[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Denver

It's disrespectful to the people who are born and raised in African countries when you can't even tell anyone anything about Africa and its very disrespectful to the white, mixed, Asian, Middle Eastern ect Africans who are constantly being told by African Americans that they are not allowed to call themselves African despite being born and living there while the Americans can't even name 5 countries or don't partake in any culture,

I'm sorry, where is this happening?

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

I'm sorry, where is this happening?

The amount of videos on social media of black Americans who have never left the country attacking white South africans by saying they will never be African because they are not black.

You can't claim a nationality for your self it just does not work like that

[bitontheslide]

of all the things to get outraged about at the moment, this is pretty low on the agenda. It doesn't even apply in the UK.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Denver

Not even a thing, just because your grandfather 8x removed was born in Ireland it doesn't make you Irish and you are only seen as part of another nationality if its your birth grand parents or parents born there

Seriously Denver you should do a bit of research before you come out with this crap

Why do you think Biden has an interest in Northern Ireland? The Irish American vote is huge, most of these people have never set foot in Ireland but they are very proud of their roots

[Oliver_W]

Tbh I thought the term "African American" came because people were uncomfortable with the word black?

[Livia]

I thought I was alone here, that I was maybe missing some point. But... no.

[bitontheslide]

the same is true for Scottish Americans who come over here to soak up their ancestors history, find out what clan they are attached to etc.

Heritage, no matter how far back it goes, is a very big deal

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Livia

I thought I was alone here, that I was maybe missing some point. But... no.

I don’t know what the point is at all tbh

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Seriously Denver you should do a bit of research before you come out with this crap

Why do you think Biden has an interest in Northern Ireland? The Irish American vote is huge, most of these people have never set foot in Ireland but they are very proud of their roots

They can't stake a claim in Africa when they don't even know what country they are stacking the claim in and people on mainland Africa actually don't like it

[Toy Soldier]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

the same is true for Scottish Americans who come over here to soak up their ancestors history, find out what clan they are attached to etc.

Heritage, no matter how far back it goes, is a very big deal

We had an exchange student for a year in my Uni residence who had chosen to do his year abroad in Scotland because …. His family had Irish roots on his father’s side, but there were no exchange places for Irish Universities so he decided that Scotland was “close enough” .

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

Tbh I thought the term "African American" came because people were uncomfortable with the word black?

Yeah but like the dated awful word "coloured" people eventually realised it's actually ok to actually say BLACK , it's strange that African American is still used . Obviously it's no where near as cringe as saying "coloured" though.

[Denver]

Also using Scottish and Irish heritage is a very poor example to back your argument up, neither is a continent with Iver 50 countries hundreds of traditions, religions, cultures, tribes ect and to just generalise Africa as black is a very bad thing to do

[LeatherTrumpet]

the crux of your thread premise is based on tiktok clips and

"I don't understand the obsession with the Americans calling every black person African American? "

there is no obsession

and

they dont


So really i am not sure what can be said?

[Denver]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

the crux of your thread premise is based on tiktok clips and

"I don't understand the obsession with the Americans calling every black person African American? "

there is no obsession

and

they dont


So really i am not sure what can be said?

You name one black American that has never been referred to African American?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Denver

The amount of videos on social media of black Americans who have never left the country attacking white South africans by saying they will never be African because they are not black.

You can't claim a nationality for your self it just does not work like that

And you've researched their life and ancestry to assess they're not, in fact, African American?

[thesheriff443]

Denver i could turn round and say you shouldn’t be talking about African Americans because you are not one that’s how far you are stretching this

It’s just another band wagon that people jump

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Denver

Also using Scottish and Irish heritage is a very poor example to back your argument up, neither is a continent with Iver 50 countries hundreds of traditions, religions, cultures, tribes ect and to just generalise Africa as black is a very bad thing to do

Nobody generalised Africa as "black".

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

And you've researched their life and ancestry to assess they're not, in fact, African American?

Most of them have no history of ancestory because records of slaves were never kept and you don't see all white people called European Americans or Asian people Asian Americans, 90% of America is not naturalised Americans so if they want to start calling one race from the continent they think they are from then they need to be doing it to all races or stop and the Americans need to stop acting like they have high authority over Africs when they know nothing about it

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Nobody generalised Africa as "black".

Calling all black people African American is not generalising Africa as a black only continent ?

[Cherie]

Denver the black community have requested they be referred to as African American, take it up with Jesse et al..

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Denver

Most of them have no history of ancestory because records of slaves were never kept and you don't see all white people called European Americans or Asian people Asian Americans, 90% of America is not naturalised Americans so if they want to start calling one race from the continent they think they are from then they need to be doing it to all races or stop and the Americans need to stop acting like they have high authority over Africs when they know nothing about it

You're taking offence on behalf of a continent that hasn't taken offence.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Denver

Calling all black people African American is not generalising Africa as a black only continent ?

No.

And not all black people are referred to as African American.

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Denver the black community have requested they be referred to as African American, take it up with Jesse et al..

But not the black community who currently dont live in America and i have seen so many posts and videos of people who know which African country they came from but live in America who are totally against the term

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

No.

And not all black people are referred to as African American.

Name one black American who hasn't

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Denver

Name one black American who hasn't

You want me to provide proof but we're supposed to take your word for it?