[Billy]

Ok so whats your opinion on Dannii as a judge?

I tihnk sehs great. SHe doesnt put people through for teh sake of it, and doesnt let her feelings get in the way of her job

[Matt]

I think that having been through it all herslef she is the only judge on the X Factor that deserves her place on the panel.

I also admire Sharon Osbourne for being the only judge to keep a straight face. (Apart from last week... lol)

[Wasted]

I like her so far, the only one time where I've seen her put someone through out of sympathy was when she said yes to Ryan. But otherwise, she doesn't just put people through if they have a sob story, only if she thinks they're good enough.

But she was rather harsh in this blog I read a week ago:

http://www.xfactor.tv/news/dannii/?scid=78

[MarkWaldorf]

I think she's a great addition, but sometimes she's a bit dull. Overall she was probably the most deserving person they could have got though.

[Billy]

Wasted, I agree, I was dissapointed and shocked that she wrote that, and I cant maek any excuses for her doing this, except that she said what we were thinking, but even so its very harsh

[XxShortyxX]

I think she is the eye-candy lol I like her, she has lovely eyes, but I prefer her sister.

[Harry!]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
I think she is the eye-candy lol I like her, she has lovely eyes, but I prefer her sister.

her sister is defo better!

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Matt
I also admire Sharon Osbourne for being the only judge to keep a straight face

Well, to be honest, she has had so much surgery, she probably cant help it.

[Billy]

LMAO Arneldo, I actually burst out laughing at that

[Shaun]

I'm not sure what to make of her, if I'm honest - she doesn't get a lot of attention in the shows.