[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Saturn

Surely a poster can criticise an act justly without being accused of being jealous?

Jealous of what? (do you mean singing?)

Well that would be the case if you were criticising her singing but you said she looks like a fat old lady which is a personal attack, when she looks beautiful and young like every week.

[Saturn]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Well that would be the case if you were criticising her singing but you said she looks like a fat old lady which is a personal attack, when she looks beautiful and young like every week.

No even Simon said she looked terrible last night.So you are not right in your summary of the situation?

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Saturn

No even Simon said she looked terrible last night.So you are not right in your summary of the situation?

But he didn't say she looked like a fat old lady, he just said he didn't like the dress which is not even harsh unlike your comment.

[Saturn]

Originally Posted by LukeB

But he didn't say she looked like a fat old lady, he just said he didn't like the dress which is not even harsh unlike your comment.

Well now he could not say that of course but I am not on the telly so I can say what I think without a huge twitter backlash, this is why i said "fat old lady" as that is what she looked like. If i happened to be an x factor judge i would have said "i think that your dress Saara, is unflattering and a little dated" that way twitter and the daily mail comments would not be in flames. Do you understand this now?