[aj2463]

Who do You think was the most talented or who's performance did You like the best?

For Me, deffo La Toya

[Tom8592]

Mutya

[CbgAndy]

Mutya

[AyeAye_xO]

muyta or ben

[lily.]

Coolio - because he can freestyle rap .. it's not as easy as it looks.

[30stone]

Mutya or ben.. michelle usually is amazing though im sad that she wasnt better.

[Stu]

Coolio, because people who perform material written by somebody else are not artists. I dont care if they have the voice of an angel.

If something is not yours, dont ****ing sing it [with covers being an obvious exception. And Elvis, I guess. After all, before Elvis their was nothing ].

[Locke.]

Most of them are talented in their own way. I voted Coolio though.

[30stone]

Originally posted by Stu
Coolio, because people who perform material written by somebody else are not artists. I dont care if they have the voice of an angel.

If something is not yours, dont ****ing sing it.

Some people are singers not singer/songwriters.

what would the people who were great song writers do if no one was to sing their song..

[TomV87]

Coolio isnt that original . ..

Youtube video

[lily.]

Originally posted by 30stone

Some people are singers not singer/songwriters.

what would the people who were great song writers do if no one was to sing their song..

They would spontaneously combust I expect. :P

[lily.]

Originally posted by TomV87
Coolio isnt that original . ..

Who said he was original?

[30stone]

Originally posted by Linda

They would spontaneously combust I expect. :P

Well there would be quite a few good songs that nobody would ever hear..

[lily.]

Originally posted by 30stone
Well there would be quite a few good songs that nobody would ever hear..

Indeed.

And, think of the mess cleaning up all those burnt up writers who'd combusted.

[Stu]

Originally posted by 30stone

Some people are singers not singer/songwriters.

what would the people who were great song writers do if no one was to sing their song..

This is where it gets tricky. Being a singer is one thing. People like Leona can get away with singing anything because they are just so good at singing.Having a full time pop group is a different story. I dont believe in going out their releasing albums and performing them with your name if they did not originate form your brain. People are always going to disagree, I know, and I like a bit of pop every once in awhile [Read : When im really drunk] but their my views .

What would the songwritters do? Well first off, I dont consider pop songs to be of much artistic merit. Pop is a business. And I dont consider the songs that great, in terms of lyricism. Really, pop is not about lyricism. Anybody can see that. So who knows. If they can sing, give it a bash I say .

[\PJ/]

They were all great,my fave perfomances were mutya's and coolio's.

[Deirdre]

Coolio is a great songwriter, so I voted for him.
I do love Mutya's voice though

[lily.]

Me too Deirdre. She sounds good live.

[GabrielleisLove]

Mutya without a doubt!

[Deirdre]

Originally posted by Linda
Me too Deirdre. She sounds good live.

Yeah.
Reminds me of the early Sugababes

[WATERS]

Michelle could not sing poor girl.. she looked amazing though
i felt bad on poor Verne
and lucy should have gotten her talent/s out

[Iceman]

Mutya

[LemonJam]

Tommy is very good and convincing in a speech, so I'll go down the non-musical route and say Tommy.

[PrincessBiatch]

I think if anything, the contest highlighted what mediocre talent they all had. If I had to choose, I'd say Mutya can hold a note.

[sophieyk2]

Mutya was by far the best, Ben was cheesy and Coolio was full of it. Thought Tina was brill at the old Shakespeare though, not easy to learn in such a short time and she showed Verne up - who needs Hollywood stars.