Aaron vs Josie Gibson?

[Scream]

Josie was from the last Big Brother and was a popular winner so I wanted to see who people preferred.

[Roy Mars III]

I perfer every housemate this year more than Josie. Even Rebeckah.

[Doogle]

Wat

[Marmalite]

I liked Josie right in the beginning but not even half-way through the show I started detested her!

[Patricia4]

Not Josie no thankyou.

[saigon]

Aaronn and Josie are 2 of the worst HMs ever. They want drowning the pair of them.

[Samuel.]

Aaron of course.

Josie ruined a potentially legendary housemate in John James :nono:

[Maia]

Aaron >

[Bollo]

Aaron definately, Josie was ok at first but by the end she annoyed me so much i woud've preferred Sam Pepper to win just to see the look on her face

[Gillian-73]

She wasn't popular with me! anybody over josie but most certainly aaron.

[Callum]

Aaron. Josie was so annoying.

[Pyramid*]

Pretty much a no-brainer, there simply is no comparison.

one was a fat, lazy, filthy, thick slob - the other is intelligent, cares for both his personal hygiene and presentation and has great wit and high morals.

[icecakes]

Aaron , Josie was one of the worst winners ever:bored:

[Locke.]

Tom would be a better winner than Josie

[StraightEdge695]

aaron of course =)

[MeMyselfAndI]

Aaron! Although Josie was one of the best HMs of a dire series

[joeysteele]

Although Josie won BB last year she in effect got boring to watch once she took up with John James and wasted her BB experience.
I voted for Aaron.

[Lex]

Both clever players!...But Aaron is eminently more likable than Josie!

[Razor]

Josie is the only BB winner I don't like.

[The Human Santapede]

Aaron, he is nowhere near as grating as Josie is.

[vesavius]

Josie was from the last Big Brother and was a popular winner so I wanted to see who people preferred.

lol not here and DS she wasn't and another great example of this forum's cliques getting it so wrong.

The result is predictable.

[SoBig]

Aaron. Never really liked Josie.

[RyanChaddy]

I choose Josie.
Due to Aaron's arrogance. This is just MY opinion. No one else's, Aaron's one of the most pathetic housemates this year, he's not the worst though.

[karezza]

Josie is a 40-year-old woman with dodgy teeth, manky hair & a weight problem. No wonder JJ dumped her.

[Colbert-Bump]

Aaron.

[Black Dagger]

Josie was and is a disgusting, fat slob.

[Novo]

Just the mere sight of her name makes me ill

[Josy]

Aaron

[ChristmasNeeve]

Aaron

[alex_front2]

Hated Josie and everything she stands for. I despise women who make a virtue of being overweight 'Ooooh I am a curvey girl and therefore women love me, ALL men hate skinny girls, doing it for the larger ladies BLAH BLAH BLAH'. Erm wrong on all counts, love.

the only thing these 2 have in common is that they are from the west country.

[ozzyshaggah]

josie of course
aaron is a pathetic arrogant prat

[HBB1508]

Aaron - couldn't stand JJJ they ruined BB for me.

[BigBrotherfan4ever]

I liked Josie & for me I thought from day 1 she would won. But I have said I really really like Aaron, I think he would be a better winner, cause he Is much more involved with everything in the house, much more than Josie ever was IMHO.

[tweetypiebabe1]

Aaron

I initially liked Josie but the JJJ thing got way too much and she literally just stayed in bed all day so she didn't entertain me much but I knew she would've won regardless and had she stayed, she would've won ultimate BB as well which would have been unfortunate as there were much more bigger and better characters who did get to the final :)

[Razor]

couldn't stand JJJ they ruined BB for me.

+1

[fruit_cake]

prefer Aaron to Josie

[Scream]

josie..

[MaratSafinForever]

Josie was a fat mess.

[Cheddarcakes]

Could never stand Josie

[BJ]

Aaron

No contest. I can't stand Josie.