[Shaun]

They've both been the first singles off two (what looks set to be) hugely successful Madonna albums - but which single do you prefer, and why?

[Shaun]

For me it's a tricky decision, I love both. I can see 4 Minutes being one of my favourite songs of the year...but Hung Up was just amazing. The whole disco-themed album was one of my favourites of all time.

[Spike]

Love both, prefer Hung Up because its an amazing song.

[Captain.Remy]

Hung Up hands down. For me 4 minutes is a mistake in her career, it happens sometimes.

[_Max_]

Hung Up definitely

[Sam!]

4 minutes

[Christina]

I cant stand Hang Up .. i much prefer 4 minutes x

[Matt]

Hung Up without a doubt. I can't stand 4 Minutes.

[Billy]

They're both crap, and Madonna is a bitof a hasbeen

[Jack]

Hung Up is a better song based on it's own merits, however 4 Minutes appeals to me more.

[xDramatick]

Hung Up.
4 Minutes is rubbish.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Billy21
They're both c**p, and Madonna is a bitof a hasbeen

As much as I respect it's your opinion, that's a **** one

She's pretty much one of the best musicians ever.

[MrGaryy]

Hung up I'm not too fond of 4 mins except for the chorus.

[Callum]

Hung Up but i also love 4 minutes.

[geoking66]

I love them both, but I'd say the album version of "Hung Up" because it really is Madonna at what she does best: dance. However, the remixes for "4 Minutes" are amazing; you should check out the Bob Sinclair Space Funk Remix, it's a godsend.

[Sarah.]

4 Minutes, I love it!

[Arneldo]

I'd rather listen to Shabnam's song that any of Madonna's rubbish.

She is a talentless. All she has going for her is her "ooh soo brilliant star quality". She can't sing and her dancing is awful.

Like my sig says - a disgrace to music.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Shaun

As much as I respect it's your opinion, that's a **** one

She's pretty much one of the best musicians ever.

She may have been back in her day, but theres nothing worse than knowing Madonna is somewhere in her 50s prancing about in her pink leotard as if shes 18.

[Callum]

You can dislike madonna as much as you like , but there's no denying she is a good, talented singer. even if you think she's crap, you cannot possibly say "she's not good". it's just fact that she is good.

[Jack]

Originally posted by Billy21

She may have been back in her day, but theres nothing worse than knowing Madonna is somewhere in her 50s prancing about in her pink leotard as if shes 18.

She's 49 (and looks great on it in my opinion). I admit it can be slightly cringe worthy and embarassing but it shouldn't make her music crap. She is still a fantastic performer and an amazing talent.

[Xander]

I do quite like 4 minutes , kinda catchy. Hung Up (Confessions On A Dancefloor) were focusing more towards a pop/dance direction which I didn't like. 4 Minutes is more hip-hop/pop direction(?) which I really quite like.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Callum
You can dislike madonna as much as you like , but there's no denying she is a good, talented singer. even if you think she's c**p, you cannot possibly say "she's not good". it's just fact that she is good.

I can quite easily say shes not a talented singer. Performer, entertaininer yes, (well back in hte day)

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Arneldo
I'd rather listen to Shabnam's song that any of Madonna's rubbish.

She is a talentless. All she has going for her is her "ooh soo brilliant star quality". She can't sing and her dancing is awful.

Like my sig says - a disgrace to music.

Wtf?

How can she be a disgrace to it when she continues to revolutionise it? She's the only musician around today, that I can think of, who has adapted to every popular style of music; pop, dance, rock, country, r&b, hip-hop...

Sure, she hasn't got an amazing voice, but does she need one? She writes and produces her own stuff, and is amazing at writing catchy hits, and especially performing them.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Arneldo
I'd rather listen to Shabnam's song that any of Madonna's rubbish.

She is a talentless. All she has going for her is her "ooh soo brilliant star quality". She can't sing and her dancing is awful.

Like my sig says - a disgrace to music.

Agreed.

[Jack]

A disgrace to music? She made music what it is today.

I always say there's no such thing as a wrong opinion, but that is one.