**The X Factor** 2nd Live Show Discussion Show (17/10/09)

[*mazedsalv**]

Heres the thread as there is none!!

:)

[Novo]

Hopefully Rikki or John and edward go first tonight

that will seal there place in the bottom two

[*mazedsalv**]

A group wont be on in the first 2 slots tonight as they have lost an act so 1 group will be on around 4th and the other around 8th or 9th.

An over 25 will be on first i think.

[Stephanie]

they better not put olly on first, hopefully as he was early last time he will be on later.

[Stacey.]

cant waittt!!! xxx

[Novo]

True Salv forgot about that

[alc09]

I hope the Irish bastards are gone tomorrow or Rikki, in fact any of the boys as they are all irritating tossers.

[Stephanie]

i hope rikki goes, ugh his eyebrow and him piss me off.

[*mazedsalv**]

i hope rikki goes, ugh his eyebrow and him piss me off.

Poor Rikki and his eyebrow!!:joker:

[LemonJam]

cited! :bigsmile:

[MarkWaldorf]

I think Rikki is first. XF Twitter said he was heading to the stage.

[Stephanie]

hopefully, woo!

[\PJ/]

Good luck:
Olly
Lucie
Jamie

[arsenalforever]

here we go:dance:

[GypsyGoth]

:bouncy:

[Stephanie]

GOODLUCK OLLY lmfao.

[Stephanie]

OLLLY MURS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! woo.

[arsenalforever]

over 25's is the strongest group by a mile

[Wildcat!]

lets do it!

[Stephanie]

over 25's is the strongest group by a mile
yep.

[Novo]

Olly olly olly!

[MarkWaldorf]

Omg whitney!!

[Chantel]

yep.

:thumbs:

[Wildcat!]

I think the over 25s are over rated

[Stephanie]

dermot is fitt.

[Chantel]

dermot is fitt.
Prefer Simon :joker:

[Tom]

I wonder how many times that stupid light is going to be used ... and Whitney looks odd

[arsenalforever]

I think the over 25s are over rated

Nah they are the best perfomers

[Stephanie]

Prefer Simon :joker:
i think louis is hot :love:
joking.

[arsenalforever]

Diva night should be the Girls night to shine i reckon

[MarkWaldorf]

I will be freeee

[Novo]

Olly's night to shine tonight

[Stephanie]

ollys time to show off some moves.

[Chantel]

Diva night should be the Girls night to shine i reckon

Yep, Danyl will do well though

[bronaaaa]

Eeeek >.<

[Wildcat!]

Cheryl looks healthy again. good forher.

[Chantel]

ollys time to show off some moves.

Is he dancing? :joker:

[MarkWaldorf]

I see britney

[30stone]

Cheryls always looked healthy.

[arsenalforever]

Olly's night to shine tonight

don't it think the girls will get the big cheers tonight

[Tom]

Cheryl looks FIT

Dannii has a weird growth on her head

[arsenalforever]

whitney been hitting the crack pipe with Bobby

[Tom]

They should have put Clive on the panel

[Stephanie]

lucie is first hm..

[Novo]

Lucie first!

Bad news for her

[arsenalforever]

Lucie first time to show why she's favourite

a Ballad sadly i think

[\PJ/]

Clive needs to make sure his pacemaker is on.

[Stephanie]

she needs to be amazing now, or it's bottom 2 time.

[arsenalforever]

i will always love you i bet

[GypsyGoth]

Girl crush time :lovedup:

[Stephanie]

high notes again for her. :joker:

[arsenalforever]

she needs to be amazing now, or it's bottom 2 time.

she needs to show she's not just a ballad singer
Luccie needs tos how she can groove too

[Wildcat!]

Cmon cute lucie

[MassiveTruck]

Come on lucie!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Stephanie]

awful ;/

[arsenalforever]

a uptempo number i'm impressed

[Chantel]

I hate this song

[GypsyGoth]

http://i23.tinypic.com/eg7fyb.jpg

[Stephanie]

this sounds really bad.

[arsenalforever]

awful ;/

she only started:joker:

[MarkWaldorf]

She sounds bad.

[30stone]

Im impressed, bit nervous at first, but she sounds amazing now.

[Wildcat!]

She beats Diana from last year already just becasue she can actually move on stage and dance

[Novo]

Not very good at all

[Alf]

just not good enough

[MarkWaldorf]

omg her shoes are fierce

[arsenalforever]

her voice is too weak for the song
she's a balld singer sadly

[Stephanie]

oh my god she sounds rubbish.

[Wildcat!]

I loved that!!!

[Twilight]

Lucie 9/10

[arsenalforever]

not good sadly

[Novo]

Lucie 6/10 this week

[Locke.]

Lucie 6/10

Bit quiet and forgettable.

[Alf]

She beats Diana from last year already just becasue she can actually move on stage and dance
are you high?

[Chantel]

6/10

[Wildcat!]

Bullshitt. SHe did great!!

[Stephanie]

lucie: 4/10

[\PJ/]

Nice and wooden at first but she warmed up twas good.

[arsenalforever]

5/10 for me a average singer with a fast number

[30stone]

Im very impressed with that.

If she wasn't so nervous at the start, she would have been amazing.

Still gets a 9/10 was amazing.

[arsenalforever]

Im very impressed with that.

If she wasn't so nervous at the start, she would have been amazing.

Still gets a 9/10 was amazing.

No way ben i think your looking at her legs mate:joker:

[Novo]

im very impressed with that.

If she wasn't so nervous at the start, she would have been amazing.

Still gets a 9/10 was amazing.


9/10 lol!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[\PJ/]

Danni go **** a rusty knife.

[Wildcat!]

I give her 7/10

[Locke.]

Im very impressed with that.

If she wasn't so nervous at the start, she would have been amazing.

Still gets a 9/10 was amazing.

Think with your head not your cock :nono:

[Stephanie]

ben are you deaf LOL?

[30stone]

Whats wrong with 9/10 other than the first few shakey notes...

She was amazing.

[Novo]

Ben has lost his mind

[arsenalforever]

brave song that didn't quiet hit the right note sadly

[Tom]

That was crap, she was drowned out by the backing for most. Her voice just isn't that powerful. She'd be good doing a different type though, Ruth was rubbish last year until Dannii got her doing the right stuff so hopefully the same here

[Wildcat!]

Think with your head not your cock :nono:


:laugh:

It was good though Imo

[Stephanie]

oh **** olly is 2nd or 3rd again.

[arsenalforever]

Whats wrong with 9/10 other than the first few shakey notes...

She was amazing.

your vote but i can't see her getting far cause she lacks the fast song kinda voice

[Alf]

:laugh:

It was good though Imo
for a pub kareoke

[Wildcat!]

Whats wrong with 9/10 other than the first few shakey notes...

She was amazing.


Cmon man! 9/10 is anear perfectperormance. I givee her 7/10.

[Tom]

I think 4/10 for Lucie

[bronaaaa]

I didn't hear Lucie's was she good?

[ButterflyGirl]

I don't think shes got the 'X factor' lol

[Princess]

Loved Lucie! Her dress is gorgggggggggggggg.

[30stone]

Maybe 8 then, i thought it was quality, only thing was the start was a bit nervous.

[Stephanie]

I didn't hear Lucie's was she good?
she was really bad, a 4/10 i think.

[Shaun]

she was okay i guess. 5/10.

[arsenalforever]

I don't think shes got the 'X factor' lol

nope she can only sing Ballads

[Adamw92]

i'd give her 7/10

[arsenalforever]

i think the welsh vote will save her

[GypsyGoth]

I didn't hear Lucie's was she good?

Yep she was good, not great, she sang " How will I know, if he really loves me" a whitney houstan song.

She did show she could sing pop.

[Chantel]

She'll be safe though

[Stephanie]

She'll be safe though
most likely.

[arsenalforever]

She'll be safe though

welsh vote will save and if the others suck

[30stone]

I didnt see what was wrong with that? other than the start the vocals were spot on and she put on a show..

[alchemists1]

I'd give her 1!

[Stephanie]

I didnt see what was wrong with that? other than the start the vocals were spot on and she put on a show..
out of tune, didn't hit the high notes, voice sounded weak and drowned out.

[bronaaaa]

Yep she was good, not great, she sang " How will I know, if he really loves me" a whitney houstan song.

She did show she could sing pop.

Aww :)

[MarkWaldorf]

not too bothered about olly.

[Stephanie]

OLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLY!!!! woo.

[arsenalforever]

I didnt see what was wrong with that? other than the start the vocals were spot on and she put on a show..

ben you fancy her:joker:

[Wildcat!]

I didnt see what was wrong with that? other than the start the vocals were spot on and she put on a show..

I dont understand what people are on about either. I dont expect them to be perfect. These are xfactor contestants after all.

[MassiveTruck]

I thought Lucie was absolutely great. I'm not sure what others are hearing.

[Adamw92]

Though I dislike Olly a lot, I feel sorry for him, first up for his category AGAIN

[Tom]

Does Olly actually thinks his moves are good?!

[Stephanie]

LMAO! his moves.

[MarkWaldorf]

umg i love whitney.

[MassiveTruck]

I dont understand what people are on about either. I dont expect them to be perfect. These are xfactor contestants after all.

Yeah she sings brilliantly.

I think for some people if you don't sound like you're giving birth to elephants you're not good enough.

[arsenalforever]

Does Olly actually thinks his moves are good?!

he seems to love himself

Whitney with her crack voice

[bronaaaa]

I love Olly >.<

[Tom]

umg i love whitney.

As much as she loves surgery?

[GypsyGoth]

I heard Whitney saying "Oh my god its Olly"

[Stephanie]

OLLLYLYLYLY yay.

[30stone]

out of tune, didn't hit the high notes, voice sounded weak and drowned out.

Yeah we see an average performance from olly i bet you'll score him higher than her.

[Tom]

I prefer the dramatic music with the promo vt thing from last year :( that was v dramatic, this years is crap

[Chantel]

Olly looks hot tonight <3

[MarkWaldorf]

Lmao

[Stephanie]

he looks hot.

[arsenalforever]

Olly looks hot tonight <3

he's a performer and he works the stage

[bronaaaa]

he looks hot.

<3

[MarkWaldorf]

this reminds me of scott's trainwreck last year.

[arsenalforever]

ten times better then Lucie cause he's a performer

[Wildcat!]

Gawd I despair at the xfactor tweenies. He looks hotm, he looks hot!!!! Who cares.

[Stephanie]

he's amazing.

[Adamw92]

6/10, better than last week but Olly fails to impress again

[Tom]

this reminds me of scott's trainwreck last year.

(i say yeah) yeah


hahahaha geddit? god im so witty

I like Olly (or did, hes been rubbish lately) but that was shocking

[Alf]

improvement from last week, still nothing special though
better than lucie

[Chantel]

Gawd I despair at the xfactor tweenies. He looks hotm, he looks hot!!!! Who cares.

I care

[arsenalforever]

it was better then Lucie
he sang well 8/10

[Novo]

100000000000000/10

[Wildcat!]

this reminds me of scott's trainwreck last year.

Exactly. not as bad but close. I give him a 6/10

[alchemists1]

Is Louie not there tonight?

[Tom]

5/10

[Chantel]

9/10

[30stone]

Gawd I despair at the xfactor tweenies. He looks hotm, he looks hot!!!! Who cares.


Tis part of "the x factor" though..

He was drowned out by the backing singers during the chorus moreso than lucie.. and not great singer but he performs well.

7.5/10

[arsenalforever]

100000000000000/10

no good but not that good:joker:

[Locke.]

Olly - 7/10
Laura - 6/10

[Stephanie]

9/10

[\PJ/]

Olly!

[LemonJam]

Very suprised. Wow.

[Wildcat!]

You guys are deluded! That was bad.

[GypsyGoth]

Is Louie not there tonight?


He is at Steven Gately's funeral/wake in dublin.

[arsenalforever]

Tis part of "the x factor" though..

He was drowned out by the backing singers during the chorus moreso than lucie.. and not great singer but he performs well.

7.5/10

disagree Ben he was great and lucie wasn't

[Novo]

That was amazing

[Shaun]

pretty good. 7/10.

[30stone]

Watch the show steve its on itv.

[andyman]

Olly 10/10

[bronaaaa]

He was deadly <3

[Wildcat!]

9/10

:laugh: :laugh: Pot kettle black much?

[Novo]

" A different league "

[GypsyGoth]

it was better then Lucie
he sang well 8/10

It wasn't better than Luice!

[Chantel]

It wasn't better than Luice!

It so was :joker:

[arsenalforever]

i'm straight and i taught he was great not a winner but great
i'm not a teenie

[Alf]

You guys are deluded! That was bad.
even if it was the best performance ever you would still say it's bad

[Tom]

Time for the annoying fat ghetto girl

[30stone]

:laugh: :laugh: Pot kettle black much?

LOL!!!

I called that, told you it would be..

What was that about not great singing and being drowned out by the backing vocals stef?

[andyman]

Itz da Urbz!

[MassiveTruck]

He was deadly <3

Yeah. A midget like that moving around could be boring to death.

[arsenalforever]

It wasn't better than Luice!

want tio fight Claudia:joker:

They are cockneys:joker:

[Wildcat!]

even if it was the best performance ever you would still say it's bad


Why would I say that?? I have nothing against him. I am not one to judge by looks, or gender. I only judge by what I hear.

[alchemists1]

He is at Steven Gately's funeral/wake in dublin.

Aww yeah I forgot about that,cheers.

[King Gizzard]

Olly was fcking amazing. what an all round brilliant performance

[GypsyGoth]

want tio fight Claudia:joker:

They are cockneys:joker:

:hugesmile:

I hope this girl raps.

[30stone]

Time for the annoying fat ghetto girl

Can't stand her sort of accent if thats what you call it, as you can hear it as she sings.

[andyman]

Is that Frank Butcher?

[arsenalforever]

Miss frank or Miss ghetto
they seem up themselfs

[Stacey.]

olly was fab!!

[Tom]

I really can't get over Whitneys face

[King Gizzard]

the two 'bookmarks' are freaking hot.

[Scarlett.]

I bet the fat one raps

[Wildcat!]

These girls are fun. I hope they do well.

[arsenalforever]

I really can't get over Whitneys face

the Crack ruined her sadly

[Stacey.]

i didnt like lucie - rubbish tonight

[GypsyGoth]

Is that Frank Butcher?

:laugh2:

That's what I've been thinking.

[alchemists1]

It wasn't better than Luice!

I'd agree with that,he wasnt anything special and I thou Lucie was good.

[Tom]

I'm sorry but she looks ridiculous blonde

[arsenalforever]

look at there Faces:joker:

[Stacey.]

these girls are all very talented

[Wildcat!]

the two 'bookmarks' are freaking hot.



Its book ends!!

[GypsyGoth]

I bet the fat one raps


I hope so :bigsmile:

[MassiveTruck]

Why are they grinning to this song?

[Tom]

Oh here she is dressed as a bagpipe

[30stone]

The blonde one and the fat one arent that good.

I think the mixed race girl with dark hair is the best singer to be honest.

[arsenalforever]

they can sing i give 'em that

[MarkWaldorf]

honestly can people stop calling her 'the fat one.' it's so patronising.

[Stacey.]

theyy sound great togther and... on their own!!!!
shanice looks beautiful!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Alf]

boring

[Wildcat!]

Cmonnnn!!!!! Their harmony is not as good today! But they are OK!

[King Gizzard]

this really is quite terrible

[MassiveTruck]

They should shoot the stylist.

[GypsyGoth]

Oh here she is dressed as a bagpipe
:laugh2:

[lily.]

I don't like them together to be honest. They are ok on their own...

[alchemists1]

I still think they dont gel well together,they actually look like 3 solo singers pushed together.

[arsenalforever]

after olly jumping on the stage they weren't going to look good
but its was okay

7/10

[Wildcat!]

its worth a 6/10

[Tom]

6/10, nothing special

[Adamw92]

Loved that- 8.5/10 for Miss Frank!!!

[lily.]

I'm not sure it does AMA... I thought it wasn't great.. :(

[Chantel]

6/10

[Locke.]

Olly - 7/10
Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10 [Just don't go well together at all if you ask me. Only one of them can sing, not the fat one, not the blonde one, the other one.]

[30stone]

Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Miss Frank 6/10

[MarkWaldorf]

i thought it was the best vocally yet.

[Tom]

love the way Cheryl says book ends

[lily.]

ITA with David...

[andyman]

Miss Frank 5/10

[MassiveTruck]

LOL. Simon is brilliant.

[arsenalforever]

:joker: simon hates 'em

[Shaun]

it was meh.

[King Gizzard]

Lucie 6/10

Olly 9.7/10

Miss Frank 5/10

[Alf]

Loved that- 8.5/10 for Miss Frank!!!
what a coincidance, youre supporting them aswell

[Tom]

why does Simon always have to "take everything into account"

[Chantel]

LOL. Simon is brilliant.

:joker:
I know

[lily.]

I like how Simon doesn't sugarcoat it.

[arsenalforever]

" i'd say 3" simon is class:joker:

[GypsyGoth]

Lucie 8/10
Olly 7.5/10
Miss Frank 6/10

:thumbs:

[Wildcat!]

I'm not sure it does AMA... I thought it wasn't great.. :(


I dnt expect much from them, and I give more leeway to groups than solo, because its more difficult.

[30stone]

Laura - 6/10
Miss Frank - 4/10 [Just don't go well together at all if you ask me. Only one of them can sing, not the fat one, not the blonde one, the other one.]

Agreed.

And its lucie the first singer not laura.

[ButterflyGirl]

none of them are fat, need to go to specsavers

[lily.]

I dnt expect much from them, and I give more leeway to groups than solo, because its more difficult.

Yeah, it is harder for groups.

[arsenalforever]

:thumbs:

Lucie was poor guys

[Adamw92]

what a coincidance, youre supporting them aswell

Yes i am. :xyxwave:

[Tom]

THe fat one trying to get her minute with Dermot, look at her giving daggers

[bronaaaa]

I thought Miss Frank was alright actually

[King Gizzard]

She's not even fat though?

[30stone]

Lucie was poor guys

In your opinion.

[arsenalforever]

i haven't been blown away yet gusy
pretty average although olly was a good performer

[lily.]

She's bigger than the other two, so ppl call her the fat one.

[LemonJam]

Miss Frank = greatness.

[MarkWaldorf]

Joe time

[30stone]

LOL.

Shes not slim is she!!

[Novo]

Olly has been leagues above lucie and Miss frank so far

going to be hard to top his performance

[Tom]

Alexandra's Toxic = most overrated performance ever

[King Gizzard]

bumpage..

Lucie 6/10

Olly 9.7/10

Miss Frank 5/10

[arsenalforever]

In your opinion.

you changed it from a 9 to 8.5 cause people were knocking you
you fancy her:joker:

[ButterflyGirl]

how shalow some people are ,its just sad..