[Kate!]

Which of these Tibbers would you pick for the Judges Panel on X Factor?

Pick FOUR only, and give reasons

Wait for the poll.....

[Jake.]

You best include me..............

[Raph]

Oh this sounds cool - interested to see who you'll put as the options!

[Locke.]

Mollie reminds me an awful lot of a female Louis Walsh

[Jordan.]

Patrick... "FFS can we keep Katy Perry songs on Now 67"

[Raph]

I went for

Seat 1 - Locke. The one who's opinion is hard to change and who's quite critical of the contestants, but is really complimentary of his own acts.
Seat 2 - Munchkins. The really nice and pretty one, that everybody hears talk and says 'aw'. Always defending the contestants.
Seat 3 - Mollie. The nice one that gives good constructive criticism and knows a lot. The one that most people want to mentor them.
Seat 4 - Karl. The funny one that doesn't always make sense but is loved by the public nonetheless. THe one that's most likely to pick the obscure acts like Wagner

[Munchkins]

Originally Posted by Raph

I went for

Seat 1 - Locke. The one who's opinion is hard to change and who's quite critical of the contestants, but is really complimentary of his own acts.
Seat 2 - Munchkins. The really nice and pretty one, that everybody hears talk and says 'aw'. Always defending the contestants.
Seat 3 - Mollie. The nice one that gives good constructive criticism and knows a lot. The one that most people want to mentor them.
Seat 4 - Karl. The funny one that doesn't always make sense but is loved by the public nonetheless. THe one that's most likely to pick the obscure acts like Wagner

Yay Raph
me and Mollie would totally take down the other mentos groups

[Raph]

Originally Posted by Munchkins

Yay Raph
me and Mollie would totally take down the other mentos groups

Yeah buddy!

[Vanessa]

I'm far too soft to be a judge. I'd be the nice, quiet one. Like Leona Lewis was when she guest judged!

[Brother Leon]

Not me as there would be a show of about 4 finalists

[Z]

Simon seat - Shaun - the music critic who isn't impressed very easily, is also very knowledgable about everything ever.
Cheryl seat - Ninastar - loves pop music, is also probably shagging Shaun behind the scenes in between nice comments.
Dannii seat - Mollie - always has balanced opinions, has fierce hair
Louis seat - MrLuvaLuva - has nothing in common with Louis Walsh and actually knows a lot about music unlike Louis Walsh, I wish he'd replace the real Louis Walsh on the show.

[Marc]

I voted myself because I've seen every series and know what to look for.
Karl - because somebody has to be the irish one
Ninastar - young lesbian girl, will be able to supply the sexy females who end up losing out early on.
Lee - mature lady who can have the overs category every year, she knows what to look for sexy male wise.

[Raph]

"somebody has to be Irish one" - Ha ha that made me laugh Marc! Even better then, that I put him in the Louis Walsh chair, didn't even think about Karl being Irish.

[Shaun]

went for myself because gurrrrrrrrl
Dezzy - the sassy black judge who disappears every other series to film her reality TV show. Is known for her catchphrase "I ain't got time for that!" and for throwing a frappucino over Cher Lloyd
GypsyGoth - the encouraging, friendly judge who everyone wants to mentor them. Has penned some fantastic Finnish pop hits and is arguably the most successful of the panel.
Vanessa - the Italian temptress who has to fan her vagina every time a boyband finishes performing. Has been known to run on stage and grab crotches.

[joeysteele]

From those on the list I have chosen,
Kate,Niamh, InOne and Shaun.

Kate, because she would tell it as she saw it,with fairness being her guide though.

Niamh, because she has good taste and sees the good sides to acts like Jedward too, allowing the fun element to be part of X Factor.

InOne,because he loves Oasis and therefore his view of groups and singers must carry great weight.

Shaun, because he seems to like and know a great deal about music from all decades and genres,he would therefore be able to pick out the very best of the acts.

[Jake.]

Kate we are no longer on talking terms

[Marc]

Claudia would be the worst judge. I'm not being mean but if she was a judge they'd be about 400 acts at bootcamp

or is there a secret side to her that we have yet to see do you like to make people cry claudia..

[Shaun]

thanks joey

[Mystic Mock]

Mollie - the likeable and quirky judge.
Munchkins - the one that goes where it hurts.
Scott - the Louis Walsh type figure where he would get the clown acts.
Dezzy - i've always thought that he would make a great Simon Cowell like figure.

[reece(:]

Scott - Louis
Adele Wigglesworthit - Sharon
Locke - Simon
Mollie - Cheryl/Danni/Tulisa

[LemonJam]

arista - no explanation needed.
Dezzy - Because one of the judges needs to do a fabulous "Bad Ramen" lip-sync in the live shows.
GypsyGoth - She'd give everyone a "yes ^_^"
Karl - He'd pull a whitey during the K-Pop week and chunder during Doogle's rendition of bubblePOP.

[Doogle]

No one would chunder during my version of Bubble Pop, I'd top the votes

[Benjamin]

Myself, Shaun, Josy and GypsyGoth. We all have huge varied music tastes.

[lostalex]

the fact that i'm not even an option just proves that i'd be the best judge, cause you're all scared as fook of me.

Alex
Livia
Marc

we'd be the best judges.

[michael21]

Originally Posted by *Kate*

Which of these Tibbers would you pick for the Judges Panel on X Factor?

Pick FOUR only, and give reasons

Wait for the poll.....

#