[Chilltown]

http://www.realitybbq.com/2008/04/19...sus-favorites/

Looks like we will be getting 8 returning contestants. My Guesses for the Favorites/Least Favorites Are:

Josh - BB3

Jun - BB4

Marvin - BB5

Cappy - BB6

Rachel - BB6

Evel Dick - BB8

Daniele - BB8

James - BB9

[Sam1994]

That is a rubbish idea, can't they think of their own twists instead of copying from Survivor? I hope this isn't true

[Arneldo]

Too early to bring back ex-houseguests, I think. I mean the only houseguests I'd like to have back from S8 and S9 are Jen, Eric, James, Sheila. And from the all-stars we got a good idea of which ex-houseguests would want to go back, and who the public want back. My guess is it would just be another reason to send Janelle back.

[Chilltown]

I honestly do not think that we would end up getting Janelle/Kaysar/Howie/Will/Boogie, etc for a third season. Dick and Daniele as well as James would be the most solid choices for All-Stars and probably Eric as well.

[Callum]

I would love to see the Donato's back.

[MrGaryy]

I think Janelle would do it again and If I'm honest I would love watching her again! James too!

[JeanP!]

* Janelle BB6/BB7
* Natalie BB9
* James BB6/BB7
* Kail BB8
* Marcellas
* Drew BB5
* Adria BB5
* Natalie BB5

[Sam1994]

Not Janelle again please, they may as well just name it The Janelle Show if she is ever in it again

[Chilltown]

Originally posted by JeanP!
* Janelle BB6/BB7
* Natalie BB9
* James BB6/BB7
* Kail BB8
* Marcellas
* Drew BB5
* Adria BB5
* Natalie BB5

Umm...you realize none of them will be back right =/

Jannelle - It is a rule that no one is aloud on for a THIRD season
Natalie - Not a favorite, and not a villain. She is like Amber from last year. No chance to return.
James - No THIRD season.
Kail - Not memorable enough to return as well as not being a fan favorite or villain.
Marcellas - NO THIRD season.
Drew - Boring and neither a fan favorite or villain.
Adria & Natalie - I doubt they would allow both back. One would probably return at best and fill a 'villain' role. But I doubt either would return since they turned down All-Stars and are not as memorable as recent years characters.

[gowildcats]

They would never put a housemate for the 3rd time, thats ridiculous! And Its too early for any sort of all stars. Survivor did it in season 16. BB wont be any different

[Captain.Remy]

I think it'd too early, we only had 2 series between all-stars and BB10. However, I love the idea, it works perfectly in Survivor 16 so it would be a great twist.
Anyway here are my choices:
- BB8 Dick.
- BB8 Danielle.
- BB8 Jen.
- BB9 Joshuah.
- BB8 Eric.
- BB9 Natalie.
- BB9 Ryan.
- BB8 Jessica.

[MrGaryy]

Where does it say that a housemate can't return a third time?

[Redmond]

This would suck, I want new houseguests. Look at Allstars, most of the housemates that came back were way too smug.

Don't they ask them every year who their favourite housemate was? Because usually on the houseguest profiles on CBS.com it gives the houseguest's favourite past houseguest. Although this year they haven't done that.

[bbcanada]

NOOOOOO!
This is a horrible idea! I'm sick of them doing crap twists like this, KEEP IT BIG BROTHER! Strangers in a house!
This better not be true otherwise I am definitly not watching.

[Rory]

Originally posted by Chilltown
Jannelle - It is a rule that no one is aloud on for a THIRD season

Wait, where does it say that?

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Rory

Wait, where does it say that?

That's what I was going to ask him.

[Rory]

I sure hope not, but it could be likely since Survivor: All Stars occurred before Fan vs. Favorites; however, I think there should be some more seasons between AS and FvF

[Captain.Remy]

Message original : Rory
I sure hope not, but it could be likely since Survivor: All Stars occurred before Fan vs. Favorites; however, I think there should be some more seasons between AS and FvF

Exactly, a gap of 2 series is too short. It should work for BB12.

[Rory]

Originally posted by Captain.Remy

Exactly, a gap of 2 series is too short. It should work for BB12.

Yeah. Hopefully BB will still be successful enough to do it then.

[Chilltown]

http://www.realitybbq.com/2008/04/20...casting-calls/

Confirmed even more? Looks like it is near 100%

[MrGaryy]

Yes! I would love it! Really hope that Janelle does it if it does happen.

[Chilltown]

And also, it is an unwritten rule in CBS Reality Shows that a player is not allowed to return for a 3rd season. A player can be voted out and return within a season, and then go on to play in All-Stars or FvF (i.e. Kaysar). However 3 Seasons isn't allowed with contestants. If it were we would have seen Stephenie Lagrossa of Survivor Palau and Guatemala come back for Fans vs. Favorites. Or Rupert Boneham of Pearl Islands and All-Stars return for Fans vs. Favorites. Both were immensely popular with fan viewers, possibly even more-so than BB contestants Janelle and Kaysar.

[Chilltown]

Originally posted by thebiggerbrother
Yes! I would love it! Really hope that Janelle does it if it does happen.

Yes, I as well. Also idk if this is relevant or not but the week James was getting evicted after he failed to won the Veto, he told Sheila the Producers were letting him play again for another season in the future. It may be on YouTube. It was on an episode of BB: After Dark though.