[JerseyWins]

Rank the castaways here!

Alec Merlino
Alison Raybould
Angelina Keeley
Bi Nguyen
Carl Boudreaux
Christian Hubicki
Dan Rengering
Davie Rickenbacker
Elizabeth Olson
Gabby Pascuzzi
Jeremy Crawford
Jessica Peet
John Hennigan
Kara Kay
Lyrsa Torres
Mike White
Natalia Azoqa
Natalie Cole
Nick Wilson
Pat Cusack

[JerseyWins]

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Mike White
3. Dan Rengering
4. Kara Kay
5. Bi Nguyen
6. Pat Cusack (idk maybe more of a blue tier but it was a funny one episode ride )
7. Jessica Peet
8. Carl Boudreaux
9. Natalia Azoqa (could absolutely go either way but right now I like her)
10. Gabby Pascuzzi
11. Christian Hubicki
12. Angelina Keeley
13. Natalie Cole
14. John Hennigan
15. Lyrsa Torres
16. Alec Merlino
17. Nick Wilson
18. Alison Raybould
19. Elizabeth Olson
20. Jeremy Crawford

I feel like there were a lot more people in the Goliath tribe that were pretty irrelevant in this premiere now that I ranked the cast. Overall I like this cast though... liked most that got a decent edit anyway.

[JerseyWins]

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Mike White
3. Dan Rengering
4. Kara Kay
5. Jessica Peet (another bordering green-tier castaway with potential going early </3)
6. Natalia Azoqa
7. Gabby Pascuzzi (lol)
8. Christian Hubicki (I think I can/will most likely get behind him even though his archetype can be very hit or miss for me... his reaction to the vote flip was hilarious and felt so forced/OTT - during the discussion at camp AND at TC )
9. Bi Nguyen (a bit on the bland side but very likable)
10. Carl Boudreaux
11. John Hennigan (unsure but maybe rootable... I think I'd like a John/Natalie duo lasting as well)
12. Natalie Cole (lmfao, she's kind of annoying though so I'm a bit undecided)
13. Lyrsa Torres
14. Alec Merlino
15. Angelina Keeley
16. Nick Wilson (MOST unsure about him but I'm really leaning towards not liking him even though I'm liking the other half of the Mason-Dixon line)
17. Alison Raybould
18. Jeremy Crawford (pretty annoying / bossy as he'd say.. only thing saving him from bottom ranked I see him as slightly comical in a way)
19. Elizabeth Olson (ehhh, nah)

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Mike White
3. Dan Rengering
4. Kara Kay
5. Jessica Peet (another bordering green-tier castaway with potential going early </3)
6. Natalia Azoqa
7. Gabby Pascuzzi (lol)
8. Christian Hubicki (I think I can/will most likely get behind him even though his archetype can be very hit or miss for me... his reaction to the vote flip was hilarious and felt so forced/OTT - during the discussion at camp AND at TC )
9. Bi Nguyen (a bit on the bland side but very likable)
10. Carl Boudreaux
11. John Hennigan (unsure but maybe rootable... I think I'd like a John/Natalie duo lasting as well)
12. Natalie Cole (lmfao, she's kind of annoying though so I'm a bit undecided)
13. Lyrsa Torres
14. Alec Merlino
15. Angelina Keeley
16. Nick Wilson (MOST unsure about him but I'm really leaning towards not liking him even though I'm liking the other half of the Mason-Dixon line)
17. Alison Raybould
18. Jeremy Crawford (pretty annoying / bossy as he'd say.. only thing saving him from bottom ranked I see him as slightly comical in a way)
19. Elizabeth Olson (ehhh, nah)

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Dan Rengering
3. Kara Kay
4. Mike White
5. Christian Hubicki
6. Natalia Azoqa
7. Bi Nguyen
8. Carl Boudreaux
9. Gabby Pascuzzi
10. John Hennigan
11. Natalie Cole
12. Alison Raybould
13. Nick Wilson
14. Alec Merlino
15. Lyrsa Torres
16. Jeremy Crawford (I could go anywhere from here to a couple spots higher from this episode )
17. Angelina Keeley
18. Elizabeth Olson

Something like that but I'm still highly unsure with a lot of people, especially the orange tier.

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Dan Rengering
3. Kara Kay
4. Mike White
5. Christian Hubicki
6. Natalia Azoqa
7. Bi Nguyen
8. Carl Boudreaux
9. Gabby Pascuzzi
10. John Hennigan
11. Natalie Cole
12. Alison Raybould
13. Nick Wilson
14. Alec Merlino
15. Lyrsa Torres
16. Jeremy Crawford (I could go anywhere from here to a couple spots higher from this episode )
17. Angelina Keeley
18. Elizabeth Olson

Something like that but I'm still highly unsure with a lot of people, especially the orange tier.

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Natalia Azoqa
3. Kara Kay
4. Dan Rengering
5. Mike White
6. Christian Hubicki
7. Gabby Pascuzzi
8. Carl Boudreaux
9. Bi Nguyen (liked her enough but honestly a bit meh all in all, definitely on the lower end of the disappointing early boots/evacs/quits this season)
10. John Hennigan
11. Alec Merlino (a lot more potential from this episode)
12. Natalie Cole
13. Alison Raybould
14. Nick Wilson
15. Lyrsa Torres
16. Angelina Keeley
17. Elizabeth Olson

[JerseyWins]

People know this thread isn't just for me right?

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Natalia Azoqa
3. Kara Kay
4. Dan Rengering
5. Mike White
6. Christian Hubicki
7. Gabby Pascuzzi
8. Carl Boudreaux
9. Bi Nguyen (liked her enough but honestly a bit meh all in all, definitely on the lower end of the disappointing early boots/evacs/quits this season)
10. John Hennigan
11. Alec Merlino (a lot more potential from this episode)
12. Natalie Cole
13. Alison Raybould
14. Nick Wilson
15. Lyrsa Torres
16. Angelina Keeley
17. Elizabeth Olson

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Kara Kay
3. Dan Rengering
4. Mike White
5. Christian Hubicki
6. Gabby Pascuzzi
7. Carl Boudreaux
8. John Hennigan
9. Alec Merlino
10. Natalie Cole (borderline one or two spots higher)
11. Angelina Keeley
12. Alison Raybould
13. Lyrsa Torres
14. Nick Wilson
15. Elizabeth Olson

Btw: I think I'd rank Natalia lower than where I did as it was more of a one-episode overreaction, but still great and I'll see where she ranks when the season's over. I'm liking my favorites more and more

[reece(:]

1. Natalie
2. Angelina
3. Kara
4. Davie
5. Elizabeth
6. Carl
7. Alec
8. Alison
9. John
10. Lyrsa
11. Gabby
12. Christian
13. Dan
14. Mike
15. Nick

[MB.]

Thought I'd give this a go for the first time this season, although a lot of these people are close enough that my rankings could change drastically in another seven days (probably not, like, #IWouldDie4Alison drastic, but still):

Angelina
John
Lyrsa
Elizabeth
Gabby
Alec
Davie
Kara
Christian
Dan
Nick
Mike
Alison
Carl

Natalie [will not give you her jacket]
Jeremy [king of breaking his tribemates' backs, breaking up marriages and having beautiful skin]
Natalia [invented stank, your faves could never. Also now Survivor's most iconic Muslim player. Ibrehem is shaking!]
Bi [I'm sure the editors gave her such a bloated edit that one time so people weren't tempted to make #BiErasure puns] [I still will]
Jessica [I think I liked her but I can't remember why. I'm feeling generous so she gets green]
Pat [broke his back for non-Jeremy-related reasons. RIP]

[Wojtek]

(Natalie)
1. Angelina
(Bi)
2. Dan
3. Elizabeth
(Natalia)
4. Lyrsa
5. Kara
6. John
7. Gabby
8. Carl
(Pat)
(Jessica)
9. Davie
10. Alison
11. Alec
12. Christian
(Jeremy)
13. Nick
14. Mike

[MB.]

Originally Posted by MB.

Thought I'd give this a go for the first time this season, although a lot of these people are close enough that my rankings could change drastically in another seven days (probably not, like, #IWouldDie4Alison drastic, but still):

Angelina
John
Lyrsa
Elizabeth
Gabby
Alec
Davie
Kara
Christian
Dan
Nick
Mike
Alison
Carl

Natalie [will not give you her jacket]
Jeremy [king of breaking his tribemates' backs, breaking up marriages and having beautiful skin]
Natalia [invented stank, your faves could never. Also now Survivor's most iconic Muslim player. Ibrehem is shaking!]
Bi [I'm sure the editors gave her such a bloated edit that one time so people weren't tempted to make #BiErasure puns] [I still will]
Jessica [I think I liked her but I can't remember why. I'm feeling generous so she gets green]
Pat [broke his back for non-Jeremy-related reasons. RIP]

A month on, and my Angelove has only grown stronger...

Angelina
Gabby
Kara
Christian
Davie
Alison
Mike
Nick

Natalie
John
Elizabeth
Jeremy
Lyrsa
Alec
Natalia
Dan
Carl
Bi
Jessica
Pat

Blimey, there's less red in this post than a Tory conference

[LemonJam]

something like...

1. Angelina
2. Christian
3. Elizabeth
4. Mike
5. Dan
6. Davie
7. John
8. Kara
9. Carl
10. Alec
11. Gabby
12. Alison
13. Nick


1. Natalie
2. Natalia
3. Bi
4. Pat
5. Lyrsa
6. Jessica
7. Jeremy

[reece(:]

1. Angelina
2. Carl
3. Kara
4. John
5. Elizabeth
6. Dan
7. Davie
8. Gabby
9. Christian
10. Alison
11. Mike
12. Alec
13. Nick

[Jigs]

1. Angelina
2. Christian
3. Alison
4. Elizabeth
5. Gabby
6. John
-
7. Nick
8. Alec
9. Kara
10. Mike
11. Carl
12. Davie
-
13. Dan - slime

[Wizard.]

1. Angelina
2. Alec
3. Alison
4. Gabby
5. Christian
6. Nick
7. Mike
8. John
9. Kara
10. Dan
12. Davie
13. Carl

[iRyan]

This is hard because I actually don’t dislike anyone left

1 Angelina
2 Christian
3 Gabby
4 Kara
5 Davie
6 Allison
7 Mike
8 Nick

[DouglasS]

1. Kara
2. Davie
3. Gabby
4. Christian
5. Angelina
6. Alison
7. Nick
8. Mike

[TomC]

1.Angelina
(Alec)
2.Alison
3.Kara
4.Davie
5.Gabby
(Carl)
6.Christian
7.Nick
8.Mike

why am I a sucker for the pleasant, UTR female

[JerseyWins]

1. Davie Rickenbacker
2. Kara Kay
3. Dan Rengering
4. Alec Merlino
5. Natalia Azoqa
6. Mike White
7. Christian Hubicki
8. Pat Cusack
9. Jessica Peet
10. Gabby Pascuzzi
11. Bi Nguyen
12. John Hennigan
13. Natalie Cole
14. Nick Wilson
15. Lyrsa Torres
16. Jeremy Crawford
17. Angelina Keeley (she could be a tier above but I just think the red tier does her character more justice )
18. Carl Boudreaux
19. Alison Raybould
20. Elizabeth Olson

[LemonJam]

1. Angelina
2. Natalie
3. Christian
4. Carl
5. Dan
6. John
7. Alison
8. Elizabeth
9. Bi
10. Gabby
11. Natalia
12. Davie
13. Kara
14. Nick
15. Jessica
16. Lyrsa
17. Mike
18. Alec
19. Pat
20. Jeremy

[TomC]

1. Alison - I can't even really articulate why I love Alison so much, but she is a gem. She was level-headed throughout the game, kind-hearted, a wee bit shady, and is also a meme queen
2. Angelina - It's not often you get a new player who's quite as unique as Angelina, and we have been on a ****ing ride w Stangelina.
3. Alec - Just a fun guy who really broke out of the typical strong male archetype. Wish he'd gone further.
4. Natalie - Ugh queen.
5. Davie - It took a while for Davie to really show up on my radar but he was just such a sweet guy and really fun to watch. I REALLY wish Davie had taken it over Nick if a David had to win.
6. Gabby - Another one who took a while to grow on me, but I ended up really liking Gabby. I was scared she'd be another Hannah, but she was faaar superior.
7. Kara - I really wanted to stan Kara, but I went into the final realising how truly boring she'd been lol. I still think she had a great social game and was interesting to watch for similar reasons to Alison.
8. John - Very UTR, but I liked him.
9. Jeremy - He was basically a premerge boot scream.
10. Carl - In the words of Reddit, 'thank you Carl for bing'.
11. Elizabeth - Messy.
12. Lyrsa - I liked ha but she was moody and came for QUeen Nat!
13. Bi - Wish she'd survived longer.
14. Natalia - She seemed a bit cold and mean, but she could have been interesting if she'd stayed longer.
15. Jessica - Honestly can't remember a thing, apart from being happy she was voted off.
16.Christian - Christian was fine, but I just will never really buy into his archetype. People try to distance him from Cochran but honestly they share many traits that I find a bit tiresome.
17. Pat - Probably would have been a bit much if he'd stayed in the game.
18. Dan - He was a bit of a scream but also a bit tiresome.
19. Mike - Smug, annoying force in teh game.
20. Nick - As Macie says, slimy. He just had little redeemable personality, and his petulance when the vote didn't go his way.

Although the two ppl I hold most against made it to ftc, it was a bloody fantastic season, definitely top 10.

[Donovan.]

1. Angelina
2. Davie
3. Natalie
4. Gabby
5. Alec
6. Lyrsa
7. Kara
8. Carl
9. Nick
10. Elizabeth
11. Alison
12. Bi
13. Christian
14. Natalia
15. John
16. Dan
17. Mike
18. Jeremy
19. Pat
20. Jessica

Honestly I can't even say I dislike Dan Jeremy or Mike, just liked them least of the cast. I still appreciate the arcs that the 3 of them had and what they added to the season.

Pat and Jessica I just don't really remember.

[Wojtek]

1. Angelina
2. Natalie
3. Gabby
4. Bi
5. Elizabeth
6. Dan
7. Lyrsa
8. Kara
9. Alison
10. John
11. Carl
12. Natalia
13. Pat
14. Jessica
15. Christian
16. Davie
17. Nick
18. Alec
19. Jeremy
20. Mike

[Macie Lightfoot]

1. Angelina (****ing duh. She's the type of castaway that comes up like once every tenth season that you'd be willing to take a bullet for. Easily the best newbie since Jaclyn Schultz, and if you watched the season and still can't recognize her greatness then we just look for fundamentally different things in Survivor)
2. Natalie (alol I actually wasn't buying the hype at first after the premiere but then everything in the following four episodes happened and I was in love. CUT IT SHORT!)
3. Natalia (another one whose greatness was fully realized after her boot episode. Literally pushing Alec back into the shelter after securing his vote, LASHING OUT after her blindside, it just all worked)
4. Kara (alol so a lot of this is just edgic desperation BUT she would've been a great sequel to Winchele had she actually won and it was great to see how she immediately realized what a liability Dan was and then kinda acted on it)
5. Gabby (lmao I kept bouncing back and forth between loving her and hating her for the exact same reason aka her ABSURD theatrics and ability to spontaneously choke on her own tears <3 Asking Christian to play with her was also a scream)
6. Alec (okay so the forced CPN villainy at first was kinda lame but it all came in full circle during his boot episode for me? Crying over the prospect of being a lame unanimous vote was cute <3)
7. Carl (drunk mafia boss Carl <333333333333333 I also *LOVED* his irrational hatred for Elizabeth and calling her a know-it-all just bc she suggested the merged tribe name)
8. John (okay so the whole BROCHACHO thing was a bit much and he definitely faded into irrelevancy after four episodes but he's definitely A Good Person who probably would've jumped up 1-2 spots had he received a better edit)
9. Christian (definitely one of the better nerd archetypes. A little forced down our throats but ultimately harmless and charming enough)
10. Mike (would've been a lot lower BUT he had a surprisingly great performance in the finale to the point where I was almost devastated that he lost?! An annoying lame duck at times but once he was pumped with HTC in the final few days he was gr8)
11. Jeremy (okay so he would've been ranked a lot higher just on the episodes BUT he's been kind of atrocious post show and it's easy to see why his entire tribe turned on him alol)
12. Bi (was a presence... that was liked? Has a cute edgic strip and was alright enough to watch)
13. Jessica (I think I really liked her in the premiere and then she got booted the next episode and I did not give a single **** so)
14. Elizabeth (didn't really care for her but her confessional about LAZY PEOPLE....... AND STUPID PEOPLE was a top five non-Angelina confessional of the season)
15. Pat ("I'd give my left nut to be 36 again" <3333333333 he would've probably been awful had he lasted longer but alas)
16. Alison (I actually almost ranked her in my bottom 3 lmao like she's definitely A Good Person but she really got on my tits with the whole BIG MOVES and SURVIVOR RESUME and GRIM REAPER and I'M ALWAYS THE TARGET bull**** and she definitely lasted like 3 episodes too long)
17. Nick (I actually don't care about him at all while I do NOT understand why Reddit loves him other than being a Good Ol' Southern Boy, I do not understand why so many people on other forums get worked up about him? Like for having a CP heavy edit he's probably one of the most irrelevant winners ever?)
18. Lyrsa (so a lot of people other places LOVE her and I really just don't care at all? Bottom 3 seems harsh but I can't justify ranking her above like...... anyone else other than the next two)
19. Dan (I'm sure some people like him for the lulz irony factor BUT he was actually kinda low-key gross with his attitude regarding Queengelina and that's an unforgivable sin as far as I'm concerned. He was also just a dumb meathead jock and not even in an entertaining way? Definitely suffers from Former Fatty Syndrome)
20. Davie (the CORRECT last placer of this season bc Davie ****ing sucks! He was plucked out of the MvGX cast with all his bull**** about BIG MOVES and encouraging everyone to applaud and shake hands after a game-changing blindside and ****ing IDIOCY like "Christian blindsided me two TCs in a row but I don't take things personally unlike some people so I still want to work with him " and he was probably the biggest offender of the day after TC idol hunts were I ****ing HATED so yeah last place was easy here. He's also somehow randomly a fan favorite and I *do not* get it!)

[TomC]

I literally don't recall Alison mentioning big moves and resumes

[JerseyWins]

I literally don't recall Davie ****ing sucking