Controversial Dance Off decisions

[Nicky91]

Katie was miles better than Judi


yet so called dance experts ''craig, motsi, shirley'' prefer entertainment over dance content



good on Anton for having his own opinion and preferring who dances best to save



Judi can never ever become a dancer even if she dances for 100 years or so




Katie really massively improved her routine in the dance off compared to saturday night

[joeysteele]

In the dance off Katie was the better.

Sorry but Judi just strutted about with next to no real dance moves.
Shook her body a lot but it was a very poor routine.

For me, Judi is one who is Just staying at best the same in dances.

I agree Anton is the better judge then again, he knows what it's like competing then to come for the comments.

Honestly, for me, either they should do a chosen dance to dance off, probably the same one.
The judges have voted on the dance before so it's pointless to dance it again.
IF it happened someone voted last by the judges, were in the dance off but someone else much higher was in with them.
The dance off is pointless even more.

Unless they did a different dance.
As on X Factor, where you chose a sing off song to do.

Really however for me, just leave it all down to the public votes added to the judges votes.
Then who is bottom there, goes out.

Plus, I have to say too, Shirley Ballas is a terrible replacement for Len Goodman.
She shows her favourites, can be biased and please, in the first week she was on about mistakes made.

On Saturday she as head judge said, it's ONLY week 3 and that she'd be ignoring mistakes.

The judging of the panel is what spoils the night.
They should just give opinion and advice with no voting.O
Or have their voting only for fun.

Just abide by how the public vote in my opinion.

The dance off is the biggest waste of time on Strictly for me.
Unless as I said, they both did a different dance in it from the one done before.

Shirley really irritates me however.
Craig is as ever his annoying self.
Motsi is okay.
Anton definitely the fairer of all of them.
In my view anyhow

[Nicky91]

Craig, Motsi, Shirley are all blind if they really think Judi dances


all that woman does is a tiny bit of walking but standing in the same place

even Graziano struggles with the lifts, but any pro would with the blob



Judi pls withdraw from the competition, this is a dance contest not a joke act show like Dancing On Ice

[Nicky91]

for Judi

Youtube video
Click to view this video on Youtube

ur in the wrong place

ur in the wrong place



most definitely in the wrong show



hope this vile woman will get rigged out next

[joeysteele]

I don't think Judi is vile.
I didn't think either for me should have been the bottom 2 this week.

However in the dance off Judi was the worst.
No doubt about that for me.

I just can't see how Judi will improve.
Because she hasn't since week one.

Last week was maybe entertaining but not really dancing.
This is supposed to be a DANCING competition not just a dancing show.

Judi has a great personality but a dancer I doubt she'll ever be.
In a for entertainment routine she'd be great to watch but when most others are really trying hard in any particular dance.

It has to be about much more than just entertaining.

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I don't think Judi is vile.
I didn't think either for me should have been the bottom 2 this week.

However in the dance off Judi was the worst.
No doubt about that for me.

I just can't see how Judi will improve.
Because she hasn't since week one.

Last week was maybe entertaining but not really dancing.
This is supposed to be a DANCING competition not just a dancing show.

Judi has a great personality but a dancer I doubt she'll ever be.
In a for entertainment routine she'd be great to watch but when most others are really trying hard in any particular dance.

It has to be about much more than just entertaining.

no offense of course, and i wasn't a fan of Katie either

but i would become mad if Judi stays over any of my favourites


and i like journey contestants more last few years now


i really don't want producers to place Robert into comedy slot either, he is way better than that, more serious routines pls

i am also quite the fan of Dianne for a few years now, and i hope she makes it past week 4, and breaks that week 4 curse from last 2 years as well

[Vanessa]

Definitely wrong decision last night.
Katie danced it clean, while Judy made a mistake.
And Shirley didn't see it. Funny how Anton saw it and she didn't

[Nicky91]

Dan, Judi, Tilly are now the weakest of the pack i think



i don't mind Greg, i like his sense of humour too ''dancing Macarena as 007''



some call Ugo a weak dancer but i definitely disagree there, i find Ugo growing more and more in his confidence, and also his performance this week, barefoot is always more difficult than with shoes so also respect for that and he has such a loveable personality of you just want him to do well

[Strictly Jake]

Woah woah woah absolutely no need to fat shame people Nicky. If you don't like her dancing then that's your opinion. Katie wasn't able to put much time into rehearsals due to filming so it's prob best she left quite early on at least she got to have the experience but I think she misjudged how much time she would need for it whereas it's clear Judi is loving every second and I would have been sad to see her go. She really isn't vile. The only vile person I see round here is you saying such disgusting things about people. You do this every strictly season it's beyond ridiculous. Be kind.

[Nicky91]

Originally Posted by Strictly Jake

Woah woah woah absolutely no need to fat shame people Nicky. If you don't like her dancing then that's your opinion. Katie wasn't able to put much time into rehearsals due to filming so it's prob best she left quite early on at least she got to have the experience but I think she misjudged how much time she would need for it whereas it's clear Judi is loving every second and I would have been sad to see her go. She really isn't vile. The only vile person I see round here is you saying such disgusting things about people. You do this every strictly season it's beyond ridiculous. Be kind.

fair enough Jake


i just thought since they said ''based upon that dance off alone'' i really thought they would save Katie because she danced it way better than first time around, whereas Judi's more or less stayed the same


yes i like Judi's personality, i like how she comes across on ITT, i was shocked she was in the dance off last night since i thought personality wise she would've won over quite some votes, her being in the dance off i knew Adam would be safe on public vote, but i didn't know both Adam, Dan would be saved on public vote

and yes for Adam i've seen many people voting over on DS too

Dan must've have some form of fanbase now i think, or just more votes than both Judi, Katie (i knew Katie would be in the DO because of the week before also having been in the DO so little or no public support)

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I don't think Judi is vile.
I didn't think either for me should have been the bottom 2 this week.

However in the dance off Judi was the worst.
No doubt about that for me.

I just can't see how Judi will improve.
Because she hasn't since week one.

Last week was maybe entertaining but not really dancing.
This is supposed to be a DANCING competition not just a dancing show.

Judi has a great personality but a dancer I doubt she'll ever be.
In a for entertainment routine she'd be great to watch but when most others are really trying hard in any particular dance.

It has to be about much more than just entertaining.

I agree with everything that you've said Joey to some extent.

The only thing I will say is that Katie has not been connecting with the public unfortunately for her, so at least she's not suffering more humiliation in the competition anymore.

Although having said all of that I do feel torn on the judges saving the weaker dancer as I believe that's the public's job to do that if they want to.