[Lewismacfarlane]

According to the press its
Simon Cowell
Louis Tomlinson
Robbie Williams
Ayda field

[Nicky91]

Ayda to have all of her acts out in the first few liveshows then sorry but she knows nothing about music


whereas i think Robbie can be a good mentor


Louis T for Louis W

[Ryebailey23]

Not true ,..

[Lewismacfarlane]

Originally Posted by Ryebailey23

Not true ,..

Who is judging then

[Ryebailey23]

Originally Posted by Lewismacfarlane

Who is judging then

I have to be tight lipped sorry ..

[Lewismacfarlane]

Originally Posted by Ryebailey23

I have to be tight lipped sorry ..

Something tells me this is true

[Strictly Jake]

I think robbie and ayda will be a duo she just isnt relevant enough to be a solo judge

I dont see why they had to change the panel in the first place

The panel was the only thing they did right last year along with allowing acts to sing their own songs it was the live show format that was a mess

I love sharon and hope its true that she is doing live shows

Louis walsh annoys me but he just should be there

Nicole is actually the hardest working mentor so its a shame they axed her

The panel should be

Simon Cowell
Nicole Scherzinger
Rita Ora
Robbie Williams

With sharon returning as a Wildcard judge in the live shows

[Denver]

I know who the judges are

[Strictly Jake]

Then pm me adam

[Denver]

Nope they will be revealed in the coming days

[Lewismacfarlane]

Originally Posted by Adam.

Nope they will be revealed in the coming days

You can tell me I won't say anything

[Denver]

Or you can be patient

[Lewismacfarlane]

Originally Posted by Adam.

Or you can be patient

What I do want to know is when will the panel be confirmed


And how do you know who the panel is

[Denver]

The panel will be confirmed before the auditions on the 18th

[EddyEagal]

An announcement is coming this week. It is imminent.

Ayda is NOT a judge. This has been a very elaborate media spin to get her some coverage - a condition to Robbie's involvement in the show. It has also been a way to legitimise the return of a pervious judge, which I posted on this forum a good month or so ago now. You can go through my posts to see who it is. I am not posting a name again, as within the past week, strict embargos have been introduced.

The panel is interesting. There is one (or two) big names.

As I said before - again a month or so ago now - the panel is not exhaustive of those involved in the show this year. The make-up of the panel is going to allow for other guest appearances, which is where the likes of Ricky Martin and Rita Ora come in.

[Denver]

Tula Paulinea Contostavlos and Ella Marija Lani Yelich-O'Connor is a coming girls?

[Strictly Jake]

By the sounds of what eddie is saying

Mel Tulisa and Simon are the judges and the 4th will swap and change

Robbie
Rita
Sharon....

[EddyEagal]

Originally Posted by ShakeyJake10

By the sounds of what eddie is saying

Mel Tulisa and Simon are the judges and the 4th will swap and change

Robbie
Rita
Sharon....

Not quite.

A few names are right, but one is very wrong.

Spoiler:

Mel is not going to be on the show.

[Strictly Jake]

That was one of the names you mentioned

Ok so im guessing Simon Tulisa Robbie

With the 4th judge changing

Rita Ora
Louis Tomlinson
Sharon Osbourne...

[Owoaje1993]

I’m just happy Nicole has gone didn’t think she was a good and she was an average mentor in my opinion

[Nicky91]

i think the judges will be Simon, Tulisa, Robbie, and then first at auditions for 4th Judge we have Louis Tomlinson, then at bootcamp & Judge houses 4th Judge will be Rita Ora, and then from liveshows we have Sharon Osbourne as 4th Judge

[Lewismacfarlane]

Sharon is a 5th judge at the live shows

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Lewismacfarlane

Sharon is a 5th judge at the live shows

so do they then have 5 categories

[Lewismacfarlane]

Originally Posted by Nicky91

so do they then have 5 categories

I think she'll be an impartial judge

[Strictly Jake]

I think we may see sharon as a wildcard judge she can pick any 3 acts she wants out of those sent home