[Kate!]

1 Rose
2 Amy
3 Romana

[Tony Montana]

1. Rose
2. Donna
3. Martha

[LukeB]

Donna
Rose
Martha

[Marsh.]

1. Donna
2. Rose
3. Bill

Disclaimer: Bill didn't have anywhere near the best series, but I found Amy progressively irritating and Martha was let down by the actress.

[Cal.]

1. Donna
2. Rose
3. Martha

[LukeB]

Rose was my favourite but after a re-watch Donna was just amazing! she deserved another series.

[Oliver_W]

Donna
Bill
Clara

Zoe
Jamie
Ace
Kamelion

[Cal.]

And can I just say Donna’s exit was so ****ing sad? It doesn’t bare thinking about it?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Cal.

And can I just say Donna’s exit was so ****ing sad? It doesn’t bare thinking about it?

[Calderyon]

Rose Tyler
Amy Pond
Donna/Martha/Jack

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Cal.

And can I just say Donna’s exit was so ****ing sad? It doesn’t bare thinking about it?

sadder than David Tennant as the doctor saying he doesn't want to go

[Morgan.]

1. Donna Noble
2. Amy Pond

Rest are all even

[Greg!]

Donna
Rose
Amy

In THAT order! All legends

[Strictly Jake]

Clara
Rose
Amy

[Strictly Jake]

As for the doctor

David Tennant
Matt Smith
Jodie Whittaker

Id like to think the Peter Capaldi days never happened

[user104658]

Hmmm Clara is my favourite character who has BEEN a companion, however, I think she was "elevated" a bit too much to be a "good companion", if that makes sense. Jenna Coleman would have made a great first female doctor IMO, in an alternate universe.

So it's Amy > Rose and Clara is in there somewhere but I can't decide where.

[user104658]

Originally Posted by Strictly Jake

As for the doctor

David Tennant
Matt Smith
Jodie Whittaker

Id like to think the Peter Capaldi days never happened

Smith > Tennant, is fact

AND Capaldi has some great episodes, just messy overall.

[Saph]

Originally Posted by Cal.

1. Donna
2. Rose
3. Martha

this

Donna had the most interesting story line of any companion tbh, her ending was SO sad too..

Rose was great in series 1, but she got annoying in season 2. If if wasn't for the iconic Jackie, she wouldn't be 2nd.

Martha was good because she had some balls and had some of the best episodes of the entire show during her series. Its a shame her story line was the 'shes not rose' story.

[Saph]

Bill was great too but she was done dirty with a crap storyline and being with capaldi

[Marsh.]

Erm Capaldi was great!!! Just Moffat let him down with crap scripts.

He actually came into his own with Bill, Missy and Nardol. Once Clara had stopped hijacking his show.

[Saph]

Clara was the worst.. she was so dull and I swear she did about 8 series

[Daniel.]

Rose
Donna
Martha

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Saph

Clara was the worst.. she was so dull and I swear she did about 8 series

It's weird. Certain parts of her story are great, and Jenna is a really good actress (if not the strongest companion actor NuWho has had) but it didn't translate into the most interesting one. They were done dirty by some of those appalling episodes.

[Marsh.]

Also Bill's transformation to Cyberman was up there with Donna's exit as very effective.

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Also Bill's transformation to Cyberman was up there with Donna's exit as very effective.

Probably the strongest episodes of the series - the first time in a long while I’d actually been gripped and excited by a DW story.