[Mokka]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Spoiler:

J'haquen whipped her everytime she said hated the hound, implying that she was lying, hated being the past tense because she thinks he's dead, he's alive so she should be saying she hates him as apposed to hated

I think the implication in that scene was that she ended up liking him in the end despite her longing to keep hating him. I don't think it was hinting anything else tbh.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Mokkajava

I think the implication in that scene was that she ended up liking him in the end despite her longing to keep hating him. I don't think it was hinting anything else tbh.

Yeah that's what i thought too

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Mokkajava

I think the implication in that scene was that she ended up liking him in the end despite her longing to keep hating him. I don't think it was hinting anything else tbh.

Originally Posted by Niamh.

Yeah that's what i thought too

But surely because she said hated (past tense) then at some point it was true, because there was a point where she did hate him so he shouldn't have hit her for lying because it was true, whereas if she'd have said I hate him it would be a lie bc she doesn't now

I think they're bringing him back idc, he's probs still alive in the books too so I think they'll do it here

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Smithy

But surely because she said hated (past tense) then at some point it was true, because there was a point where she did hate him so he shouldn't have hit her for lying because it was true, whereas if she'd have said I hate him it would be a lie bc she doesn't now

I think they're bringing him back idc, he's probs still alive in the books too so I think they'll do it here

No i do think he's still alive but she doesn't know that so she wouldn't have been lying. I think it was because she grew to like him and that was the lie