[Arneldo]

Discuss here

[Arneldo]

Charlie was great, and Dom. Andy wasn't great, I think. Rhydain is just ...no, please go away. The Chico/McDonalds of 2007.

[xDramatick]

Andy, Leon, &Charlie = <3

Please.. just not Rhyd.

[Ruth*Star]

Kimberly was great, so was Same Difference, i'd be so happy if SD got though.

[xDramatick]

Stephanie<333

As long as Hope&Futureproof don't get through ^^:;
I wanna see W4&I Sette Cantanti&Same Difference get through

[Billy]

Kim, Stephanie and Hope were amazing

[Callum]

Emily was amazing tonight..

[XxShortyxX]

Kim, Steph, Kimberly, Hope, Nikki, and Beveraly were the best, I hope they all get through.


Kimberly is the only one who seems to be bubby and actually has a personality I luv her

[Billy]

I really dislike Emily now. Shes gunna crumble at the live shows, If i have to hear one more time about how she nearly died Ill go mad. I couldnt give a monkeys, its the x factor not flamin jeremy kyle

[XxShortyxX]

I think the girls this year are way better singers then the guys. No doubt a guy will win this year though lol

[Riz]

Originally posted by Billy
I really dislike Emily now. Shes gunna crumble at the live shows, If i have to hear one more time about how she nearly died Ill go mad. I couldnt give a monkeys, its the x factor not flamin jeremy kyle

what about that woman that keeps saying about her dead dad im sorry for her but this is a competition to sing, and it should be judged on your voice not your past.

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Callum
Emily was amazing tonight..

I actually disagree.
I think she was horribly flat.
I think she's got potential, but she's not showing it.

[Wasted]

Boys - No-one was really good, not even Dominic, who so far is the only boy worthy of noting down. But Dominic was brilliant in all the other stages and DOESN'T have a lame sob story so he deserves to go through.

Over 25's - Zita (sp?), Beverley and Daniel were the best from this group tonight. Beverley surprised me, she normally shouts but she was sounding good this time.

Groups - W4, Hope and Ghostt were the 3 best here. But I don't think I want Hope to go through, I don't want Futureproof through neither. I want the other two I mentioned and Same Difference.

Girls - Kimberley, Alisha and Stephanie were my 3 favourites here. I think Alisha is my favourite overall. Emily was better tonight than she was last week but I still don't think she should go through, I do like her though and she has a nice, rich voice.


Was anyone else counting the amount of sob stories we had tonight? I lost count.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Rizwan

what about that woman that keeps saying about her dead dad Im sorry for her but this is a competition to sing, and it should be judged on your voice not your past.

God I know, I just wanna slap her and tell her to isng

[XxShortyxX]

We always get the sob stories. That's one thing even Simon hates.

The only people who didn't have a sob story were Kimberley, Steph and the blonde girl who is 16, but looks like she is 20 lol.

[Billy]

her names Kimberley too lol

[Wasted]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
We always get the sob stories. That's one thing even Simon hates.

The only people who didn't have a sob story were Kimberley, Steph and the blonde girl who is 16, but looks like she is 20 lol.

Alisha hasn't had one neither, and she's one of the people who has had the least coverage so far.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Wasted

Alisha hasn't had one neither, and she's one of the people who has had the least coverage so far.

Which one is she? Is she the black women who is 23? I like her.

[Wasted]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX

Which one is she? Is she the black women who is 23? I like her.

Yeah, the one with the afro.

[CassetteFinger]

I want Zyta to get through so much but lookin at the odds her names isent there so im guessing she dident make it i really think that emily is crap a bad version of Jordin sparks her vibrato is way to fast for my liking sounds like a sheep

[XxShortyxX]

Yeah she is good. My mum likes her lol.

My fav is kimberley, because not only has she got the voice, but the personality as well.

[Callum]

Originally posted by Rice_Square
I want Zyta to get through so much but lookin at the odds her names isent there so Im guessing she dident make it i really think that emily is c**p a bad version of Jordin sparks her vibrato is way to fast for my liking sounds like a sheep

Yes I want Zyta to get through too, she deserves it bless her. That Niki annoys me mind, waste of talent if you ask me.

[Billy]

I agree with Callum.

Niki and Emily are the biggest waste of talent

[Conzors]

Who is zyta again?

[Dan_]

Boys-Nobody really stood out.Andy,Dominic,Charlie and Leon were all good but not outstanding.Rhydian messed up and Luke was his normal high pitched self.

Girls-I thought the best three were Stephanie, Kimberley and Alicia by a mile.Victoria was average as was Kim.I thought Emily was the weakest of them all, very disappointed in her.

Groups-Missed them as I was getting my dinner.

25 and overs-Icaro was terrible.Niki, Beverley and Daniel D all impressed me.Zyta and Daniel M were okay.