[Northern Monkey]

Pretty sure Pizza Hut would be well within their rights to refuse to do catering for a Neo-Nazi event if they so chose.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

It's about discrimination, they were breaking the law.

Originally Posted by Dezzy

They're a business, they can't refuse customers on grounds of sexuality. They were happy enough to bake other cakes that would conflict with their beliefs so it's less about religion and more about their own personal bias.

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Also, baking a cake does not equate to agreeing with it's message.

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Again, baking a cake does not mean they support whatever the cake is for, they are just fulfilling their end of the order.

They seem to be able to separate their religion and their work when it comes to other orders so what made this order so different?

Originally Posted by Greg!

Ridiculous statement. So you'd support someone not making a cake in support of an interracial marriage as well just because "they don't agree with it"??

Originally Posted by Dezzy

No it doesn't, it simply means you're fulfilling your end of a business transaction. If a bunch of Neo Nazis had a meeting and ordered pizzas from Pizza Hut for refreshments than does that mean that Pizza Hut supports their point of view? Of course it doesn't.

Two different courts with different people presiding over them with all the facts at hand reached the same conclusion. I don't know what there is to argue about.

Spot on