[just thinkin]

So they could change the scenario question depending on who had what amount to keep who they wanted. Envelopes should have been identical so they couldn't change the question to save who they wanted......

[Withano]

Interesting theory... Could easily be true

[Carnoch04]

How do you imagine they would have changed it though? Sam was toast either way.

[Gusto Brunt]

They should have had the names on the envelopes.

[Mullens123]

I thought this too. Like maybe had Jack/Chloe taken it then they'd have said "whoever you vote out will take this from the prize fund"... meaning Sam once again would go.

[just thinkin]

They had different questions prepared depending on who too which amount...if jack had the 15000 they would probably say it would have been deducted rather than added... if it was fair...they should have had aame colour envelopes.

[Transgenderqueen]

Very interesting theory, wish we had a mole from channel 5 or something. Wonder what Twitter is saying about it?

[Beetlejuice]

Originally Posted by just thinkin

So they could change the scenario question depending on who had what amount to keep who they wanted. Envelopes should have been identical so they couldn't change the question to save who they wanted......

Yep, you're absolutely 100% spot on. The whole twist was about getting Sam out.

[Mullens123]

Originally Posted by Transgenderqueen

Very interesting theory, wish we had a mole from channel 5 or something. Wonder what Twitter is saying about it?

I don't remember what site it was on... but there was someone who someone knew inside info into BBUK and the production (they gave proof somehow). They claimed that all twists are pre-planned and aren't made up on the spot. I personally don't believe it but... maybe you will? They said the same kind of bs C5 give when they say "the show is moving in a new direction" and how audiences are always changing.

[Vicky.]

I have no doubts that if Chloe/Jack were chosen to go (never going to happen...even if they had the highest..) there would have been a further twist where they got the chance to snatch the entire prize fund. To advertise this as something that would rock the house or whatever was a ****ing joke.

[ItWasJustBanter]

Probably sexist envelopes or something.

[Northern Monkey]

Cool story

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by just thinkin

So they could change the scenario question depending on who had what amount to keep who they wanted. Envelopes should have been identical so they couldn't change the question to save who they wanted......

The problem with this theory is that Big Brother asked the housemates to open the envelopes BEFORE BB asked the housemates anything.

So the envelopes wouldn't need to be colour coded if there were different question options. They all revealed the amount inside beforehand anyway.

[bitontheslide]

they could have cut the conspiracy theories by announcing to the public what was going to happen before the event - they didnt

[Beetlejuice]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

The problem with this theory is that Big Brother asked the housemates to open the envelopes BEFORE BB asked the housemates anything.

Yes, but they knew who had what because they knew the colour codes.

So the envelopes wouldn't need to be colour coded if there were different question options. They all revealed the amount inside beforehand anyway.

Yes but they decided which question to ask depending on who had which colour.

[just thinkin]

Marsh....the reason they asked that particular question AFTER they had the envelopes was because they knew wot each person had in the envelopes....it was a failsafe method to keep who the wanted.

[just thinkin]

They should have posed the qiestion....had identical envelopes and then told them to open...no colour coding......its so obvious what they are playin at

[Ashley.]

Jack would've taken the Blue one because he's a football-mad boys' boy, and Chloe would've taken the Red/Pink one because she's a girly girl. It's psychology.

What colour did Sam pick?

[Jamie89]

Brilliant point OP

Everyone involved in the twist will have known that Sam would be the target, in fact Emma just said on BOTS that she thinks it would have been Sam regardless of her amount. But I think if Sam had picked the Ł1000, the scenario given to the HM's would have been "whoever you evict, their amount will be deducted from the prize fund", just to help the HM's make the decision that the producers wanted.

I'm not normally one for conspiracy theories but you're right, there was absolutely no need for the envelopes to be colour coded and if memory serves, it's extremely unusual for this to be the case.

[Transgenderqueen]

Originally Posted by Beetlejuice

Yep, you're absolutely 100% spot on. The whole twist was about getting Sam out.

What was the point though? She was never going to win. Or do u mean to save the other 2? I feel really bad for her

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Beetlejuice

Yes, but they knew who had what because they knew the colour codes.



Yes but they decided which question to ask depending on who had which colour.

But, again, listen to what I'm saying...

They wouldn't need to be colour coded to know the contents because BB asked them to reveal what they had BEFORE asking the housemates a question.

So if they had different questions based on who had what amount they wouldn't need the different colours.

[Transgenderqueen]

Originally Posted by just thinkin

They should have posed the qiestion....had identical envelopes and then told them to open...no colour coding......its so obvious what they are playin at

They would always have chose poor Sam though

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by just thinkin

Marsh....the reason they asked that particular question AFTER they had the envelopes was because they knew wot each person had in the envelopes....it was a failsafe method to keep who the wanted.

BUT they opened the envelopes BEFORE anyway therefore a colour code would not be needed in this conspiracy theory.

[Lampfan]

We Scots are a sucker for blue. When I saw her grab it I had a feeling it would land her in bother.

[just thinkin]

Marsh..by them picking colours it gave them a chance to pick the question accordingly...if the had plain envelopes...asked the question and had them open the plain envelopes that wud have been fair..once the picked tge coloured ones they needent have even bothered openong then as the producers knew what was in tgem before they opened them at all....cant you see that. .gave tgem a chance to pick tge apropriate question and bought them time