[Amy Jade]

Originally Posted by sampvt

no comment, not worth the hassle.

You know you are wrong more like.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by sampvt

no comment, not worth the hassle.

Thanks for letting me know I'm right.

[Slevin]

Originally Posted by pontyboi

"he started it" seriously? That's the most childish response ive ever heard. It's not a coincidence you seem to have a lot of arguments with people on here. Finally ofcourse were allowed to defend our favs on here that's why it's called a forum to discuss so then why contradict this with asking mods to close the thread?

It's petty.

some of us dont take too kindly to logic around here

[sampvt]

fook me, im off, dont need another shower.

[reece(:]

The factual evidence hurts it seems

[Jessica.]

I think this is a bit clearer.

[armand.kay]

Originally Posted by Jessica.

I think this is a bit clearer.

oh so its concluded she did swing, and would you look at that right near her eye.

[armand.kay]

And it looks like charlotte pushed her away after she hit hanna. Makes me wonder.

[Jessica.]

Originally Posted by armand.kay

And it looks like charlotte pushed her away after she hit hanna. Makes me wonder.

Yeah, I was thinking that, but I don't really want to make that much of an assumption since she wasn't fully in view like Ellies hit.

[parmnion]

Originally Posted by Jessica.

I just made this, you can see the impact.



her arm hits her, she moves her arm back and then puts it out again in a defensive manner on the railings.

Hannah was lucky charlotte was pushing ellie back or that butchers arm coulda knocked her out.

[rusticgal]

IT looks to me like Ellie moved her right foot to the lower step and lost her balance...as she slung her right arm out to grab onto something she caught Hannah then proceeded to grab the railings.
I don't think it was deliberate at all...

[rusticgal]

Originally Posted by armand.kay

And it looks like charlotte pushed her away after she hit hanna. Makes me wonder.

As I have just said I think Ellie lost her balance..swung her right arm out to grab the railings and caught Hannah before grabbing the rail. Ellie's left arm is around Charlottes neck and she pulled her with her as she lost her balance. Charlotte did not push her away.

[Jessica.]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

IT looks to me like Ellie moved her right foot to the lower step and lost her balance...as she slung her right arm out to grab onto something she caught Hannah then proceeded to grab the railings.
I don't think it was deliberate at all...

I don't think anyone said Ellie tried to punch her directly in the face, but she was being confrontational and reckless, so someone getting hit was a result of that. She was also begging for a physical confrontation by shouting "hit me", which means she wouldn't have been opposed to having an actual fight. I think they both ended up looking bad but Ellie definitely did make contact with a face which people are denying.

[Northern Monkey]

So who hits Hannah in the eye?I'm sure I remember her saying she was hit in the eye?That seems like it would be a different incident.

[Mullens123]

Originally Posted by Epic.

Even if it was accidental, I still ultimately blame Ellie for not hearing out Hannah's claim and instead just denying denying denying and her not at least getting a talking to for this hit, albeit accidental, slightly aggravates me

preach

[armand.kay]

Originally Posted by Northern Monkey

So who hits Hannah in the eye?I'm sure I remember her saying she was hit in the eye?That seems like it would be a different incident.

[Kazanne]

I am sure if Ellie had hit anyone BB would have removed her,you can't tell for certain from that gif.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

I am sure if Ellie had hit anyone BB would have removed her,you can't tell for certain from that gif.

Not if it wasn't deliberate, it looks accidental to me so the producers may have interpreted it that way

tbh though with the incompetence of this production team it wouldn't even surprise me if they didn't bother to review the tape, just warn the people who were most obviously aggressive (Deborah and Lotan)

[parmnion]

Looking at it again it looks like ellie is trying to yank hannah out the way to get at debs....foolish girl.

[parmnion]

And everone is focused on ellie the aggressor..no one seems bothered or wary of debs.

[rusticgal]

Originally Posted by Jessica.

I don't think anyone said Ellie tried to punch her directly in the face, but she was being confrontational and reckless, so someone getting hit was a result of that. She was also begging for a physical confrontation by shouting "hit me", which means she wouldn't have been opposed to having an actual fight. I think they both ended up looking bad but Ellie definitely did make contact with a face which people are denying.

I never implied punching in the face either. Ellie and Charlotte were trying to stop the sisters getting up the stairs because the were trying to get to Lotan in a very aggressive way.
It was a bit of a mess but it looks like Ellie lost her balance and yes she did make contact but it looks accidental...not deliberate.
Let's not forget who the aggressors were on those steps...it was the 2 sisters. Ellie and Charlotte were trying to prevent them running up the stairs..

[Captain.Remy]

The intent was there at least, and it's enough to consider it as a bad move.
Damn, I like Deborah but I so wish she would have dragged this b!tch out and ripped her hair out.

[Jedman]

If ellie hit hannah she deserves it anyway for acting like such a dramatic aggressive twat.