[AndyEssex1]

Diana Vickers - constantly compared to the singing style of Janet Devlin also finished 5th in 2008. She's doing ok, and more importantly is independent from Syco and is not given songs to sing. She writes them.

Nobody expects Michael Buble to sing rock or Queen songs, yet his style has made him the sort of superstar that Cowell would love to get his hands on.

Janet will do well. Nobody will finance Alexandra's 2nd CD because they're not that interested in her. She's just a TV personality now. If Misha makes an album, it won't be as successful as Alexandra's because the show was at it's peak in 2008, and Misha hasn't got the personality to fall back on for TV work.

Olly isn't a great pop star, but the X Factor is producing some very good, young TV talent. Alesha Dixon another example. Olly is very good with Caroline on the Xtra Factor though.

[Adamw92]

Originally Posted by AndyEssex1

Diana Vickers - constantly compared to the singing style of Janet Devlin also finished 5th in 2008.

Diana finished 4th, not 5th.

[Niamh.]

I much prefer Janet to Diana, she has a far better voice imo

[Adamw92]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

I much prefer Janet to Diana, she has a far better voice imo

I love both but if I had to choose I'd have to say Diana for me but I just love Janet's voice, can't wait for her album!

[robb]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

I much prefer Janet to Diana, she has a far better voice imo

I think Diana was more style over the music. JANET IS THE OTHER WAY AROUND, which is why I much prefer her. There are some similarities to their voice. I just couldn't imagine Diana now singing Chasing Cars or anything by the RHCP. IF ONLY janet had sung these type of songs in the midst of the show, when the judges started to turn against her and her 'form' started to stagnate..... still, she may well have a future, if her fanbase sticks with her....