[Wildcat!]

I think she is an awful mentor so far. SHe has picked realy dreadful songs for her acts in my opinion, but I was actually expecting her to be pretty gppd with groups.

Maybe she will get better in time. But I have to say, first impressions.

[Marsh.]

I'm surprised the angle she's gone for with some of the songs. I thought she'd be better than the mindless pap and try something different. But I guess the X Factor moulds all of them into bland carbone copies of everything before. Even Gary has chosen some cliche and standard songs. But I think he made the wrong choice of acts anyway.

Kelly is the only one that's tried doing something interesting with her acts. Not a fan of the rapping but she has by far got the best category.

The less said about Louis the better.

[Wildcat!]

OK my bad, her last act was alright!

[Vicky.]

Who in their right mind would take advice from someone who churns out the absolute CRAP that N-Dubs bring out anyways

[Locke.]

She is responsible for the greatest creation in X Factor history - The Risk

[Jords]

wtf! Shes the best judge and mentor so far! From the VT clips you can really tell shes put everything into it.

The only exception is 2 Shoes which was a poor song choice, but hey nobody gets everything bang on.

[Jordan.]

Kelly and Louis made far worse song choices.

[MusicXian]

The risk are great.