FAQ |
Members List |
Calendar |
Search |
Today's Posts |
![]() |
#1 | |||
|
||||
Senior Member
|
My main plan is to watch some of The X Factor Seasons where I was too young to really form proper opinions of the performances.
I am back in the Singing Show mood thanks to American Idol. ![]() I will also plan on doing some rewatches eventually, but I did do some of them not too long ago, so it's not an urgent matter for me. I also might cover some other countries versions too, if I can find them in the land of the sea. Anyway I'm starting with Season 2 of the UK version. My rankings: Live Show 1: 1. Maria Lawson - Emotion - She had the nicest sounding voice to my ears. 2. Brenda Edwards - Son Of A Preacher Man 3. Andy Abraham - Greatest Love Of All 4. Chenai Zinyuku - The Closest Thing To Crazy - Probably the most interesting song choice on the night. I dock a couple of points for sometimes she was sounding like she was singing through her nose, but for the most part I liked the performance. 5. Chico Slimani - Da Ya Think I'm Sexy? ![]() 6. Journey South - Something About The Way You Look Tonight 7. Nicholas Dorsett - On The Wings Of Love 8. Shayne Ward - Right Here Waiting 9. The Conway Sisters - SOS ![]() 10. Phillip Magee - Amazed - Interesting song choice, but ultimately sung badly imo. 11. Addictiv Ladies - Superstar - I honestly didn't think that anyone could sound worse on the night, until 4Tune came along. ![]() 12. 4Tune - I Want It That Way ![]() Live Show 2: 1. Maria Lawson - The Way You Make Me Feel 2. Chico Slimani - Play That Funky Music ![]() 3. Journey South - Desperado 4. Brenda Edwards - Rescue Me 5. Nicholas Dorsett - Let's Get It On 6. Andy Abraham - You To Me Are Everything 7. Shayne Ward - If You're Not The One 8. Chenai Zinyuku - Young Hearts Run Free ![]() 9. The Conway Sisters - You Raise Me Up ![]() 10. 4Tune - I'll Be There ![]() 11. Phillip Magee - Wind Beneath My Wings - Wtf! ![]() Live Show 3: 1. Maria Lawson - Piece Of My Heart - Is her final placing in this Show satire from the public/the production? Imo she has the best vocal in the competition, absolutely crazy to think what ends up happening with her tbh. ![]() 2. Phillip Magee - Johnny B. Goode - A huge improvement, but unfortunately that week 2 performance was toxic which I'm guessing killed his vote going into this performance. 3. Andy Abraham - Unforgettable 4. Chico Slimani - Livin La Vida Loca - Ricky Martin should be jealous of the vocal from Chico on this song. ![]() 5. Journey South - Angel Of Harlem 6. Nicholas Dorsett - Let's Stay Together 7. Brenda Edwards - Midnight Train To Georgia 8. Chenai Zinyuku - Hero ![]() 9. Shayne Ward - Summer Of 69 ![]() 10. The Conway Sisters - Total Eclipse Of The Heart ![]() Live Show 4: 1. Maria Lawson - You're Beautiful 2. Journey South - The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face - Definitely my favourite performance from Journey South so far. 3. Chico Slimani - Kiss - What a vocal. ![]() 4. Chenai Zinyuku - Always On My Mind 5. Andy Abraham - Can't Take My Eyes Off You 6. Brenda Edwards - Somebody Else's Guy 7. The Conway Sisters - One Voice 8. Shayne Ward - You Make Me Feel Brand New ![]() 9. Nicholas Dorsett - I Want You Back ![]() Live Show 5: 1. Brenda Edwards - Heartbreaker 2. Maria Lawson - Brown Sugar - It was her weakest performance, but I still enjoyed it personally. 3. Journey South - Livin On A Prayer 4. Nicholas Dorsett - I Believe I Can Fly 5. Andy Abraham - I'll Make Love To You - Strange song choice for Andy imo. 6. Shayne Ward - Cry Me A River ![]() 7. The Conway Sisters - Hold On ![]() 8. Chico Slimani - Hero - Words can't even describe what I thought of this performance. Live Show 6: 1. Chico Slimani - It's Chico Time 2. Andy Abraham - Me And Mrs. Jones 3. Shayne Ward - A Million Love Songs - Probably his best vocal so far imo. 4. Journey South - Angels 5. Brenda Edwards - Last Dance 6. Nicholas Dorsett - If I Ever Fall In Love 7. The Conway Sisters - One Moment In Time ![]() Live Show 7: 1. Andy Abraham - I Have Nothing - I honestly didn't expect to put this performance anywhere near the top. ![]() 2. Brenda Edwards - I Will Always Love You 3. Shayne Ward - I Believe In A Thing Called Love - Not a bad effort imo. 4. The Conway Sisters - Nothing's Gonna Stop Us Now - Probably their strongest performance tbh. 5. Journey South - I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For - Besides week 4, I feel like Journey South suffer from sounding too Karaoke, and considering this is a top 6 round, I do feel like their standards should be higher than it currently is. 6. Chico Slimani - Billie Jean And I can't believe that Simon would say that a contestant "isn't sexy" on national TV. Imo Brenda might not be as attractive as Maria or Chenai, but she's also not some hideous beast that I think Simon was making her out to look like. And you can't win with Simon anyway because I remember during Season 6 of American idol, him attacking Haley for dressing "provocatively" to get men to vote for her. Rant aside, I will be listening to the seventh Live Show in a few minutes, but first I have to listen to some good singing after hearing some of these contestants in Season 2. ![]() Some of them are talented tbf, especially Maria. Live Show 8 Round 1: 1. Chico Slimani - I Got You (I Feel Good) 2. Andy Abraham - Easy Lover 3. Brenda Edwards - I'm Outta Love 4. Shayne Ward - Take Your Mama 5. Journey South - Bad Day ![]() Live Show 8 Round 2: 1. Chico Slimani - Time Warp - Probably Chico's best vocal imo. 2. Journey South - Candle In The Wind 3. Andy Abraham - When I Fall In Love 4. Brenda Edwards - I'll Never Love This Way Again 5. Shayne Ward - Careless Whisper ![]() Live Show 9 Round 1: 1. Brenda Edwards - Respect 2. Journey South - You're In My Heart (The Final Acclaim) 3. Shayne Ward - If Tomorrow Never Comes 4. Andy Abraham - (Everything I Do) I Do It For You - Definitely not Andy's best. ![]() Live Show 9 Round 2: 1. Journey South - Let It Be 2. Shayne Ward - Unchained Melody 3. Andy Abraham - Lately 4. Brenda Edwards - Without You Live Show 10 Round 1: 1. Andy Abraham - When A Man Loves A Woman 2. Shayne Ward - If You're Not The One 3. Journey South - Don't Let The Sun Go Down On Me Live Show 10 Round 2: 1. Andy Abraham - O Holy Night 2. Shayne Ward - When A Child Is Born 3. Journey South - Happy Xmas (War Is Over) - I don't know what's happening to Journey South, but this final is below their usual standard imo. Live Show 10 Round 3: 1. Shayne Ward - Over The Rainbow - Why didn't we get more performances like this from Shayne in other weeks, this was actually really good from him. 2. Andy Abraham - Me And Mrs. Jones 3. Journey South - Let It Be I've heard That's My Goal loads of times in the past, so I'm not listening to it again. ![]() Overall it was a topsy turvy kind of Season for me, I definitely liked some of the contestants, but some of the standard were shockingly bad even by X Factor bad acts standards imo.
__________________
![]() Last edited by Mystic Mock; 31-07-2024 at 10:19 PM. |
|||
![]() |
![]() |
|
|