[InOne]

Originally Posted by JH95

I do love him, but a bit ironic considering that his music appeals more to the older generation than younger.

A number 1 album and world tour says differently I think

[Jake.]

I'm not saying that his music appeals to 70 year olds only, I'm 17 and I'm a huge fan I'm just saying that I don't find the need to continuosly slagging off other artists (and it always seems to be those that are doing well)

[Iceman]

Originally Posted by JH95

I'm not saying that his music appeals to 70 year olds only, I'm 17 and I'm a huge fan I'm just saying that I don't find the need to continuosly slagging off other artists (and it always seems to be those that are doing well)

Most of the time though it's the press asking him about the other artists, he's bound to get pissed about it and slag them off..

[InOne]

Well at least he says what he thinks, he's always said if he's asked a question he'd answer it honestly.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Iceman

Most of the time though it's the press asking him about the other artists, he's bound to get pissed about it and slag them off..

And yes, this.

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Iceman

Most of the time though it's the press asking him about the other artists, he's bound to get pissed about it and slag them off..

Originally Posted by InOne

Well at least he says what he thinks, he's always said if he's asked a question he'd answer it honestly.

Yeah, both good points

[InOne]

Just saw this: http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage...n-twitter.html

[Livia]

So long as he makes himself feel better at the expense of another artist, he's happy I guess. I'm no fan of Emeli Sande but the slating she got from Noel is, I suppose, to be expected from him now. He's had people kissing his arse for a couple of decades and no one big enough to tell him he's wrong. I'd have liked him and his brother more if they weren't such an insuffereable, ignorant pair of ****s.

[Raph]

well well this man is talking a lot of sense right here

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Livia

So long as he makes himself feel better at the expense of another artist, he's happy I guess. I'm no fan of Emeli Sande but the slating she got from Noel is, I suppose, to be expected from him now. He's had people kissing his arse for a couple of decades and no one big enough to tell him he's wrong. I'd have liked him and his brother more if they weren't such an insuffereable, ignorant pair of ****s.

Noel is never wrong Livia

[Livia]

Originally Posted by InOne

Well at least he says what he thinks, he's always said if he's asked a question he'd answer it honestly.

Always best to engage the clutch of tact though. Just because you can say it doesn't mean you should. Everyone over the age of 10 knows that, surely.

Love Sande's comeback though LOL...

[Livia]

Originally Posted by InOne

Noel is never wrong Livia

I'm sure he believes that, and that's why he's such a gobsh1te.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Livia

Always best to engage the clutch of tact though. Just because you can say it doesn't mean you should. Everyone over the age of 10 knows that, surely.

Love Sande's comeback though LOL...

Why shouldn't he say what he thinks though? It's because we've got all these nicey nice artists that British music is in such a state. You only have to look at this years Brits to see that.

Noel is one of the biggest supporters of up and coming bands. He's said some stuff in the past about various bands but he's had his fair share of people slagging him off.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by InOne

Why shouldn't he say what he thinks though? It's because we've got all these nicey nice artists that British music is in such a state. You only have to look at this years Brits to see that.

Noel is one of the biggest supporters of up and coming bands. He's said some stuff in the past about various bands but he's had his fair share of people slagging him off.

I'll tell you why... because if someone asks another artist what they think of Noel Gallagher and they answer honestly, all bloody hell breaks loose. He can be honest and say it's not his thing and he doesn't really warm to it, but no... he's got to be the rock and roll rebel . He's done it for too long now and to be honest, it's been done better.

Noel supports bands who play music like his own. Anything else is crap to him. He can't accept that just because he doesn't like it, doesn't necessarily mean it's crap, and that everyone who does like it is a moron.

If I wanted to listen to Oasis in their purest form, I'd cut out the middle man and listen to the Beatles.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Livia

I'll tell you why... because if someone asks another artist what they think of Noel Gallagher and they answer honestly, all bloody hell breaks loose. He can be honest and say it's not his thing and he doesn't really warm to it, but no... he's got to be the rock and roll rebel . He's done it for too long now and to be honest, it's been done better.

Noel supports bands who play music like his own. Anything else is crap to him. He can't accept that just because he doesn't like it, doesn't necessarily mean it's crap, and that everyone who does like it is a moron.

If I wanted to listen to Oasis in their purest form, I'd cut out the middle man and listen to the Beatles.

When has hell ever broken loose? LOL He's takes it on this chin and doesn't even care. And it's good he's a rock and roll rebel, we need more people like him in the industry. But to be fair, there was nothing rock and roll or rebelious about what he said, he was just being honest. He didn't insult them personally or anything, just the music.

He's into a fair bit of music but if you like and know a certain genre you're best off sticking with it. He'd be no good helping an up and coming rapper out would he because he knows nothing of the genre.

And Livia, I can't believe you used that old line LOL The only song of Oasis that sounds anything like The Beatles is 'Whatever'. They're much more influenced by The Stone Roses.

You're not one of those who hates the Gallaghers because of what they said about Nirvana are you?

[Shaun]

Originally Posted by Livia

Love Sande's comeback though LOL...

you would, grandma

[Shaun]

and joe there're more than Whatever to be fair Don't Look Back in Anger and its Imagine intro is a good example. (I don't mind though... it's an obvious inspiration but not exactly one to be frowned upon)

[Livia]

Originally Posted by InOne

When has hell ever broken loose? LOL He's takes it on this chin and doesn't even care. And it's good he's a rock and roll rebel, we need more people like him in the industry. But to be fair, there was nothing rock and roll or rebelious about what he said, he was just being honest. He didn't insult them personally or anything, just the music.

He's into a fair bit of music but if you like and know a certain genre you're best off sticking with it. He'd be no good helping an up and coming rapper out would he because he knows nothing of the genre.

And Livia, I can't believe you used that old line LOL The only song of Oasis that sounds anything like The Beatles is 'Whatever'. They're much more influenced by The Stone Roses.

You're not one of those who hates the Gallaghers because of what they said about Nirvana are you?

Oh yeah, the Gallaghers are very laid back when someone cricitises him, I've noticed that about them...............

I'm not suggesting he should be helping out people in other genres, just that he should be a little more respectful of people who aren't in his particular genre.

No, I don't dislike the Gallaghers because of what they said about Nirvana. I dislike them because I find them rude and aggresive, and musically they are at best, a mediocre Beatles tribute band with three or four decent original tunes to their name. Lots of their tracks are beatles inspired (obviously). It makes me laugh that while they're ripping off the Beatles, fans call it "paying tribute".

You hate me now, don't you LOL...

[Livia]

Originally Posted by Shaun

you would, grandma

Yeah... I already said I'm not a fan.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Livia

Oh yeah, the Gallaghers are very laid back when someone cricitises him, I've noticed that about them...............

I'm not suggesting he should be helping out people in other genres, just that he should be a little more respectful of people who aren't in his particular genre.

No, I don't dislike the Gallaghers because of what they said about Nirvana. I dislike them because I find them rude and aggresive, and musically they are at best, a mediocre Beatles tribute band with three or four decent original tunes to their name. Lots of their tracks are beatles inspired (obviously). It makes me laugh that while they're ripping off the Beatles, fans call it "paying tribute".

You hate me now, don't you LOL...

In recent memory the last proper feud they had was with Robbie Williams who's a twat anyway. And Liam finished that one at the Q awards in 2005.

But if he's asked to comment on British music there's no point in him sugar coating it. It's just his opinion and he always likes to word things in a way so they're more entertaining.

As I said, they're more Stone Roses influenced and they had the piano from Imagine and a few odd lines here and there but that's it.

I don't hate you LOL but the whole Beatles thing is a tired lazy argument that doesn't really have much basis I'm afraid.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by InOne

In recent memory the last proper feud they had was with Robbie Williams who's a twat anyway. And Liam finished that one at the Q awards in 2005.

But if he's asked to comment on British music there's no point in him sugar coating it. It's just his opinion and he always likes to word things in a way so they're more entertaining.

As I said, they're more Stone Roses influenced and they had the piano from Imagine and a few odd lines here and there but that's it.

I don't hate you LOL but the whole Beatles thing is a tired lazy argument that doesn't really have much basis I'm afraid.

I notice that Oasis fans get rather touchy when someone makes the all-too-obvious Beatles comparison. Of course, calling it a tired argument doesn't mean it isn't true.

Robbie Williams is a twat though, that's something we can agree on.

Now... stop disagreeing with me or I will pop up and give you a Chinese burn.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Shaun

and joe there're more than Whatever to be fair Don't Look Back in Anger and its Imagine intro is a good example. (I don't mind though... it's an obvious inspiration but not exactly one to be frowned upon)

Yeah I remembered them as I'd just posted my last reply LOL

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Livia

I notice that Oasis fans get rather touchy when someone makes the all-too-obvious Beatles comparison. Of course, calling it a tired argument doesn't mean it isn't true.

Robbie Williams is a twat though, that's something we can agree on.

Now... stop disagreeing with me or I will pop up and give you a Chinese burn.

There's some there, but they were very much their own band. Everyone recognised the Oasis sound as the whole Beatles comparison was years ago when they were saying they wanted to be bigger than The Beatles and all that. There will never be another band that made in impact Oasis did to youth culture. Arctic Monkey's have come the closest. And I'm not being touchy, just realistic

I'm afraid Livia I can't agree with you, and no amount of violence will change my mind

[Shaun]

robbie williams is amazing excuse me

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Shaun

robbie williams is amazing excuse me

We need Laura in here to write a 10,000 word essay on why he's not LOL