[BB-Rocks]

Who do you think is better at singing this song?

Leona or Shayne?

Leona:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=QLr1sBQ5gpE

Shayne:
http://youtube.com/watch?v=kXiQeRxgxgo

[Chrizzle]

Both were good, but Leona was miles better!

[MarkWaldorf]

Leona x10000000

[Arneldo]

Shayne

[Lance]

Neither did justice to the original song.

I loved how the judges praised Shayne's version, how he did it.... they all pointed out how unique he made it.

Although, it was copied note by note from another performance of a US male (who's name is eluding me at the moment).

And Leona's was just a poor immitation of Eva Cassidy's classic.

[tinkerbell]

Shayne is poo! i dont know why he won, maybe because the little 10 year olds liked his looks.

[ttw]

EVA CASSIDY

[Dan_]

Originally posted by tinkerbell
Shayne is poo! i dont know why he won, maybe because the little 10 year olds liked his looks.

He's technically a pretty good singer, people might not like his style but he can still sing well.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by BB fernzy

He's technically a pretty good singer, people might not like his style but he can still sing well.

He's got a very impressive falsetto.

[Crystal-Rose]

Leona

[SiMoN!]

Shayne by a mile for me

[stacey]

i think leona was way better

[Ruth*Star]

Leona! but shayne was okay at it. i can understand why shayne won, he has talent, but leona has more talent than he has.

[andybigbro]

Shayne Ward

[Kaz]

Originally posted by Lance
Neither did justice to the original song.

I loved how the judges praised Shayne's version, how he did it.... they all pointed out how unique he made it.

Although, it was copied note by note from another performance of a US male (who's name is eluding me at the moment).

And Leona's was just a poor immitation of Eva Cassidy's classic.

An identical copy of Josh Groban's version, Lance.

And I agree ........ Eva Cassidy's version is just sublime.

[CassetteFinger]

Leona of course she is 200000% better than shayne ward but i think Eva Cassidy is the best.

[dupin]

Originally posted by GiRTh

He's got a very impressive falsetto.

My sister was obsessed with opera/singing techniques at the time of the series, and she pointed out that, actually, he had an awful falsetto, technically.

[Sam]

I love Leona's version but I still remember when Shayne sang it in the final i was like 'WOW'

[Tom4784]

I loved Leona's version and hopes she includes a version in her album!

[Billy]

Leonaa, I didnt like Shayne. Maria should have won that year