[Mike]

Do you think Shilpa would have still won the show if she hadn't been involved in the whole bullying issue?

[spitfire]

no chance.

[Ruth*Star]

imo i think she could have.

[Dan_]

I think it would have been closer but she would have still won as she already had a big fanbase and that was already growing even before the bullying.

[Sasha]

I never voted her out of sympathy

[Blink_Me]

She would have won without all the Jade business. It was obvious she was going to win from the early stages.

[Siouxsie]

sympathy vote

[andybigbro]

YES SHE HAD TONS OF SUPPORT BEFORE THE INCIDENT

[Jay]

I think it would of been close or she would of finished second, but after what she's been threw im not arguing that she won.

[Siouxsie]

Well as Jade would say Good for you good for you

[MarkWaldorf]

Maybe.

[Crazy4Shilpa]

I would say no, but not because of the sympathy vote, but because she is not a known celebrity in england.

[SiMoN!]

No way, it's the sympathy vote

[Razmataz]

Sympathy vote...haha maybe we should flog a few emo's in there.

[Siouxsie]

Originally posted by SiMoN!
No way, it's the sympathy vote

deffo

[on_mercury]

Anyone who says it wasnt a sympathy vote are in denial.

[MarkWaldorf]

Originally posted by on_mercury
Anyone who says it wasnt a sympathy vote are in denial.

[Dan_]

Originally posted by on_mercury
Anyone who says it wasnt a sympathy vote are in denial.

Would Jermaine have won instead then?I don't think so.She already had fans before it.

Funny how most the people who don't like her keeping saying it's the sympathy vote like she was not a fave beforehand.

[Crazy4Shilpa]

she had the most members in her fanclub on this forum even before the whole bullying thing.

[InTheHood]

She would have made the top 2 at least.

It was between Shilpa and Jermaine and it may have been closer.

[Corkie]

I'm not sure as without the bullying issue she might have not won as that made her known to generally be a kind and forgiving person but without she would have still made good entertainment I think

[BB-Rocks]

Well i think it would have been a two horse race with both her and Jermaine

[abs]

Originally posted by Mike
Do you think Shilpa would have still won the show if she hadn't been involved in the whole bullying issue?

we will never know will we!!!

[Slezer]

Perhaps not, but if anybody had gone through what she did they wouldnt have handled it as well.

[Princess]

Not sure. She was a brill housemate but the whole being diginifed throughout it all and not lowering herself to their level showed us how amazing she is.