X Factor Discussion Thread - 28/11/10 - 8pm (Live Show 2)

[Locke.]

On from 7.45-9.40 tonight.

http://i56.tinypic.com/15xscp2.jpg

Song Choices:

BOYS

Matt
I Love Rock'n'Roll - Joan Jett and the Blackhearts
Nights In White Satin - Moody Blues

GIRLS

Rebecca
I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For - U2
I Can't Get No Satisfaction - Aretha Franklin

Katie
Everybody Hurts - REM
Sex On Fire - Kings Of Leon

Cher
Walk This Way - Run DMC/Aerosmith
Girlfriend - Avril Lavigne

OVERS

Wagner
Addicted To Love - Robert Palmer
Creep - Radiohead

Mary
All I Want Is You - U2
Brass In My Pocket - The Pretenders

GROUPS

One Direction
Summer Of 69 - Bryan Adams
You Are So Beautiful - Joe Cocker

QOTD - Who do you think will give the best performance tonight? (don't be biased!!)

[Locke.]

10 mins left, get your drinks ready

http://www3.pictures.zimbio.com/pc/Cher+Lloyd+Cher+Lloyd+Matt+Cardle+Battersea+TQNea3 KStKpl.jpg

[Shaun]

looking forward to Rebecca's songs, and of course Wagner's.

[Shaun]

as for best performance - I really think "Brass in Pocket" is suited to Mary - if she can't pull it off she's in trouble.

[Smithy]

Either Matt or Rebecca

[Stacey.]

Cher will be the best once again.

[GypsyGoth]

:dance:

[GypsyGoth]

qotd: I think Katie will be the best :love:

[Smithy]

Ughh Wagner has to go this week

[Stacey.]

So three go tonight? D:

[Smithy]

So three go tonight? D:

When did he say that :S

[Jordan.]

Wtf is Cheryl thinking picking them songs for Cher. :bored:

[Stacey.]

When did he say that :S

He said the semi-final is next week, and isn't it four in that?

[Smithy]

He said the semi-final is next week, and isn't it four in that?

I think it's a double this week and a double next week

[Shaun]

-wonders why Cheryl gives a salute every time-

[Smithy]

Death slot :dance:

[Jordan.]

Ugh great way to start.....

[Stacey.]

I think it's a double this week and a double next week

Oh right. D:

[GypsyGoth]

Death slot :dance:

:D I was thinking that too.

[Stacey.]

It's good they're actually putting him on first for once

[Jordan.]

Vile

[Shaun]

:laugh2: @ the jacuzzi shots...phwoar.

[Smithy]

:shocked: No gimmicks :O

Definitely out this week!

[Marc]

Wagner :love: <3

[Marc]

:shocked: No gimmicks :O

Definitely out this week!

First on :sad: could leave!

[Tom]

Lord Wagner moving into a hotel, he doesn't deserve to live with those peasants back in the normal house

[Marc]

OMG I CAN UNDERSTAND WHAT HE IS SAYING THIS WEEK!

He HAS to win <3

[Shaun]

he...doesn't sound awful

[GypsyGoth]

He is a creep.

[Smithy]

First on :sad: could leave!

Lets hope!

*forms prayer circle with Caitlin and Claudia*


and wow this song is apt

[Shaun]

:( you belong there, Wagner.

[Jordan.]

Very fitting song.

[Stacey.]

Very fitting song for him

[Marc]

He is a creep.

Excuse me **** if you're gonna say mean stuff about Lord Wag.

[Smithy]

he...doesn't sound awful

yes, yes he does

[Stacey.]

Very fitting song.

Omfg D:

[Jordan.]

30 seconds?

[Tom]

he...doesn't sound awful

Apparently he's classically trained, I don't know how much truth is in that though

He actually sounds quite good tonight

[Marc]

:( you belong there, Wagner.

This.

[Smithy]

lololololololol Dannii!!

[Jordan.]

Omfg D:

Great minds *dies*

[Jayson]

Wagner singing one of my fave songs = dream come true.

[Stacey.]

LOL Dannii!

[Stacey.]

Great minds *dies*

:love:

[bbfan1991]

Liked that from Wagner:), he so doesn't give a ****!:D.

Dannii still sour about last week:rolleyes, quelle surprise...

[Smithy]

I thought he was saying weirdo :laugh2:

[Shaun]

what the ****?

the song's called "Creep", and the lyric is "I'm a weirdo".

[Smithy]

oh :L

[Marc]

Dannii still remains the best Judge.
Followed by Simon and then the other two can ******* off.

[Jordan.]

Why did no one mention it lasted about 30 seconds. ;o

[Marc]

Thom Yorke will be love that, biggest compliment

[Jayson]

Silly judges don't even know anything about the song.

[Smithy]

I think we should kill another member of Boyzone to get rid of louis for a week

[Shaun]

I thought he was saying weirdo :laugh2:

I always used to think the line was "I'm a widow" :conf2:

[Shaun]

ahh/ NOT MARY NEXT, SHE'S CURSED.
but then it tends to be the one that performs after her that's in trouble.

[Marc]

I think we should kill another member of Boyzone to get rid of louis for a week

:laugh2:

please be Robbie Williams..


oh... wrong band? :devil:

[Locke.]

LOL Can't help but love him. I think it's time for him to go but I'd still rather he stayed than Mary, Rebecca and One Direction

[Braden]

Wagner was great!

[Smithy]

I always used to think the line was "I'm a widow" :conf2:

:laugh3:
edit: I misread that, thought it said window, on reflection, its not that funny as widow



And serious wtfage at all 3 girls going one after another

[Shaun]

I'm aware I keep going on about the curse. I don't care.

[Marc]

ahh/ NOT MARY NEXT, SHE'S CURSED.
but then it tends to be the one that performs after her that's in trouble.

That is fine then. Sir Wag is fine

[Jayson]

That advert should kill itself.

[Marc]

I'm aware I keep going on about the curse. I don't care.

You're the curse.

[bbfan1991]

ahh/ NOT MARY NEXT, SHE'S CURSED.
but then it tends to be the one that performs after her that's in trouble.

The Christmas discount at Tesco is going to pot then:shocked:.

[tate]

I actually didnt hate that, I dont know whether to seek help or not but i liked Wagner doing Creep

[Shaun]

You're the curse.

you have aids

[Stacey.]

Cher had better be last tonight..

[GypsyGoth]

I think we should kill another member of Boyzone to get rid of louis for a week

:laugh2:

[Shaun]

she probably will. She's the only one I'd say is definitely safe tomorrow - I can't see her getting less than Katie at least.

[bbfan1991]

Cher had better be last tonight..

The 5 wannabe Biebers will just you watch:p.

[Marc]

you have aids

you have a fat butt

[Ninastar]

this advert = sex

[bbfan1991]

:laugh2:

He forgot Westlife:rolleyes::laugh:.

[Mr XcX]

Live tonight peeps aswell.

Felt sorry for Wagner.

[Smithy]

Is anyone else sick of the firework instrumental being used EVERYWHERE?

[Jordan.]

The 5 wannabe Biebers will just you watch:p.

On now thank god.

[Ninastar]

The 5 wannabe Biebers will just you watch:p.

oh rly

[Shaun]

you have a fat butt

i'll sit on you.

[Marc]

<3 'shauns curse theory' works for these guys

[bbfan1991]

I'm wrong:laugh2:.

[Marc]

i'll sit on you.

You already did... :bawling:

[Tom]

LOL Can't help but love him. I think it's time for him to go but I'd still rather he stayed than Mary, Rebecca and One Direction

He's come full circle when he does a good performance, no point in him staying after tonight unless he wins the entire thing. let someone who deserves it win it, and I think the other 6 all deserve it in their own way (even if most are crap).

Good to see he's safe from the Mary curse though, she'll be on next? Hopefully she'll bump these out of the competition

[Smithy]

oh well, at least they know who the actual competition is in the show :')

[bbfan1991]

On now thank god.

Toilet break or make a cuppa time for me..:D

[Shaun]

Is anyone else sick of the firework instrumental being used EVERYWHERE?

Yes. You'd think it was the most inspirational song of all time or something, the amount it's getting overplayed

[Marc]

*throws up*

[Shaun]

Yep. 70 backing vocals.

[Marc]

Does Liam ever wear anything different?

[Shaun]

How anyone can sit and think "yep that's just 5 voices" is beyond me.

[Smithy]

Aww lily allens tweeting about xf

[Mr XcX]

*throws up*

is sick too.

[Stacey.]

NIALL!!!! lrwlvkl *dies*

:lovedup:

[Jordan.]

Cant take anymore of this.

[GypsyGoth]

*throws up*

Don't worry, Tesco Mary should be along soon to clear that up.

[Tom]

The one in the middle always does dancing like he's in a black nightclub

Edit, he';s not in the middle anymore, the one in the grey coat

[Stacey.]

That was quite good actually :')

[Shaun]

Aww lily allens tweeting about xf

I thought she quit Twitter?

[Jayson]

What is it with the mop haired one from One D pointing all the time?

[tate]

Louis comments are the same every fricking week

[Shaun]

I'm pretty sure both songs so far have been about 1 and a half minutes long.

[Jordan.]

Louis. :laugh2:

[Shaun]

Louis must give amazing head. I can't see any other reason Simon keeps him.

[bbfan1991]

Louis Walsh is immense:D.

[Mr XcX]

Please peeps do NOT pick up the phone!

HATE THEM SO ****ING MUCH!!

[Smithy]

I thought she quit Twitter?

That was months ago, cos she thought she was over using it, but she came back with a tweet every couple days

[GypsyGoth]

Louis must give amazing head. I can't see any other reason Simon keeps him.

:laugh3:

[Mr XcX]

Cruise ship act on now!

[Smithy]

never in my loife time

[Tom]

I'm pretty sure both songs so far have been about 1 and a half minutes long.

They're all performing twice and the time slot is only half an hour longer than usual

[Shaun]

-giggles at the idea of Lady GaGa going down to HMV to buy her own single-

[Marc]

U2... oh look they're Irish..

Could Louis BE any worse at being a judge?

[bbfan1991]

Cruise ship act on now!

Kevin Cruise's imaginary mother?:D.

I've warmed to Mary a bit...

[Marc]

Mary's FUPA is looking good

[Tom]

When Mary is good shes amazing but when shes crap she just sounds like a low rent Jane McDonald. Shes going for the Jane sound tonight.

[Ninastar]

she looks like shes put weight on

[Shaun]

U2... oh look they're Irish..

Could Louis BE any worse at being a judge?

he could have picked The Pogues :tongue:

[Stacey.]

Same every week with Mary.

[Marc]

Mary seems to be stuck in week 1

[Stacey.]

she looks like shes put weight on

Maybe she's pregnant with Wagner's baby

[bbfan1991]

Same every week with Mary.

Yet Cher gets stick for doing it:conf:.

[Smithy]

k tnx Mary you can leave now

[bbfan1991]

Maybe she's pregnant with Wagner's baby

*Orders an ASDA till*:p:D.

[GypsyGoth]

she looks like shes put weight on

She has WagBo in her belly :')

[Shaun]

was lovely. meh.

[Mr XcX]

Kevin Cruise's imaginary mother?:D.

I've warmed to Mary a bit...

:)

You cannot fault her performance but I just find her cold!

I think if I was to even run up on the stage and light fire to the fat biatch she would not give off warmth!

[tate]

Sorry Mary, same week in week out and you are boring me

[Jordan.]

Best so far.

[Stacey.]

Yet Cher gets stick for doing it:conf:.

Yeah I know, it's sort of the same with Rebecca aswell..

[bbfan1991]

She has WagBo in her belly :')

As Stacey would say.. a combination between Susan Boyle and Ife Kuku:).

[tate]

She has WagBo in her belly :')

Isnt it Logbo now??!!!

[bbfan1991]

Yeah I know, it's sort of the same with Rebecca aswell..

Double standards and all that, at least some can see both sides of the story:p.

[Marc]

Maybe she's pregnant with Wagner's baby

Her and Gillian just HAVE to swap pregnancy stories!

[Smithy]

Phew!

Hopefully Cher gets the curse of Mary

[tate]

dont count on Ireland for votes this week Mary / Walsh, they cant afford it!!!

[Jordan.]

Cher then Rebecca... prepare to be highly entertained then amazingly bored.

[Stacey.]

Phew!

Hopefully Cher gets the curse of Mary

I thought the curse of Mary was proven wrong like a week ago?

[Smithy]

I thought the curse of Mary was proven wrong like a week ago?

No Paije was still in it

[Smithy]

Cher then Rebecca... prepare to be highly entertained then amazingly bored.

Cher's about as entertaining as a broken finger

[Stacey.]

No Paije was still in it

Two weeks ago then? Because one week it failed :/

[Locke.]

Well if you want to beat the Mary curse then you put the best act on after her. Very smart of Cheryl.

[Shaun]

Two weeks ago then? Because one week it failed :/

Week 4, when Belle Amie went.

[Mr XcX]

Hope Rebecca soon goes. Nodding dog!!

One DIREction out too!!

[Mr XcX]

Hope Rebecca soon goes. Nodding dog!!

One DIREction out too!!

[Smithy]

Two weeks ago then? Because one week it failed :/
well obv its back in place after last week :/

[tate]

bottle of wine number 2 now chilling outside in the snow ... got a feeling this could be a long night

[Mr XcX]

OOHHH! This BIATCH pulled a well strop after losing!!

[Ninastar]

N'aww katie.

[Shaun]

her speaking voice... :yuk:

[Shaun]

what the hell has Cheryl done to her.

[Ninastar]

ew this is hardly a rock song.

[Smithy]

o_0

oh dear

[Jayson]

Avril Lavagina :bored:

[Marc]

She's made this song less disgusting

[Jordan.]

Cheryl ****ed up with this song. Cher still doing her best with it.

[Ninastar]

I hope one of them stage lights falls and crushes her like a bug.

[Ninastar]

I hope one of them stage lights falls and crushes her like a bug.

[Mr XcX]

Really bad IMO!

[tate]

its like watching kiddie karaoke

[Tom]

Cher's performances are growing on me but her personality makes me cringe

[GiRTh]

Good lord. Cant wait to see how the judges can praise this.

[Marc]

Avril Lavagina :bored:

:laugh2:

fanny

[Jayson]

This is horrific.

[Smithy]

Cheryl ****ed up with this song. Cher still doing her best with it.

That's still not very good

[bbfan1991]

I loved that:blush:.

[Shaun]

she looks and sounds like the bastard lovechild of Cyndi Lauper and Janette Krankie.

[Stacey.]

Omg :lovedup:

That was one of her best performances ever

[GypsyGoth]

I hope one of them stage lights falls and crushes her like a bug.

:shocked: :laugh2:

[GiRTh]

Laughable comments.

[bbfan1991]

she looks and sounds like the bastard lovechild of Cyndi Lauper and Janette Krankie.

Think Worcestershire sauce:p.

[Ninastar]

How was that her best so far!!???

[Shaun]

How was that her best so far!!???

madness.

[Shaun]

"you've got to take the good with the bad", "pick myself back up"

she's even stole her opinions from Keri Hilson songs.

[bbfan1991]

Dannii didn't mention anything about the rapping shocker:shocked:, she would have been critical if she didn't like it despite Simon's attempts to prevent that...

[Marc]

Cher Lloyd is cool, I think people should be more like her.

Her and Wagner should duet.

[Jordan.]

That's still not very good

Yeah well atleast she tried to entertain.

*waits for rebecca to walk out like a slug and stand in her usual place*

[Smithy]

Rebecca!!!!

:worship:

[Mr XcX]

nodding DOG on now!

So FAKE and BORING!

[Stacey.]

*still dying over that performance* :lovedup:

[Smithy]

Yeah well atleast she tried to entertain.

*waits for rebecca to walk out like a slug and stand in her usual place*

Tried. Tried and failed darling

And slugs don't walk

[Tom]

I think Rebecca is going to get a standing ovation tonight... dunno why I think that

[Jordan.]

nodding DOG on now!

So FAKE and BORING!

:worship:

[Marc]

Yeah but you associate Rebecca with C**K

[Stacey.]

Cher Lloyd is cool, I think people should be more like her.



:love:

[Jordan.]

Tried. Tried and failed darling

And slugs don't walk

Darling? LOL alight.

[Locke.]

That was Cher's worst performance :( Need the second one to be much better

[bbfan1991]

Rebecca's been better than Matt last couple of weeks IMO but there is something quite bland about her:(.

[Stacey.]

Tried. Tried and failed darling

And slugs don't walk

Smithy we know you're gay, you could make it less obvious though

[GiRTh]

This isnt a rock song

[Mr XcX]

OMFG at her song choice!

Hope she breaks down on stage!

Silly BIATCH!

[Shaun]

why've they put a R&B beat over a U2 song?

[Marc]

I HAVE RUNNNN I HAVE CRAWLLEDD I HAVE SCALEEED THEEESE CITY WALLLSSS THEEESEE CITYYY WALLLS

ONNLLLYY TOOO BEEE WITH YOOOOOU

:) Hai

[Jordan.]

That was Cher's worst performance :( Need the second one to be much better

I wasn't keen on it much neither. Will be blaming Cheryl if shes in the bottom again.

[GypsyGoth]

This isnt a rock song

Yep, it doesn't sound the least bit rock.

[Shaun]

this is ridiculous - the ACTUAL song is amazing, and I was looking forward to it :(

[Smithy]

Smithy we know you're gay, you could make it less obvious though

Go look up the word patronizing, just coz your bf can't defend himself :pat:

[Tom]

why've they put a R&B beat over a U2 song?

why not?

[tate]

Jeez Rebecca, your voice is amazing but for Lucifer's sake, dance, move, walk, skip JUST DO SOMETHING, ANYTHING BUT RIGID

[Marc]

This is a little boring and forced..

[Shaun]

why not?

because it's rock week and has made the song sound ****?

[Locke.]

I think Rebecca is the most boring person ever to be on TV

[Mr XcX]

She is a BIATCH!

See animal rights are going to campaign about this COW'S clothes!!!

[bbfan1991]

Rebecca isn't going to get criticised about this song because she's one of the favourites:sleep:. If that was Mary, Katie, Cher or Wagner then people would be going crazy.

[Stacey.]

That was good, not her best by far though..

[Jordan.]

Go look up the word patronizing, just coz your bf can't defend himself :pat:

I wasn't attempting to defend myself :S

I dont really care if you was trying to start an arguement.

[Ninastar]

are Matt and Katie last? they are muh two faves <3

[bbfan1991]

Rebecca is always good but agreed with Dannii's comment:).

[Shaun]

finally. comments about her rigidness.

[Smithy]

I wasn't attempting to defend myself :S

I dont really care if you was trying to start an arguement.

Pretty sure you were, bringing rebecca into it when we talking about Cher. trot on.

[GiRTh]

The shows been sh*t so far. Its going from bad to worse.

[Marc]

are Matt and Katie last? they are muh two faves <3

HAI! :cat:

Matt is singing such a good song. I think I might wee, I'm so excited.

[bbfan1991]

Rebecca has more personality than Leona:).

[Shaun]

bleh.

wagner > mary > rebecca > cher, so far.

[Patrick]

'Households are arguing and the one thing they agree on is everyone loves Rebecca'

k,
So a mother and father are throwing stuff at eachother and the son is in the middle slapping the daughter when suddenly it all stops 'hey isn't rebecca epic?' 'yah' and then it continues?


No.

Cheryl, Just No.

Rebecca is a boring bint, done the same thing for months and better ****** off.

[GiRTh]

Rebecca has more personality than Leona:).Thats not hard. A Gnat with a lobotomy has got more personality that Leona.

[Patrick]

So much Cher-gativity :(

[Shaun]

Rebecca has more personality than Leona:).

I don't think she does. Now that you've compared them I'm thinking they're carbon copies :o apart from their voices - their personalities are really similar: quiet, nervous, eager to please.

[Tom]

Rebecca has more personality than Leona:).

I get the impression Rebecca is one of those people who doesn't shut up when you're good friends with her but really quiet if you're not, I didn't get that with Leona, shes just boring

[bbfan1991]

Thats not hard. A Gnat with a lobotomy has got more personality that Leona.

:D Even Sinnita tried her best to get it out:joker:.

[Stacey.]

Leona > Rebecca

[Mr XcX]

So they are planning on opening voting lines after Katie or Matt performs.

Leaves people a lot of time to Vote for Wagner in their masses!

[Mr XcX]

Leona > Rebecca

Amen.

[Locke.]

Wagner - 5/10
One Direction - 2/10
Mary - 3/10
Cher - 6/10
Rebecca - 4/10

[Marc]

Jedward would have been better.

[Tom]

:D Even Sinnita tried her best to get it out:joker:.

I want Wagner to perform a Sinitta song if he gets through to next week

[tate]

I want Wagner to perform a Sinitta song if he gets through to next week

So Macho or Toy Boy???!!!

[Ninastar]

I love this girl.



oh, Wrong one :'( thought she was the Gucci bitch.

[Mr XcX]

So far / 10

Wagner - 5
1D - 3
Mary - 2
Cher - 3
Rebecca - 3

[Smithy]

omg it's back

[Shaun]

-forgot Matt existed-

[Smithy]

I hate the fact Katie is performing last again in two weeks :/

[Tom]

So Macho or Toy Boy???!!!

Both either as a medly or one in each round

in other stuff, Take Me Out :amazed: I hope Rhian is back

[Mr XcX]

Grubby drunk on now!!!

[Ninastar]

yaay katie is last :')

[tate]

so if Matt is on now then Katie is last again???

[Shaun]

lmao Nicolo.

[GypsyGoth]

yaay katie is last :')

:D I hope it helps her :love:

[bbfan1991]

Funny how Matt after all that ranting about Wagner said it's time to shut up a day or two before the live shows, he'll be safe anyway but it'll just galvanize Wagner's fanbase silly man:laugh2:.

[Stacey.]

Katie shouldn't be last again...

[Tom]

Heres another person with no personality and he always looks nervous

[Ninastar]

*remembers how much she loves matt*

[Mr XcX]

This is the best so far.

[Shaun]

the only one that's been 'rock' so far. And that's at a stretch.

[bbfan1991]

Oh God Matt will be singing Put A Needle On It next week by the looks of things:D.

[GypsyGoth]

Britney did this better.

[Tom]

Brings back memories of Ruth :(

*nostalgic*

[Stacey.]

He sounds so good.

[Mr XcX]

Ended BAD!

[Ninastar]

Brings back memories of Ruth :(

*nostalgic*

Nooo, don't remind me of Ruth, I only just got over that :'(

[tate]

Sounds great, showing the rest of them up so far tonight ... I was weary of that song but it was great

[Jordan.]

Meh.