Would Secret Story Have Being Successful?

[Pronshi]

If channel 5 did this.
Left CBB/BB till jan 2012
Started A Celeb Secret Story (Jan/feb)

Normal Secret Story in June/July - August/September

Would it have being a successful show?
-including Livefeed
-No editing like now

Would we have seen heights of 3 million viewers + ?

I personally think it may have done well :)

(Die hard cult fans off BB would follow)
Non fans would give it a go

Good show = hooked audience

[Marc]

Well I like to think I'm a die hard BB UK fan but I don't know how SS differs; care to explain for us silly people?

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

I've never even heard of secret story.:conf:

[Chuck]

Secret Story is like the French version of BB, Portugal has it too. :suspect:

Basically all the housemates have secrets and no-one should find out, something like that.

[Pronshi]

Well I like to think I'm a die hard BB UK fan but I don't know how SS differs; care to explain for us silly people?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_Story_(2007)
french one is very huge with 1 every year form 2007

[Pronshi]

Secret Story is like the French version of BB, Portugal has it too. :suspect:

Basically all the housemates have secrets and no-one should find out, something like that.

correct :blush:

[Pronshi]

I've never even heard of secret story.:conf:

here
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secret_Story_2007_(France)
it isnt too different but still different :)

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

Doesn't seem much different to BB of what i've just read on Wikipedia, but i've never seen it before. So i would have to say i dont know, if it work in the UK, cause we are used to BB.

[Jordan.]

Not on C5.

[Ryan.]

Not on C5.

I actually agree, people seem unwilling to give new shows a chance on c5. It has sort of a stigma for some reason...

[Pronshi]

I actually agree, people seem unwilling to give new shows a chance on c5. It has sort of a stigma for some reason...

yea watching channel 5 may kill their rep :)
Im not joking lol

[Marc]

Some of these probably do have big secrets, Rebeckah's was that she likes to urinate on her victims. Secrets out!

[fingers]

Some of these probably do have big secrets, Rebeckah's was that she likes to urinate on her victims. Secrets out!

Secret out ought to be an automatic eviction!!:joker:

[lostalex]

I'm looking forward to seeing Secret Story Australia. It will be the first english language version of Secret Story i think.

If it's successful in Australia, then maybe an American Network might pick it up and do an AMerican version of SS. I hope so!

[AJ.]

Don't like the format, I don't want a gameshow. They should just aim for BB3/5.

[lostalex]

Secret Story is like the French version of BB, Portugal has it too. :suspect:

Basically all the housemates have secrets and no-one should find out, something like that.

There is a Canadian version too i think, but it's in french language.

[lostalex]

Some of these probably do have big secrets, Rebeckah's was that she likes to urinate on her victims. Secrets out!

Victims? she pissed on some pervert guy (maybe french, maybe german, she didn't say his nationality) i don't think she wanted to piss on him though. lol

[Pronshi]

Don't like the format, I don't want a gameshow. They should just aim for BB3/5.

well channel 5 have tried that and its the worst ratings in history!

[Connected]

OMG we had 1 in the Netherlands this year...
It would be the show of the year, but in the end only 250.000 people were watching

I'm still glad that I can watch Big Brother from the UK :D!

[Vladimir]

I'm not sure, maybe. I'd rather see an UK version of BBUSA.

[Jords]

I think it would, the concept needs changing to spark re-interest, and SS would have been enough.