X Factor Discussion Thread - 28/11/10 - 8pm (Live Show 2)

[Marc]

Not that great. but he doesn't do rock so he did well enough!

[Smithy]

did he just scream when the girl came towards him

[bbfan1991]

Brings back memories of Ruth :(

*nostalgic*

Ruth better than Matt;).

I loved Brtiney's version too Claudia:).

[Shaun]

did he just scream when the girl came towards him

I thought that LOL

[Ninastar]

*orgasm*

[Mr XcX]

Miss FAKE 2010 on now!

Cannot wait for FRODO!

[Ninastar]

omfg shes so cute.

[Jordan.]

*still misses her hair*

[Shaun]

oh not this song :(

[Smithy]

oh dear :/

[Stacey.]

This song is amazing <3

[Marc]

This could do wonders for her..

[Ninastar]

oh not this song :(

this is soo the wrong song for her :(

[bbfan1991]

Meh, now Jamie Archer owned this song!:).

[Tom]

I'm sure she said "this is the real me" every week when shes got a new persona :joker:

She needs to grow her hair again

[Mr XcX]

Omg! :(

[Tom]

I'm sure she said "this is the real me" every week when shes got a new persona :joker:

She needs to grow her hair again

[GiRTh]

Katie tries to hard. IT all looks bit forced at times.

[Tom]

This is brutal

[ButterflyGirl]

Terrible

[Jordan.]

Cher should have sang this.

[GypsyGoth]

:lovedup:

[Shaun]

this is soo the wrong song for her :(

I hate it because of how much it was overplayed LOL

[Stacey.]

I really like it!

[tate]

Love the song but singing it with a Monroe whispery voice? No

edit to say that last 30 seconds was fricking awful

[Marc]

Aw.. maybe not.

She's not doing that well with it, its too big for her!

[Marc]

She needs to stop 'woo'ing hahahaha

[Smithy]

*prays*
*fall in the fire* *fall in the fire* *fall in the fire*

[Mr XcX]

Like she is in HELL!!!

[Shaun]

well. at least she has stage presence.

[GypsyGoth]

Brilliant!!

[GiRTh]

******ing awful, Bottom two for her tomorrow.

[bbfan1991]

Isn't this ironic considering the gran stories:p, £25 Sheila will have Wagner as a client...

[Ninastar]

:lovedup:

this, even if it wasnt that good, its still :love:

[ButterflyGirl]

Are they deaf? lol

[Marc]

Aww thats Katie gone. (so far)

[Smithy]

She needs to grow her hair again

It takes a little bit longer than a week tom :p

[Stacey.]

Her best performance ever <3

[Marc]

Aww the crowd :love:

[Shaun]

round 1: wagner > mary > matt > katie > rebecca > cher > one direction

[Marc]

Granny mention. LOLZZ

Her sex is on fire, like her grans loins

[GypsyGoth]

this, even if it wasnt that good, its still :love:

I love that the crowd are cheering :')

[Damaris]

Bless her

[ButterflyGirl]

X factor should never do rock music it's an insult to the real artists

[Marc]

Her hair looks better? Is that because.... ITS GINGER? -ish

[Stacey.]

*Believes her hair is nothing like ginger*

[GypsyGoth]

I thought they were doing another song.

Edit: Nevermind.

[Mr XcX]

Round 1

Matt > Wagner > Cher > 1D > Rebecca > Katie > Mary

[Mr XcX]

Round 1

Matt > Wagner > Cher > 1D > Rebecca > Katie > Mary

[Locke.]

Wagner - 5/10
One Direction - 2/10
Mary - 3/10
Cher - 6/10
Rebecca - 4/10
Matt - 6/10
Katie - 6.5/10

[Marc]

I thought they were doing another song.

They are.

[Locke.]

Wagner - 5/10
One Direction - 2/10
Mary - 3/10
Cher - 6/10
Rebecca - 4/10
Matt - 6/10
Katie - 6.5/10

[Mr XcX]

Wagner - 5
1D - 3
Mary - 2
Cher - 3
Rebecca - 3
Matt - 7
Katie - 2

[Damaris]

Wagner - 5/10
One Direction - 4/10
Mary - 6/10
Cher - 6/10
Rebecca - 3/10
Matt - 8/10
Katie - 7/10

[Marc]

Oh does everybody do this ranking thing? LOL

I wasn't too fond on anybody, Wagner was the only one who performed his best performance.

[Mr XcX]

Wagner is on now!
Oh dear

[Smithy]

Its a phenomenomnoomnomnomnomn

[Smithy]

Oh christ him again

[Marc]

Wagner :bigsmile:

[tate]

well after his 1st performance tonight i have high expectations of him for his 2nd (gonna be sadly disappointed though arent i??!!)

[Stacey.]

Ugh not again.

[Mr XcX]

Go WAGNER! :)

[ButterflyGirl]

Another good song murdered.

[Jordan.]

please just leave.

[Smithy]

I actually don't understand him

[Tom]

Simon saying he liked Wagner all along ... yep everything is adding up to him going tomorrow :( they do this every year when they get bored with their novelty act

[tate]

WHAT IS WRONG WITH ME???? i have enjoyed both of wagners performances this week, and not in that PMSL way, actually enjoyed enjoyed them

[GypsyGoth]

He is by far the worst singer in the show.

[Stacey.]

He looks so much like a perv :/

[Jordan.]

boooo.

[GypsyGoth]

Hahaha they booed him!!! :laugh2:

[Marc]

Might as well face it you're addicted to Wag!

[Danielle1232]

He looks like ma maw.

[ButterflyGirl]

He's not the only terrible singer in the show.

[Marc]

He had the same set up as Robert Palmer <3 :love:

[Shaun]

this song killed Kandy Rain...don't let it kill Wagner.

[Smithy]

Go Away Tramp!!!! [Wagner not Stacey]

[Jordan.]

oh shut up you vile mong.

[Tom]

He is by far the worst singer in the show.

says her who supports Katie :joker:

[sexyb4ck]

wagner for xmas no 1 woo hooo

[Tom]

oh shut up you vile mong.

says the Cher fan :joker:

[GiRTh]

Best of the night.

[Shaun]

oh shut up you vile mong.

what I think whenever you post :love:

[bbfan1991]

Enjoyed that from Wagner.. LOL at his sarcastic laugh after Cheryl has finished what she is saying:D.

[Jordan.]

what I think whenever you post :love:

Um there is an ignore button to put to use.....

[Patrick]

Wagner looks more and more like Josef Fritzl every time.

[Marc]

Not a rock song

Not a rock song

Not a rock song

Not a rock song

Not a rock song

Not a rock song

Not a rock song

[Shaun]

omg this is sooooo rawk! <3

[Tom]

its like they're the borrowers in Alexandra Burke's winners video

[Stacey.]

Go Away Tramp!!!! [Wagner not Stacey]

...

[Ninastar]

*is reminded of small ginger kid singing you are soo bootiful to a spoonful of peas (I think)*

[Smithy]

Christ how cheesy is the background

[Smithy]

*is reminded of small ginger kid singing you are soo bootiful to a spoonful of peas (I think)*

fish finger

[Mr XcX]

Hate these twerps!!!

[Stacey.]

This is really good :love:

[Tom]

I hope they give us a new batch of songs next year, this is about the millionth song tonight that was done last year/the year before/both

[Jordan.]

*is reminded of small ginger kid singing you are soo bootiful to a spoonful of peas (I think)*

oh god :shocked:

[SocietyIsRuined]

This is against the rules, this song is not rock.

[Marc]

I seriously think its time these guys go.

Cheesey photo's in the background make me want to stab them.

[Shaun]

ugh, I hate how self-indulgent this is. Whoever thought it was a good idea to have their faces doing a slowmo in the background needs shooting

[Locke.]

Harry has yellow teeth

[Damaris]

I bet louie calls them rock chicks x

[Mr XcX]

This is really good :love:

:rolleyes: some are easily pleased and deceived by Simon Cowell's FAKE BOY BAND!!

[Marc]

Zain always over does it. He does okay, until the last note.

Harry can't sing that well.

******* off and die 1D

[Patrick]

Go'awn Louis!

Speechless Simon, You ******ing dolt.

[Marc]

Zain always over does it. He does okay, until the last note.

Harry can't sing that well.

******* off and die 1D

[Stacey.]

:rolleyes: some are easily pleased and deceived by Simon Cowell's FAKE BOY BAND!!

What do you mean fake boy band? :/

[Smithy]

Oh well, as a big a **** as he is, at least Louis has a go at simon for breaking rules

[Ninastar]

fish finger

oh yah,

[Marc]

ugh, I hate how self-indulgent this is. Whoever thought it was a good idea to have their faces doing a slowmo in the background needs shooting

Made me throw up..

might be the ice cream and chocolate I ate....

[bbfan1991]

The audience are driving me nuts LOL:mad:.

[Tom]

Louis is epic

[Shaun]

the hypocrisy of Simon telling someone to research their music knowledge.

[Mr XcX]

What do you mean fake boy band? :/

They are FAKE

Cannot sing and mime to backing track!!!

[Ninastar]

Harry and Zain <333333

[Benjamin]

Dannii is becoming jessica and bettiepage 'stunning'

next she'll be saying wurk it''

[Mr XcX]

GET THEM THE **** OUT!

Ignorant little twats!!

[bbfan1991]

Louis is awesome:D, Cowell cannot accept criticism over his new project.. hypocrite so it's alrgiht for him to do it to the other acts.

[ButterflyGirl]

It's not an actual rock song, Louis was right.

[Marc]

GET THEM THE **** OUT!

Ignorant little twats!!

[2]

[Shaun]

Dannii is becoming jessica and bettiepage 'stunning'

next she'll be saying wurk it''

and next she'll be shot for being a cretin? <3

[GypsyGoth]

I don't want her to dance :(

[Jordan.]

Mary dancing *prepares to be amused*

[Tom]

Mary doing grinding, now theres a thoguht for y'all

She'll be performing Beyonce next week

[Marc]

Because it wasn't a rock song, their votes should be halved.


:love: this song Mary is singing

[Smithy]

got breasts in pockets? :conf2:

[Stacey.]

Dannii is becoming jessica and bettiepage 'stunning'

next she'll be saying wurk it''

:joker:

[StGeorge]

One Direction as a 3-piece....seeing as the two dogends didnt do anything. :conf2:

[Marc]

Ohh Mary messed up

[GypsyGoth]

got breasts in pockets? :conf2:

:laugh2:

[Shaun]

this song is amazing.
BRASS in pocket, smithy :p

[GypsyGoth]

This is a bit shouty :bored:

[SocietyIsRuined]

So Louis has a go over it not being a rock song and then uses the non-rock band The Pretenders for his act.

This rock night so far hasn't been rock.

[Loukas]

.. but your not gonna sell records tho

[Marc]

got breasts in pockets? :conf2:

some big pockets!

[tate]

Mary ...... meh

[Patrick]

Does Mary remind anyone else of a hotter version of Jessica Walsh from TiBB?

[Ninastar]

God smithy.

[Smithy]

this song is amazing.
BRASS in pocket, smithy :p
ohhh, that makes much more sense
some big pockets!

:laugh2:

[Marc]

<3 that song so frigging much.

Dannii minogue; your face is karaoke

[Jordan.]

Where was the dancing? I wanted a backflip. :(

[Marc]

'get down with your bad self?' hahahahaha

[Stacey.]

Does Mary remind anyone else of a hotter version of Jessica Walsh from TiBB?

:laugh2:

[Shaun]

patrick :o rofl

[Patrick]

Dannii is becoming jessica and bettiepage 'stunning'

next she'll be saying wurk it''

http://i56.tinypic.com/213f33a.jpg

wurk it gurl

[bbfan1991]

Oh Mary Mary quite contrary:(.

[Smithy]

Rebecca and Katie?

WTF THEY CHANGED THE ORDER :mad:

[GypsyGoth]

Rebecca amd Katie? I thought it was Cher.

[Stacey.]

Omfg are they changing the order?!

[Ninastar]

Rebecca and Katie?

WTF THEY CHANGED THE ORDER :mad:

Rebecca amd Katie? I thought it was Cher.

these.

[Smithy]

fix!

[GypsyGoth]

Maybe Dermot messed up, like the time he called them housemates :laugh:

[Stacey.]

If Cher goes last. Omfg. cmvfrv;l

[Mr XcX]

Changing order is so UNFAIR!!

FIX!!

[bbfan1991]

Maybe Dermot messed up, like the time he called them housemates :laugh:

Referring to all those interesting rumours in the press about what is going on in that house, we need a fly off the wall documentary NOW:joker:.

[Patrick]

Maybe Dermot messed up, like the time he called them housemates :laugh:

Oh god I LOLed so hard at that.

[Marc]

Cher is last. JUST GET OVER IT PEOPLE.

It's not like they just murdered a seal pup.

[hotleggs]

how can mary fit jeans with her size ???

she needs too go

[Patrick]

I was looking for a porno to watch during the break, wut's wrong?

Why's everyone saying it's a fix?

[Smithy]

Cher is last. JUST GET OVER IT PEOPLE.

It's not like they just murdered a seal pup.

I'd sooner they did

[bbfan1991]

Cher is last. JUST GET OVER IT PEOPLE.

It's not like they just murdered a seal pup.

There would be no moaning if it were Rebecca, Matt or Wand:p.

[Patrick]

Oh here comes X Factor's Answer to Rachel Rice and Sheryl Gascoigne :rolleyes:

[Mr XcX]

FIX!!

Saving CHAV CHER!!

Dirty slag CHERYL IS!

I bet she got Wagner on 1st!!!

[Stacey.]

Cher'll be last! :D

[Patrick]

Oh she looks fit.

[Marc]

This is more like it Rebecca <3

[Smithy]

Oh here comes X Factor's Answer to Rachel Rice and Sheryl Gascoigne :rolleyes:

Rachel Rice who won :amazed:

[GypsyGoth]

This is a bit meh.

[Smithy]

This is so much better than song 1 :D

[Tom]

One of the backing people looks like Leona

[Stacey.]

Maybe she should stay to ballads :/

[Mr XcX]

This is so much better than song 1 :D

This

[Jordan.]

As forgettable as everything else she has sang.

[hotleggs]

FIX!!

Saving CHAV CHER!!

Dirty slag CHERYL IS!

I bet she got Wagner on 1st!!!

exactly mr x i agree :)

[tate]

much much better, still wish she was moving around the stage though

[bbfan1991]

Meh:).

[Marc]

Rebecca... could... be.... in.. trouble...

[hotleggs]

Reporting.

why ?

[StGeorge]

Rebecca has been the top act tonight IMO and i was in fear of her for tonights theme....she has taken Rock and rolled it into her own style....class..pure class. :dance:

[Danielle1232]

My nearest and Dearest :love:

[Jordan.]

Rebecca... could... be.... in.. trouble...

:amazed:

[Stacey.]

:')

[Marc]

This.

Song.

:love:.

[Patrick]

Katie :love: Haiti

[Mr XcX]

This will be good from Katie my lady!!!

[Smithy]

oh dear

[Stacey.]

She sounds good so far..

[Ninastar]

really liking it soo far :amazed:!!!!

[bbfan1991]

Much better by Katie:):D.

[Tom]

I can remember Diana's horrific version where she almost ate the mic

[Mr XcX]

GO KATIE!!!!!!!!!!!!

Wooo

[Jordan.]

:love:

[Marc]

I can remember Diana's horrific version where she almost ate the mic

:laugh2:

[GypsyGoth]

Yay! I think she did enough to stay :love:

[Marc]

Simon is so true! It needed to be longer

[Marc]

Katie is better when she's circling the drain.

I prefer desperate Katie

[Marc]

Katie is better when she's circling the drain.

I prefer desperate Katie

[Ninastar]

she has cute lips

[Stacey.]

She really should be safe after those songs..

[Smithy]

she looks like a man :shocked: o_0

[Damaris]

Performance of the night so far

[Marc]

hotleggs...Patrick

Shut up. X Factor is on.

[Marc]

hotleggs...Patrick

Shut up. X Factor is on.

[Tom]

Simon is so true! It needed to be longer

thats probably what Sharon Osbourne said and why she lost her job

[GiRTh]

Its just dawned on me, if Katie goes thru she's going to be one show away from the final. Even though the public have put her in the bottom 2 five times. No simon you cant get away with that. Wagner FTW to stop this circus.

[tate]

hotleggs...Patrick

Shut up. X Factor is on.

:cheer2:

[StGeorge]

I like that song by REM, but that was awful....bottom two for a record 5th methinks. The only thing that will perhaps save her is if Wagner is there as well.

[MTVN]

Katie was amazing there :love:

[Locke.]

Cher's going to be on last :)

[Stacey.]

They're putting Cher on last for a reason. :)

[Marc]

Gillian doing a... trial?

[tate]

Cher will have a tough act to follow

[Smithy]

They're putting Cher on last for a reason. :)

Simons hoping people will get confused, thinking she's last would mean she has the number 07, so people will vote that number instead

[Mr XcX]

Gillian doing a... trial?

Chest.

Her and Shaun will be hilarious

[GypsyGoth]

They're putting Cher on last for a reason. :)

I hope she does great and makes the semi finals.

[Mr XcX]

Simons hoping people will get confused, thinking she's last would mean she has the number 07, so people will vote that number instead

OMFG! I can see this happening.

[Danielle1232]

They're putting Cher on last for a reason. :)

Cos she is COOL :) x

[bbfan1991]

Not bad:).

[tate]

brilliant song choice for Matt, his 2 performances have been outstanding tonight

[Marc]

:love: song... perfect for him.

[Ninastar]

wow. That was outstanding.

[Tom]

If its a talent show theres no doubt Matt will win but he's even more boring than Rebecca

[Mr XcX]

http://i.telegraph.co.uk/telegraph/multimedia/archive/01006/YM-credit-rating-c_1006023c.jpg

[Smithy]

That was good, but th end of that was just him shouting :s

[StGeorge]

Best performance tonight by Matt. :thumbs:

[GiRTh]

Best of the series.

[Marc]

http://i.telegraph.co.uk/telegraph/multimedia/archive/01006/YM-credit-rating-c_1006023c.jpg

:thumbs:

[Stacey.]

That was really good

[Patrick]

If its a talent show theres no doubt Matt will win but he's even more boring than Rebecca

This.

[Shaun]

Matt wins round 2.

[Locke.]

Second half of that was one of the best of the series, first 20 odd seconds his voice was too low

[GypsyGoth]

It was ok.

[Tom]

Best of the series.

Nah, Mary still well and truly owns that title

NsrTcPgKwcI

[Patrick]

Ov-Er-Rat-ed!

[Smithy]

Ov-Er-Rat-ed!

Says the Cher fan :laugh2:

[Stacey.]

Omfg! :D

[Jordan.]

Cher last, ending on a high.

[Marc]

Still think;

"The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face" > "Nights in White Satin"

[Mr XcX]

GO Miss Cher

[bbfan1991]

Says the Cher fan :laugh2:

People have different tastes, why all this sneering at the Katie, Cher and Wagner fans:p.

[Mr XcX]

Omg she looks hideous!!!

[Jordan.]

:lovedup:

[Marc]

Somebody got her from the 80s

[Tom]

Omg she looks hideous!!!

Its week 8, have you only just realised?

I think she sounds qutie good tonight

[Marc]

When is she going to make it different... ?

[StGeorge]

Omg she looks hideous!!!

Matches the performance....bloody awful....and not a Rock song either.:nono:

[bbfan1991]

:love:

[Marc]

When is she going to make it different... ?

Oh she didn't... :sad:

[Jordan.]

Amazing. :worship:

[Stacey.]

Amazing! :love: