Jim McDonald vs. Phil Mitchell

[Scarlett.]

Who'd win in a fight?

http://www.tvscoop.tv/stevemcfadden.jpg
Name: Phil Mitchell
Storylines have involved: Getting shot, getting Johnny (no, not Johnnys), being addicted to crack, being addicted to alcohol, burning down his mums pub, laughing at his son, punching lots of people, shagging Shirley (and Grace Barraclough/Makepeice/Aunt Glenda). He also likes beating people down and owning them.
Redeeming quality: His head looks like a bearded eg.

http://www.corrieblog.tv/jim%20mcdonald%202.jpg
Name: Jim McDonald
Storylines have involved: Beating drug dealer Jez Quigley to death, attacking his wife, Liz, attacking Vernon Tomlin on his wedding day, breaking out of jail and fleeing on a boat, leaving the army (entrance into the show), and attempting to rob a building society, breaking and entering into a house where Liz was with her new fancy man
Redeeming quality: Above all else, he'd do anything for his family.

[Stephanie]

there's only one way to find out.

FIGHTTT.

[Kerry]

Fiwww Mitchell

[Scarlett.]

I'd say Big Jim, he's pretty scary when angry xD

2AIe2y2NrFs

[Stacey.]

Phil :love:

[Novo]

Phil

Jim can hardly walk can he? :joker:

[Scarlett.]

Phil

Jim can hardly walk can he? :joker:

Catch yerself on Novo, so it is

[Shaun]

-thought Jim was dead-

[Scarlett.]

-thought Jim was dead-

lol he's an occasional character these days, he was last seen at Chrimbo and comes back next month :p

[Kerry]

Fiww doesn't think about anyone else though. Jim does so doesn't go as far

[Ninastar]

-awaits Patrick rant on why Phil Mitchell is better-

[Scarlett.]

Fiww doesn't think about anyone else though. Jim does so doesn't go as far

That's true, but if it was a full on fist fight, I bet Jim could beat Phil :blush:

-keeps quiet about the fact he also wants to see Patrick's reply-

[Callum]

Phil Mitchell

[Josy]

Phil.

[Jords]

Phillip.

[Scarlett.]

Me and Jim will just sit in this corner with him eating his Ulster Fry, so we will, while you lot catch yerself on :spin:

[patsylimerick]

Catch yerself on Novo, so it is

:joker::joker:

Jim boy all the way. Phil's a dried up old junkie these days; Big Jim'll still be thumpin' 'em when he's 90................

[Niamh.]

Jim would kick his ass, Phil is a pussy

[bbfan1991]

Phil Mitchell:).

[Josy]

Jim would kick his ass, Phil is a pussy

:joker::joker:

[Novo]

Jim would kick his ass, Phil is a pussy

How.. he can barely walk let alone throw a punch.. Jim would be waffling on like he normally does in some accent no one can understand.. and then Phil would throw a right hook, KO.

[Scarlett.]

How.. he can barely walk let alone throw a punch.. Jim would be waffling on like he normally does in some accent no one can understand.. and then Phil would throw a right hook, KO.

Jim can walk :joker: and Jim spent 8 years in the big house, so he did, what time has Phil done?

[bbfan1991]

Grant won't probably be as aard now he has calmed down and has Courtney to look after:).

[Novo]

Jim can walk :joker: and Jim spent 8 years in the big house, so he did, what time has Phil done?

Phil ain't stupid enough to get himself locked up for 8 years.. he is obviously knows how to avoid the law better then Jim

[Scarlett.]

Phil ain't stupid enough to get himself locked up for 8 years.. he is obviously knows how to avoid the law better then Jim

Jim only got sent down because Jez was stupid enough to puncture his own lung :joker:

[bbfan1991]

Phil ain't stupid enough to get himself locked up for 8 years.. he is obviously knows how to avoid the law better then Jim

Those bent lawyers certainly worked their magic:D.

[Niamh.]

How.. he can barely walk let alone throw a punch.. Jim would be waffling on like he normally does in some accent no one can understand.. and then Phil would throw a right hook, KO.

2 words Jez Quigley. Phil is all mouth no trousers.

[Novo]

2 words Jez Quigley. Phil is all mouth no trousers.

Phil is younger then Jim Mcdonald but he has already had more on screen fights then him.. Jim is a pussy.

[Niamh.]

Phil is younger then Jim Mcdonald but he has already had more on screen fights then him.. Jim is a pussy.

Jim is hard, ex army, he doesn't go looking for fights but when they find him they're sorry they did:nono:

[Novo]

Jim is hard, ex army, he doesn't go looking for fights but when they find him they're sorry they did:nono:

Jim is past it and has nothing on Phil.. the sooner you accept this the better

[Niamh.]

Jim is past it and has nothing on Phil.. the sooner you accept this the better

Phil is passed it too, a heart attack and asking for Ian Beales help:nono:

[Novo]

Phil is passed it too, a heart attack and asking for Ian Beales help:nono:

Jim was getting bummed in the showers for 8 years..

[Niamh.]

Jim was getting bummed in the showers for 8 years..

I pity the fool who tries to bum big Jim:nono:

[Scarlett.]

Jim was getting bummed in the showers for 8 years..

Jim had soap on a rope in there, so you're wrong ;)

[Novo]

Jim had soap on a rope in there, so you're wrong ;)

the rope snapped

[Scarlett.]

the rope snapped

Big Jim doesnt need soap

[Niamh.]

Big Jim doesnt need soap

http://www.freesmileys.org/smileys/smiley-laughing001.gif (http://www.freesmileys.org/smileys.php)

[Josy]

Big Jim doesnt need soap

:joker::joker:

[Novo]

He needs all the soap he can get... smelly bastard :bored:

[Niamh.]

He needs all the soap he can get... smelly bastard :bored:

he smells of warrior.

[Scarlett.]

He needs all the soap he can get... smelly bastard :bored:
He's not smelly, that's his scent, it brings all the girls to the yard

[patsylimerick]

Jez threatened Jim's son - and died. The cracked vicar who threatened Phil's son got tired of waiting and killed himself.
Oh, and Phil's even afraid of Shirley. Mind you, I think Jim would be too