[Tom.]

I could see the logic when there were 5 but not when three. Jason is a dancer and Robin a skater, whilst ice dancer Karen is practically sat in the audience whos sole purpose appears to be to argue with Jason

[Mystic Mock]

emma is a judge because people like her as a person (including myself) but she shouldnt be a judge on dancing on ice imo.

[arista]

Originally Posted by Tom.

I could see the logic when there were 5 but not when three. Jason is a dancer and Robin a skater, whilst ice dancer Karen is practically sat in the audience whos sole purpose appears to be to argue with Jason

Thats simple
half the cost
Tom


Sign Of The Times.

[Conzors]

Jason has the dancing background (the DANCING), Robin and Karen have the ice background (the ON ICE) bit, so the judging panel is pretty full, they need one more to make it a reasonable judging panel. Emma has the Entertainment background, so i can see why they chose her. Shes a good judge though imo.

[cub]

It's the consolation prize for never getting the X Factor.

[essexash]

I like Emma herself but shes terrible on this as a judge

[GypsyGoth]

I think she is there because she is famous and pretty.

[Stacey.]

I don't know, I don't even know what she has to do with ice dancing. :s

Don't like her as a person though, or as a judge.

[reece(:]

she shouldn't be there karen shouldbe the female judge
just cos they need a woman shes there and cheap i bet too

[Shaun]

'cos she woz a spice girl init