smithy

How can she have it planned if she's gonna go out this week f/
Kate Moss is a model, so I really don't see how that would work and that's the Wil.I.Am that's just created one of the worst albums of the decade? Well, that would suit Cher to a tee. And obviously you haven't seen it because you don't look for it.

And I'm pretty sure Olly Murs is moron, who at one point was supporting Wagner, clearly, he's as fickle as you

Why do people ride on comments from other 'celebs' so what if she works with any of them,they are not so hot,lets see her work with REAL artists,LOL

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

How can she have it planned if she's gonna go out this week f/
Kate Moss is a model, so I really don't see how that would work and that's the Wil.I.Am that's just created one of the worst albums of the decade? Well, that would suit Cher to a tee. And obviously you haven't seen it because you don't look for it.

And I'm pretty sure Olly Murs is moron, who at one point was supporting Wagner, clearly, he's as fickle as you

For when she comes out?

She probably wants her in for modelling And Will.I.Am's worked with Cheryl... he's not bad actually, if he wanted to work with Rebecca you'd be praising him, and I don't really want to look for anything to do with her..

He came 2nd, he's obviously talented, and knows what he's on about..

I didn't even support Wagner LOL but yeah.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Boothy

No personality is better than s**t personality.

Cher is so far up her own arse it's untrue. She'd only inflate her ego by winning the show and probably do herself more harm than good by doing so. Rebecca is more talented than Cher and a nicer person.

We don't really know the contestants and can only mind our minds up about what we see on some VT?. I know some love to portray Cher as scum of the earth but she isn't...

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

For when she comes out?

She probably wants her in for modelling And Will.I.Am's worked with Cheryl... he's not bad actually, if he wanted to work with Rebecca you'd be praising him, and I don't really want to look for anything to do with her..

He came 2nd, he's obviously talented, and knows what he's on about..

I didn't even support Wagner LOL but yeah.

Yes, you know, like out of the competition this week, seeing as she isn't going to make the final

Will.I.Am worked with Cheryl on her past two albums and both of the songs he worked on her with were completely atrocious. And I wouldn't Will.I.Am has 0 talent he just leaches off the new thing which morons are chirping about.

I didn't say you supported Wagner, I was implying you were fickle

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

We don't really know the contestants and can only mind our minds up about what we see on some VT?. I know some love to portray Cher as scum of the earth but she isn't...

Yet you can do the exact same thing to Rebecca saying she has no personality? Umm Hypocrite much?

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

Well we've established that whether it's for the good or bad reasons Cher will definetly be remembered more than Rebecca.

Depends on what she is remembered for.

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Yes, you know, like out of the competition this week, seeing as she isn't going to make the final

Will.I.Am worked with Cheryl on her past two albums and both of the songs he worked on her with were completely atrocious. And I wouldn't Will.I.Am has 0 talent he just leaches off the new thing which morons are chirping about.

I didn't say you supported Wagner, I was implying you were fickle

If you say so We'll see.

I thought she'd not done bad with them anyway so...

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Yes, you know, like out of the competition this week, seeing as she isn't going to make the final

Will.I.Am worked with Cheryl on her past two albums and both of the songs he worked on her with were completely atrocious. And I wouldn't Will.I.Am has 0 talent he just leaches off the new thing which morons are chirping about.

I didn't say you supported Wagner, I was implying you were fickle


Yet you can do the exact same thing to Rebecca saying she has no personality? Umm Hypocrite much?

Everyone are hypocrites in someway whether it's defending their favourite act or criticising those who they aren't so keen on or like but wish they would do something else it's the way it goes.. i'm a football fan and we're fickle all the time and in shows like this the same rule applies my friend.

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by kazanne

Well at least they will be SINGING and in tune.

Cher does sing in tune so thats just stupid and even if she didn't atleast she'd be entertaining to watch unlike Matt and Rebecca who i cant even name one song they have sung because they are that forgettable, shows how much singing in tune does for them.

[Z]

Why is it such a bad thing to have a good voice but "no personality"? It's only in the last decade or so in the UK, it seems, where the private lives of celebrities has become just as news-worthy as their careers. Rebecca's personality comes across in the intro videos before her performance, at least it does to me, she's a kind girl who has a good sense of humour and hasn't a bad bone in her body. Cher's personality seems to be more of a talking point because she's very ambitious and determined to the point where some people find her annoying; in my opinion that should be viewed as a negative point - the fact that her personality is being judged just as much as, if not more than, her singing. I feel sorry for Cher, more than anything, the fact that her personality has been put on such a pedestal has ruined her chances of winning to an extent, whereas Rebecca, who has kept her head down and just performed, stands a much better chance of winning because she's not made herself into a target.


Anyway, as for the theme change, thank God for that - I was getting bored of seeing Mary and Rebecca do nothing but sing, and I was getting bored of seeing Cher jump around the stage. At least One Direction can't stand on a platform for both performances and actually have to do something in their other performance!

[cub]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

PS Mary has confirmed she will be singing Barbara Streisand's The Way We Were.

The Shirley Bassey version I suppose ....