**The X Factor** 2nd Live Show Discussion Show (17/10/09)

[King Gizzard]

It was actually alright imo

[GypsyGoth]

Lucie has been saved from the worst performance this week but sadly this guy will get the teenis votes


Luice sang good tonight!!!!

[arsenalforever]

Backing singers doing the high notes...

i could only hear there voices:joker:

[Chantel]

2/10

[Alf]

****
but he'll be safe

[Tom]

I'm sure Danniis dress is getting lower and lower as the night goes on

[andyman]

Oh dear this is bad.. But yet again silly fans will keep him in.

This show does have some flaws.. Leon Jackson? Wtf?

[Locke.]

Danyl - 9/10
Rachel - 8/10
Olly - 7/10
Joe - 6/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10
Lloyd - 0.5/10 [That was completely crap. Much worse than Eoghan.]

[Wildcat!]

I thought it was OK! HOnestly, not bad at all, becasue I dont like him.

[arsenalforever]

Simon is sooooooooooooooo right about it
the girls will keep him in

[King Gizzard]

Oh **** off cheryl

[Wildcat!]

OMG!! CHeryl FFS!!!!

[GypsyGoth]

Awww :hug:

[Tom]

Definitely getting through now :(

[alchemists1]

Why is Cheryle crying?

[30stone]

Luice sang good tonight!!!!

Should just leave it he wont listen lol.

Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Lloyd 6/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Rachel 5.5

[arsenalforever]

Gameplans have kicked in

[Novo]

**** sake

this **** is going to save him

[Alf]

playing the sympathy card

[Chantel]

Gameplans have kicked in

Like Dannii last year

[Wildcat!]

Definitely getting through now :(

Tha really Pisses me off!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Stephanie]

cheryl is the worst mentor ever.

[Stacey.]

lloyd ... dont worry babe!
or cheryl...
you will be finee.
promiseee. xxxxxxx

[andyman]

Total BS! Ban all the vile teen bs votes!

[King Gizzard]

Shes just gave him loads more votes

ffs

[arsenalforever]

Should just leave it he wont listen lol.

Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Lloyd 6/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Rachel 5.5

oh ben stop it you just love her body

[Tom]

cheryl is the worst mentor ever.

Nah, Sharon was. But she had comedic value

[Adamw92]

they should block lloyd's line right now!

[30stone]

oh ben stop it you just love her body


Who are you talking about, all im doing is adding to my list that i already have that wasjust adding lloyd. getting annoying as hell.

[\PJ/]

I wonder who wrote the script daniel or cheryl?

[Novo]

lloyd 2/10

[Chantel]

Ew the gruesome twosome

[King Gizzard]

Just kill them little brats now!!

[alchemists1]

At least every1 is better than those 2 idiots.

[arsenalforever]

this should be a laugh:joker:

god they got horrible voices

[Wildcat!]

JOhn and edward!!! LOL!!!

[King Gizzard]

How Britney is a diva I have no clue

[andyman]

lloyd ... dont worry babe!
or cheryl...
you will be finee.
promiseee. xxxxxxxHow many tibb accounts have you got?

[arsenalforever]

Ew the gruesome twosome

this must be a comedy show playing a prank

[Wildcat!]

:laugh: :laugh:

[Adamw92]

oh gosh, they're gonna dance too.....

[King Gizzard]

**** it would be so good if they werre in the bottom two

[30stone]

I would love them to perform well tonight, they do put on a show but they are annoying.

[\PJ/]

How Britney is a diva I have no clue
She flashed her pussy Nathan.

[arsenalforever]

the more hate they get the more loved they be

o.0/10

they can't sing

[alchemists1]

Are they serious? lol car crash.

[Shaun]

what the **** is this.

[andyman]

This for real?

[Chantel]

:shocked:

What are they wearing

[MarkWaldorf]

No please no anything

[Wildcat!]

:laugh: :laugh: :laugh:

Genious!!
What up Mark??

[King Gizzard]

OH BLOODY HELL this is awful

[\PJ/]

Oh they have gone gay for this one.

[bronaaaa]

I'm so embarassed for them :$

[arsenalforever]

:shocked:

What are they wearing

louis picked it from his celar

my god this is soooooooooooooooooooooooooo funny

[30stone]

Dont worry Rachel... there is a new low.

They cant dance
they cannot harmonize.
Twins?

[Shaun]

Roflmao

[Tom]

Facebook is going mad with J&E status's

[Novo]

**** sake!

LOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

[GypsyGoth]

The homo erotic twins

[Adamw92]

Oh my god, they really have to go!

0.1/10

[King Gizzard]

They shouldnt be able to do this


its about singing you twats

[arsenalforever]

The homo erotic twins

this is silly

how did they get into the live finals

[alchemists1]

I'm gonna enter my 2 year old next year if they can get on to the live show's any1 can.

[Wildcat!]

:shocked:

What are they wearing


They are wearing the exact same thing Britney wore on one of her videos11

[bronaaaa]

lol, that was deadly

[Chantel]

Dont worry Rachel... there is a new low.

They cant dance
they cannot harmonize.
Twins?

Their so bad :joker:

[King Gizzard]

Please bring back capital punishment

[Tom]

6/10

[Alf]

strictly come dancing has just got a million new viewers

[Wildcat!]

That was brilliant!

10/10 :laugh:

[arsenalforever]

Best performance so far for all the wrong reasons:joker:

[Firewire]

EW.

[\PJ/]

Oh danni fucck off.

[Novo]

1/10

i'll give them 0.5 each

[Locke.]

Danyl - 9/10
Rachel - 8/10
Olly - 7/10
Joe - 6/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10
John & Edward - 1/10 [Better than Britney]
Lloyd - 0.5/10

[King Gizzard]

**** off dannii and cheryl


The show is about SINGING

[30stone]

I have to say though..

I did watch the whole thing..

Seriously it did make me watch, it was poor and cringe worthy, chorus wasnt bad but it kept me watching,

Thats gotta be part of "the x factor"

[Stephanie]

LMAO 10/10 lmfaoaooaoa.

[arsenalforever]

I have to say though..

I did watch the whole thing..

Seriously it did make me watch, it was poor and cringe worthy, chorus wasnt bad but it kept me watching,

Thats gotta be part of "the x factor"


it was great tv:joker:

[Chantel]

It was so bad it was actually good :joker:

6/10

[andyman]

Fans... Dam vile J&E fans.

[arsenalforever]

It was so bad it was actually good :joker:

6/10

oh Chantel i can't stop laughing:joker:

[\PJ/]

So there safe again.

[GypsyGoth]

They were fun.

[Chantel]

oh Chantel i can't stop laughing:joker:
My mum loves them now :joker:

[30stone]

it was great tv:joker:



Precisely, as simon said lol.

Its not just about singing its about look its about entertainment its about likability the full package not just the voice i think.


Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Lloyd 6/10
Miss Frank 6/10
Rachel 5.5
John and Edward 4.5/10

[arsenalforever]

So there safe again.

people will want to see more funny performances

[King Gizzard]

Ive never hated anyone more

[Alf]

They were fun.
so was oncur judge

[arsenalforever]

My mum loves them now :joker:

Mums will love 'em and people will want to see the next performance

[Stephanie]

LOL that was so funny.

[*mazedsalv**]

It was so bad it was actually good :joker:

6/10

I actually agree with you!!! :joker:

It was so awfully entertaining!

[arsenalforever]

Jamie is coming soon
hope he gives a great performance

[King Gizzard]

damnit this is about singing and performing well

are you people blind lmao

[alchemists1]

It makes a mockery of a SINGING competition!
Now if it was a competition for acting like an idiot they would get 10/10.

[Tom]

Is Stacey on after the break?

[arsenalforever]

damnit this is about singing and performing well

are you people blind lmao

X factor is about looks,sob stories and ego's

talent its never been about

[King Gizzard]

if she is im turning off again

[30stone]

Is Stacey on after the break?



I hope so, i want someone to blow me away and i think she will be the last one to.

[Princess]

That was one of the most bizarre things I've ever seen! The red leather suits,the luggage conveyer things,the talking bit!!!! Just Oh my God.

Poor Cheryl :( That song was just too big for Lloyd,I think people should stop singing Leona songs.

[arsenalforever]

Is Stacey on after the break?

She's last

[Tom]

She's last

Best till last :D

[alchemists1]

All I can say is bring back that DJ guy? DJ ? DJ Talent lol.

[King Gizzard]

stacey average solomon :D

[Adamw92]

Best till last :D

woo!!!! :dance: come on Stacey!

[arsenalforever]

Jamie if he gives a great performance should be safe

[Wildcat!]

if she is im turning off again


Why dont you do yourself a favor and just turn it off forever!

[King Gizzard]

free country. ;)

[30stone]

I hope leona is on it this year at some point.
Best singer ive seen sing live.

[arsenalforever]

Best till last :D

she's ok a bit of a Lucie about her

[Chantel]

Jamie if he gives a great performance should be safe
Depends how well he sings, im sure he'll be safe though

[Wildcat!]

I hope so, i want someone to blow me .

:shocked::shocked::shocked::shocked:

[Tom]

I hope leona is on it this year at some point.
Best singer ive seen sing live.

Shes on in November some time but I agree when I first saw it her performance of Run last year was the best vocal performance I've ever seen

[GypsyGoth]

That ****ing eyebrow!!!!

[arsenalforever]

Depends how well he sings, im sure he'll be safe though


he's great but yep depends on the song

are all the guys gay?

[Chantel]

he's great but yep depends on the song

are all the guys gay?

No :joker:

[Tom]

she's ok a bit of a Lucie about her

Stacey connects with you a lot more

and yay ... Rikki :sleep:

[30stone]

Shes on in November some time but I agree when I first saw it her performance of Run last year was the best vocal performance I've ever seen

Yeah thats the one im talking about she done it on another show aswell.

Never seen anyone sing better live in my life.

[alchemists1]

He aint anything but a pub singer he wouldnt sell albums.

[arsenalforever]

No :joker:

oh i taught they were:joker:

[arsenalforever]

Stacey connects with you a lot more

and yay ... Rikki :sleep:

hopefully

[Tom]

Is it wrong to hope Rikki came out in drag with the rest?

[MassiveTruck]

Bye Bye Ricki.

[arsenalforever]

cannon fodder

[Adamw92]

Average as usual Rikki.

[Wildcat!]

NOt as good as last week!

[Tom]

I still remember Brenda's version of this in series 2, now THAT was good

Rikki is awful, I'd rate him below John & Edward for vocals

[Wildcat!]

I quite enjoyed his back to black, but not this at all.

[Novo]

He was bad last week but this is even worse

[arsenalforever]

I still remember Brenda's version of this in series 2, now THAT was good

Rikki is awful, I'd rate him below John & Edward for vocals

at least they are funny but he's serious like straggling a cat

[Adamw92]

4/10 for Rikki

[alchemists1]

They went on about this year having alotta talent but from where im sitting this has gotta be the worst year for talent since this started.

[King Gizzard]

Hes actually quite good.

[Shaun]

i haven't liked anyone apart from Rachel and J&E.
and that was a pretty awesome note from Rikki.

[Novo]

3/10

[30stone]

Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Lloyd 6/10
Rikki 5.5/10
Miss Frank 5/10
Rachel 4.5/10
John and Edward 4/10

[Chantel]

4/10

[arsenalforever]

Simon will give it to him

[Locke.]

Danyl - 9/10
Rachel - 8/10
Olly - 7/10
Joe - 6/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10
John & Edward - 1/10
Rikki - 1/10
Lloyd - 0.5/10

[Tom]

i haven't liked anyone apart from Rachel and J&E.
and that was a pretty awesome note from Rikki.

Stacey is on soon :dance:

[Wildcat!]

5/10

[arsenalforever]

2/10 cannon fodder

wedding singer:joker:

[King Gizzard]

favourites tonight olly, rachel and rikki

[30stone]

How simon can say rachel is amazing and compare her to leona.. and destroy rikki like that is beyond me.

[Wildcat!]

Cry again Cheryl cmon!!!

[arsenalforever]

no sob stories yet

[Novo]

How simon can say rachel is amazing and compare her to leona.. and destroy rikki like that is beyond me.

Come on! Simon is right

[alchemists1]

This should be the week where they can all show off there voices but all its done is show up there lack of a good singing voice.

[King Gizzard]

He obviously sees cheryl as a threat if he keeps saying her acts arent being advised properly lol.

[arsenalforever]

Jaime should blow the rest out of the water

[30stone]

Come on! Simon is right

But Rachel is just as bad as him lol.

[Chantel]

Jaime should blow the rest out of the water
I hope so

[King Gizzard]

Ben is obsessed with Rachel lol

[arsenalforever]

I hope so

so do i chantel

[Novo]

But Rachel is just as bad as him lol.

Whatever you say :joker:

[King Gizzard]

Here goes some more shouting

[arsenalforever]

Ben is obsessed with Rachel lol

its lucie LOL nate:joker:

[30stone]

Dont be silly Nathan.

Jamie shoudl be good, entertaining and good voice but singing a diva song he will have to make it his own for it to work.

[Chantel]

so do i chantel
He's singing my favourite Christina song

[30stone]

I said nothing about lucie since about 5 mins after she performs Steve wdf?

[GypsyGoth]

He sounds drunk.

[arsenalforever]

He's singing my favourite Christina song

never heard the song before

[*mazedsalv**]

My favourite Christina song here!!!

[Wildcat!]

Waaaw!!!!!

[alchemists1]

Love this tune.

[30stone]

I like it.

I like his voice, not expecting angel like singing with his voice, i think he sounds good.

[arsenalforever]

Brave choice of song from Jamie

[King Gizzard]

He needs to wash that flannel

[Wildcat!]

He is quite amazing! damn!

[*mazedsalv**]

Wow!

[Chantel]

He's done Christina proud tonight :thumbs:

[arsenalforever]

best of the nght so far
thank god:bawling:

[King Gizzard]

6/10

[alchemists1]

Best performance tonight by far!

[GypsyGoth]

He needs to wash that flannel

:laugh2:

[Wildcat!]

9.5/10. That was the only amazing performance tonight.

[Adamw92]

I'm not a fan but thats my favourite performance tonight

[MarkWaldorf]

Ew

[Alf]

jamie as arrived in the competition

[arsenalforever]

10/10 performance of the night

stacey really needs to top that

[30stone]

Jamie 9/10
Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Lloyd 6/10
Rikki 5.5/10
Miss Frank 5/10
Rachel 4.5/10
John and Edward 4/10

Jamie has just destroyed everyone tonight, he done very very well then.

[alchemists1]

Thats the way to do it thou make the song your own rather than copy the original version.

[alchemists1]

lol its a bit much Cheryl commenting about peoples voices when she cant sing a note herself.

[arsenalforever]

Jaime has arrived and will have a chance of winning

[Wildcat!]

Great performance honstly. BEst of the night by far.

[Locke.]

Jamie - 9.5/10 [close to perfect]
Danyl - 9/10
Rachel - 8/10
Olly - 7/10
Joe - 6/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10
John & Edward - 1/10
Rikki - 1/10
Lloyd - 0.5/10

[King Gizzard]

My blog will be..controversial

[Tom]

Jamie gets a 9/10 from me .... for his own good he CANNOT win

[arsenalforever]

lol its a bit much Cheryl commenting about peoples voices when she cant sing a note herself.

she wishes Jaime was under 25:joker:

[GypsyGoth]

Jamie 9/10
Danyl 8/10
Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Joe 7/10
Lloyd 6/10
Rikki 5.5/10
Miss Frank 5/10
Rachel 4.5/10
John and Edward 4/10

Jamie has just destroyed everyone tonight, he done very very well then.

I agree with your list Ben.

[alchemists1]

So whose every1s bottom 2?

[Chantel]

9.5/10
best act tonight

[arsenalforever]

My blog will be..controversial

Nate you always are :joker:

[ButterflyGirl]

loved it

[30stone]

she wishes Jaime was under 25:joker:

Whys it matter lol.

Ashley cole is 28 shes 26.

[Novo]

Jamie 9/10

[GypsyGoth]

So whose every1s bottom 2?

Miss Frank and Rachel.

[alchemists1]

Mines would be the 2 twats and probable miss frank!

[arsenalforever]

9.5/10
best act tonight

Yay :dance: i told you Chantel he'd blow the roof off it
the song was brave and he proved Louis wrong

[Wildcat!]

bottom 2 for me Rikki, rachel,

[30stone]

I agree with your list Ben.

:thumbs:

[King Gizzard]

6/10 for me.

[Adamw92]

My Bottom two- John & Edward and Lloyd

[alchemists1]

Or Ricki.

[Tom]

Rikki and Joe in my bottom 2

[arsenalforever]

Whys it matter lol.

Ashley cole is 28 shes 26.

no she wishes he was in her group:joker:

[Chantel]

Lloyd & Rikki/Rachel

[Princess]

I didn't like Jamie at all. Rikki was also meh.

[30stone]

John and Edward, Rachel or Mss Frank.

2 of them in the bottom 2 i hope.

[MiuMiu]

So whose every1s bottom 2?

John and Edward, Rachael, Rikki, Danyl, Lloyd, Lucie, Olly.

I hate this year.
It's awful.

:bawling:

[arsenalforever]

Lloyd & Rikki/Rachel

agree

[bronaaaa]

I quite liked Jamie

[King Gizzard]

I didn't like Jamie at all. Rikki was also meh.


someone agrees with me about jamie thank goooodness.

[30stone]

You didnt think he was good this week nate?

[Chantel]

agree

Even though i cant stand them, the twins have to stay at least another week :joker:

[arsenalforever]

I didn't like Jamie at all. Rikki was also meh.

i'm surprised seen as he sounds like take that do today:shocked:

[alchemists1]

To be honest it could be any1 apart from maybe 2 or 3 of them cause they were all pretty **** tonight.

[Alf]

ricki wouldnt be missed if he were to go
i dont think he has the potential to improve
i think he should go

[bronaaaa]

I hate this year.
It's awful.

:bawling:

Same :bawling:
Last year's was epic, I think that's why :(

[MiuMiu]

to be honest it could be any1 apart from maybe 2 or 3 of them cause they were all pretty **** tonight.

this!

[30stone]

i'm surprised seen as he sounds like take that do today:shocked:

LOLOL

Just no lol!

[arsenalforever]

Even though i cant stand them, the twins have to stay at least another week :joker:

yep the best moment i've seen in x factor history so bad but so good

[Tom]

I'm not missing Louis at all tonight, although it would be his ideal night for his "you look like a diva, you sound like a diva" saying

[King Gizzard]

my favourites tonight, olly, rachel, and rikki was alright

[arsenalforever]

LOLOL

Just no lol!

well take that today not the leather wearing days:joker:

[MiuMiu]

Same :bawling:
Last year's was epic, I think that's why :(

eXTRA this!

[King Gizzard]

-refrains from commenting his dislike-

[arsenalforever]

How good is this girl guys?

[alchemists1]

Is it just me but Stacey looks like a white Leona?

[Wildcat!]

I miss Louis on the Panel!!! I think that why its boring tonight.

[Chantel]

How good is this girl guys?

I like her

[30stone]

I think shes fantastic when she has the right song.

[arsenalforever]

-refrains from commenting his dislike-

express your hate nate it never stopped you before:joker:

[*mazedsalv**]

Stacey makes me happy :D

[arsenalforever]

I like her

she must be good if she finishing the show

[King Gizzard]

express your hate nate it never stopped you before:joker:



lol people will just be like ''**** you dont like anyone''

but i like olly and rachel

[30stone]

Instantly impressed with the start of this.

[Chantel]

Instantly impressed with the start of this.

:thumbs:

[arsenalforever]

good playing it safe but nice

[Wildcat!]

Nicee!!!!

[Alf]

danyl
jamie
stacey
joe


nobody else but one of these can possibley win
all the rest are just making up the numbers

[alchemists1]

She does have a voice likes.

[Twilight]

Olly 3/10
Lucie 10/10
Stacey 6/10 Bit of a let down:(
Jamie 4/10
Rachel 2/3
Danyl 4/10
Joseph 8/10
Miss Frank 1/10
Lloyd 8/10
Rikki 3/10
John & Edward 7/10

[arsenalforever]

she's safe i say

8/10

[King Gizzard]

More averageness imo

[Tom]

She is going to be amazing on big band night if this is anything to go by. 8/10

[Adamw92]

I loved that- 9/10

[Wildcat!]

Fantastic performance 9/10

[*mazedsalv**]

I adore her!!