[Elliot]

So let’s pretend punchgate never happened for a sec, were looking at them as housemates before that all happened. Both have been accused of being fake/acting up to the camera, but who do you think is more obnoxious in this regard?

[Cal.]

Ryan

[Epic.]

Although i think she is a much better housemate, I'm going for Roxanne since Ryan wasn't part of the series prior to punchgate whereas she clearly was so therefore is more obnoxious and camera mugging, but I can definitely see him playing it up more near the final

[chuff me dizzy]

Ryan by a mile, Roxanne is just a tragic mess

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Elliot

So let’s pretend punchgate never happened for a sec, were looking at them as housemates before that all happened. Both have been accused of being fake/acting up to the camera, but who do you think is more obnoxious in this regard?

Elliot I know you dislike Ryan but he's not a horrible person with severe issues . Come on now .

Roxanne is obviously the most obnoxious!! , even without punch gate all the complaints from co stars about her shows her true colours. And her behaviour prior to everything was soo irritating and attention seeking .

And every programme she does she either gets spiteful or acts fake & plays victim! .

[Gusto Brunt]

Roxanne

Ryan nowhere close

[Elliot]

Originally Posted by GoldHeart

Elliot I know you dislike Ryan but he's not a horrible person with severe issues . Come on now .

Roxanne is obviously the most obnoxious!! , even without punch gate all the complaints from co stars about her shows her true colours. And her behaviour prior to everything was soo irritating and attention seeking .

And every programme she does she either gets spiteful or acts fake & plays victim! .

I said pretend punchgate didn’t happen, they were both being criticised for the same thing on this forum and elsehwhere

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Elliot

I said pretend punchgate didn’t happen, they were both being criticised for the same thing on this forum and elsehwhere

I know but I still disagree .

People already disliked her attitude on DOI ,and her behaviour with Ben made her worse imo .

Even on launch night Ryan wasn't as OTT as Roxanne ,she kicked her leg in the air and started frantically rubbing her outfit like there was something on it . And the whole acting was soo fake & nauseating ! . Plus the pool incident with Hardeep was another sign of her being an attention seeking idiot .

[poppsywoppsy]

Taking out punchgate, Roxanne was getting on my nerves with her constant attention seeking in front of the cameras.

Jumping on her bed like a child, role playing drama, her awful rendition of the American anthem which I thought was disrespectful and latching onto Ben deliberately to cause interest.

35? More like 13.

[girlfighter1992]

Roxanne all the way from the moment she walked down them stairs.

Ryan is no way near being obnoxious I know people think he has been faking and playing up to the cameras but that is just him

[joeysteele]

Roxanne.
She was getting on my nerves re her antics towards Ben.
Long before she showed the rotten disgraceful waste of space she is later.

[Robodog]

Oooooh tough call

Right up to punchgate, i was finding them both equally as annoying and self-obsessed

Both have a fake 'loud n happy' persona, that thinly masks an angry person underneath



I'd say this is a draw

[Clootie Dumpling]

Originally Posted by Robodog

Oooooh tough call

Right up to punchgate, i was finding them both equally as annoying and self-obsessed

Both have a fake 'loud n happy' persona, that thinly masks an angry person underneath



I'd say this is a draw

I'd have to agree - both drawing focus in different ways to get maximum attention and camera time.

[RileyH]

EASILY Ryan he's so OTT and desperate and cringe

[Beso]

Ryan and his fat mouth.

[montblanc]

ryan's more obnoxious, roxanne is just a terrible person

[Clootie Dumpling]

Originally Posted by montblanc

ryan's more obnoxious, roxanne is just a terrible person

That's true - maybe I should make my mind up in relation to decibel levels!

[blisstheassassin]

Having met both of them in person (British Soap Awards) Roxanne is far more obnoxious.

[smudgie]

Roxanne.
Even before punchgate she was getting on my nerves.

[Vicky.]

Can proper tell its getting close to the final

Roxanne.

[girlfighter1992]

Originally Posted by blisstheassassin

Having met both of them in person (British Soap Awards) Roxanne is far more obnoxious.

What was they both like then