[Wildcat!]

Just listened to the performances on youtube, but I dont know what the hell the judges were talking about. I almost disagree with everything they said. First of all I thought JLS were the best. Usually I dont like their vocals, but this time they were perfect vocally and they got slated, dont get it. Diana who I usually dont like, I thought she was pretty good. ALex's Toxic if ou listen back to it was not good at all, and Ruth was just shouting. I ma not even gonna comment on Eoghan, it was so bad.

So

Ruth 7/10
Eghoan /10
Alex 6/10
Diana 8/10
JLS 9/10

[Wildcat!]

2nd performances, ALex was the best really good on that one, Ruth was OK but shouting again, JLS were pretty good again, Eoghan, what can I say, he is dreadful, and Diana was back yodeling again. SO

Alex 9/10
JLS 8/10
Diana 7/10
Ruth 6/10
Eoghan 2/10

[Spike]

I agree with everything which the judges said tonight

[30stone]

I didnt like the judges tonight either i think dianas second was better than her first though...

i agree that listening to alex's toxic it sounded so off...

[Tom]

Ruth- Great performances, deserves to go through
JLS- Both crap
Alexandra- First one was rubbish, second one was outstanding
Eoghan- Both crap
Diana- I liked them, she deserves to go through but nothing different/new/special

[Wildcat!]

I think JLS's Hit me Baby one more time was their best vocal performance so far. They were vocally what I expected from bootcamp, but hadnt seen on the live show yet. But for some reason when they pull it of, thats when they get slated. I dont get it. Go back and listen to it, because they were flawless for once.

[30stone]

Originally posted by Aint_mad_atcha
I think JLS's Hit me Baby one more time was their best vocal performance so far. They were vocally what I expected from bootcamp, but hadnt seen on the live show yet. But for some reason when they pull it of, thats when they get slated. I dont get it. Go back and listen to it, because they were flawless for once.

i thought their second performance was one of their best but the first was rubbish...

[AngRemembered]

I agree with both the opening posts.

The problem the judges have is justifiying thier selections so far this late, it MUST be apparent to them 4 of the acts are simply nowhere near good enough at all.
But, with the concept of the show, it being about the judges and who impresses Simon for next years contract.
This is what happens they blame each other they single out competition for them, and the bad sneak through, now we have a show dominated by AVERAGE at very best acts.
At worst they are dreadful, and a new viewer tonight would be simply astounded that this is a premier talent contest for the UK!!!!
The X Factor needs a shake up starting with this idea judges are the stars getting an intro on stage each week.
They need to drop this stupid idead of judges becoming mentors so we dont have this tedious argument every week (bad song choice, its not your fault, ) a hopeless mentality which wastes time on judges making judgements on other judges, meanwhile the "talent" on stage is left an after thought.
Untill something is done the X Factor will be a source of ridicule, Peter Kay has sust it, it won't be long before there is a que forming to rip this rubbish format apart, and then we all lose because every so often a real superstar can be found... it just takes longer with this show as its going.

[Adamw92]

Alexandra- Toxic was amazing, Listen was amazing- 10/10
Diana- I'm Not a Girl was good, Everybody Hurts great- 8/10
Ruth- Britney- Alright, American Classic- Bad- 6/10
Eoghan- Britney- Crap, American Classic- Even Worse- 2/10
JLS- Britney- Sh*t, American Classic- Boring- 3/10