X Factor Live; Elimination #4 - 8pm [Discussion Thread]

[Jords]

The Risk 5/10
Johnny 6/10
Sophie 6/10
Marcus 6/10
Misha B 7/10
Janet Devlin 8/10
Frankie 5/10
Kitty 8/10
Little Mix 8.5/10
Craig 7/10

The Risk were very average tonight but theyd hadnt long to adjust to the shift around.

[Marc]

Craig played it very safe. Not happy with his performance. Neither was I happy with Sophies :nono:

Little Mix, Misha B and Johnny were the best acts tonight.

[IheartBB]

This Risk - I wouldn’t have even noticed there was a new member if I wasn’t told beforehand. Fairly uninteresting performance and dodgy vocals from the Scottish dude. Charlie and Derry make this band and need to be used more efficiently if they want to win -- 4/10
Johnny - This is the kind of song he should have been singing from the get go. I’m not a fan of the chipmunk-like voice but at least he’s lost the joke tag -- 3/10
Sophie - Loved the production and thought the song choice would work for her. It didn‘t. By far her weakest performance -- 2/10
Marcus - Probably the most natural vocalist in the competition. Wasn’t crazy about the production but he should be safe for another week -- 5/10
Misha - Another solid performance. Quirky, interesting and original -- 6/10
Janet - Terrible start, okay middle, terrible ending. Her attempt at eerie just sounded flat -- 2/10
Frankie - The rockstar act is tiresome and transparent. And seeing Gary Barlow rock along is just too cringe-worthy for words. His best vocal performance to date though - 4/10
Kitty - Good lord she’s good. She’s been unbelievably consistent for the past three weeks -- 8/10
Little Mix - Don’t like the new name but I loved this performance! Great production, surprisingly good harmonies and a very impressive solo by the blonde -- 8/10
Craig - Awkward stage presence and a rather tame choice of song. Good vocals but he's missing a spark -- 6/10

[Jordan.]

Misha B - 9/10
Little Mix - 8/10
Kitty - 8/10
Craig - 8/10
Sophie - 7/10
Johnny - 7/10
Janet - 7/10
Marcus - 6/10
Frankie - 6/10
The Risk - 5/10

[Locke.]

Is Alexandra on tonights show?

[nanaimo]

Little Mix 9/10 (really good last night, hate the name though)

Janet 8/10 (wasn't her best performance but still vocally brillant)

Marcus 8/10 (loved this, a really nice guy and great performer)

Johnny 7/10 (people should stop judging him on his appearance and listen to his voice, wonderful)

Kitty 7/10 (great voice but very predictable)

Craig 6/10 (Good singer but again very predictable)

Misha B 5/10 (very talented but can't enjoy her on stage as she comes across very arrogant and very unlikeable)

The Risk 4/10 (a terrible song choice and very dissapointing)

Sophie 3/10 (don't know what to say about this girl, she has no personailty and find her boring, good voice though and she murdered the song)

Frankie 1/10 (Gave him 1 because it was an improvement from last week, but sadly will never be a Marc Bolan, Jim Morrison Rock-God and the answer to your question is Go!)

Bottom 2 Frankie-Sophie

[Tom]

Is Alexandra on tonights show?

Yeah, seems a bit pointless though and not really sure Alex should be voting. If one of Kelly's acts are in the bottom 2 then they should just automatically give them a vote like when Louis missed a show. If Kelly has 2 acts in the bottom 2 (unlikely) then take it to deadlock if the judges have a 2-1 split and if Kelly doesn't have any acts in the bottom 2, then there doesn't need to be a fourth vote and it should just go to majority vote with the other 3.

[IheartBB]

It would be weird if Alexandra votes on her behalf, especially if it's two girls in the bottom two (unlikely, I know, but still...)

[Smithy]

-cba with new thread-

QOTD: Was Alexandra Burke a suitable replacement/fill in?

[Smithy]

-cba with new thread-

QOTD: Was Alexandra Burke a suitable replacement/fill in?

[GypsyGoth]

qotd: She had more opinions than I thought she would, and she wasn't afraid to speak her mind. I think she's good, but I'd rather have Kelly.

[Jordan.]

QOTD: idc, CHER :amazed:

[Locke.]

Can't really get into the show this year, don't know why.. think it might just be because big brother is on aswell and I can only really get into one thing at a time.

Looking forward to Cher though :worship:

Is Olly on next week aswell?

[Maia]

QOTD - Yes she was

[Tom]

I'm a Celebrity soon :amazed:

[Callum]

OK dot com thank you :laugh2:

[Doogle]

QOTD: yeah

[Tom]

I still cant get used to and hate the new theme tune...

[Doogle]

So Alexandra is making a decision on the Bottom 2?!

[Tom]

I love to see Tulisa trying to walk in heels

[Jordan.]

**** sake is this **** forum ever not slow

[Smithy]

Is Olly on next week aswell?

nope http://www.606studios.com/bendisboard/images/smilies/smug.gif

[Doogle]

THIS SONG :lovedup:

[GypsyGoth]

Johnny is awful at miming.

[Maia]

I'm a Celebrity soon :amazed:

Can't wait :amazed:

[Harry!]

I hate how the group melody theme never goes with the theme from the night before.

[Tom]

I hate it when Gary tries to act like he's 18

'mate...'

[Jordan.]

ahhh Cher :amazed:

[Smithy]

Gary is sf deluded

and ew cher lloyd :bored:

[Doogle]

Cher Lloyd :lovedup::lovedup::lovedup:

[Jordan.]

oh my god.

[Doogle]

Why does she sound bad, when I heard her live at the Teen Awards she was amazing :bored:

[Smithy]

:laugh2:

[Tom]

Cher cannot sing live. She sounds like her voice is about to break

[Maia]

Someone call 999 quick I think Jordan might be dying

[Jordan.]

She doesn't sound good singing this live tbh but look at her :worship:

[Jordan.]

Someone call 999 quick I think Jordan might be dying

http://fun.resplace.net/Emoticons/Dead/DeadBanana.gif

[Tom]

She doesn't sound good singing this live tbh but look at her :worship:

Say that again when Nicole is on :amazed:

[Doogle]

She sounds a lot better now, but omfg that was awful.

[GypsyGoth]

Fair play to her, I never thought she would be back on the xf stage after releasing an album.

[Harry!]

Swagger Jagger >

[Locke.]

Amazing :worship:

Her boyfriend is one lucky bastard

[Smithy]

well that was painful

[Jordan.]

second #1 on the way

[Doogle]

Awww she looks so cute :love:

[Callum]

Cher Lloyd was bad

[Marc]

:love: Cher

[Jords]

I liked Cher's performance tbh.

[IheartBB]

I'd give that a 2/10 if she was still a contestant. Hardly giving the show a good rep.

[Callum]

Nicole :love:

[Jordan.]

Alexandra needs to stay because she hates Frankie :worship:

[Tom]

Nicole :amazed:

[Locke.]

Time to pause it so I can fast forward this awful womans performance

[Maia]

Nicole Scherzinger bores me for some reason. Not sure why.

[Jordan.]

What is this boring song

[Tom]

:lovedup:

She really should be on our panel

[GypsyGoth]

This reminds me a bit of Firework.

[Smithy]

omg is this bitch meowing

[Maia]

Wtf..

[Marc]

Slow parts of this song > Trancey parts

[Marc]

Just give the results...

[Tom]

amazing :worship:

[Maia]

Come on now, on with the results.

[Smithy]

nicole and cher were both **** omg

Bring on Florence next week and show them how it's done

[Doogle]

Boring performance.

[Visage]

Nicole Scherzinger bores me for some reason. Not sure why.

She's really dull to me.

[Locke.]

Frankie and Sophie/Johnny in the bottom 2

[Callum]

I wish people would just mime because they all usually sound so **** singing live.

[Jordan.]

nicole and cher were both **** omg

Bring on Florence next week and show them how it's done

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z341/jordannn__/Cher%20Lloyd%20GIF/getout.gif

[Marc]

Predictable I know but.. Frankie/Kitty bottom two. With a small chance of Marcus/Sophie/Little Mix being against Kitty instead...

[Doogle]

Florence is so boring though.

[Maia]

Florence is so boring though.

Florence is amazing :nono:

[Jordan.]

I wish people would just mime because they all usually sound so **** singing live.

What a horrible suggestion, no one will be taking tips from you or the disgrace in your sig.

[Doogle]

She's a great singer but ugh boring

[Marc]

Florence is so boring though.

But her music makes my heart melt :lovedup:

[Callum]

What a horrible suggestion, no one will be taking tips from you or the disgrace in your sig.

Like I care :laugh:

Britney miming >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Cher singing live

[Locke.]

What a horrible suggestion, no one will be taking tips from you or the disgrace in your sig.

:joker::joker:

[Locke.]

Like I care :laugh:

Britney miming >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Cher singing live

Frankie and Johnny >>>>>> Britney

[Smithy]

http://i1185.photobucket.com/albums/z341/jordannn__/Cher%20Lloyd%20GIF/getout.gif

Look who's popular!

[Tom]

Its weird seeing Alexandra walk out with her own category

[GypsyGoth]

:eek:

[Smithy]

yay

[Tom]

frankie & Sophie bottom 2

[Callum]

Yes! (for Kitty)

[Doogle]

:amazed:

[GypsyGoth]

Please say Little Mix.

[Harry!]

Like I care :laugh:

Britney miming >>>>>>>>>>>>>> Cher singing live

Britney Live <3

Yey at Krazy Kitty getting though!

[Jordan.]

:suspect:

[Doogle]

Craig :D

[Smithy]

ugh :bored:

[Maia]

Should've predicted Frankie rather than The Risk for the bottom two. Didn't think The Risk would get a lot of votes though, they seemed to fade into the background.

[Maia]

Little Mix! :worship:

[Smithy]

:amazed:

[Jordan.]

yay :amazed:

[GypsyGoth]

YES!!! WoooHoooo!!

[Ninastar]

yaaaaaaaaaaaay omffg

[Smithy]

http://i.imgur.com/SACue.gif

[Maia]

Marcus!!!

[Smithy]

http://i.imgur.com/R8ETa.gif

[Tom]

Why do they keep showing Dermot, I'm sure they don't usually do that? Kind of off putting

[Harry!]

Johnny <3

[Jordan.]

No @ Marcus and Johnny :bored:

[Doogle]

LOL Johnny is hilarious

[Ninastar]

omfgggg

Misha and Janet now plz

[Smithy]

http://i.imgur.com/YFmzQ.gif

[Maia]

:shocked: I hope Janet is safe

[Doogle]

Surprised @ this

[Maia]

Yes!!! :amazed:

[Ninastar]

omfgggg

Misha and Janet now plz

[Smithy]

-stops with teh gifs now-

[Jordan.]

ugh Janet.

[GypsyGoth]

I'm happy now.

[Doogle]

WOAH?!?!?!?? omg wat

[Smithy]

What the ****!!!!

[Maia]

Misha in the bottom 2? WTAF

[Ninastar]

oh **** off

[Tom]

:shocked:

[Jordan.]

**** sake. Bye Sophie :(

[Harry!]

Boo Frankie is still with us!

[Locke.]

LOL!!!!!!!!!!! Brilliant

[GypsyGoth]

Nooooo Frankie is ****!!! :cloud:

[Marc]

NO NO NO NO NO NOooo!!

[Callum]

Ffs

[Callum]

Fix

[GypsyGoth]

This is Kelly's fault.

[Z]

What's going on???

[Maia]

Hahahaha @ Frankie through. Here to be a royal prat for another week.

[Jordan.]

I hope Tulisa and Louis save Sophie and let it be deadlock.

[Callum]

I blame Alexandra for her OK DOT COM comment last night

[Locke.]

Time to send the bitch home

[Ninastar]

would love for him to fall off a cliff

[Braden]

I'm feeling quite vemenous and angry!

[Tom]

Wouldn't be surprised if Kelly definitely didn't bother coming back

[Z]

Misha v Sophie... Just goes to show, the public don't always buy into what X Factor throws at them! Frankie, Kitty and Misha in the bottom two in successive weeks and they're arguably the three most marmite contestants on the show!

[GypsyGoth]

I blame Alexandra for her OK DOT COM comment last night

:laugh:

[Smithy]

Time to send the bitch home

cher's already left the building

[Jords]

Get the bully out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Sophie :bawling:

[Doogle]

Wtf wtf wtf wtf wtf

[GypsyGoth]

This would be a good chance for the other judges to get rid of Misha.

[Z]

Ahahaha I'm so pleased by this result. Shame for Sophie that she's going to get the boot because of the show's bias towards its self declared stars, but it's a right kick in the balls for the producers

[Locke.]

Misha was 50/1 to be eliminated tonight

[Vicky.]

PMSL @ frankie getting through :joker:

[IheartBB]

If Kelly has 2 acts in the bottom 2 (unlikely)...

...especially if it's two girls in the bottom two (unlikely, I know, but still...)

Jinx :shocked:

[Braden]

I love Alexandra huffing even though she's been there like a day.

[Black Dagger]

Sophie needs a ****ing miracle.

[Maia]

End of the road for Sophie :(

[Tom]

Ouch. This is brutal

[Locke.]

I think Alexandra prefers Sophie

[GypsyGoth]

This sounds a bit meh. I was expecting a lot more.

[Z]

It'd be wonderful for Sophie if Misha's vocals went to **** in the sing off.

[Maia]

The xx/Birdy :worship:

[Vicky.]

Sophie must know its gunna be her going.

Even if misha totally choked now...no way would she go

[Callum]

cher's already left the building

:laugh2:

[Tom]

Its quite obvious that its going to go to deadlock and Sophie will be out

[Black Dagger]

I think Alexandra prefers Sophie

No chance, even if she did... Gary, Louis and Tulisa will get rid of Sophie...

My first favourite goes, 4 more to go...

[Vicky.]

It'd be wonderful for Sophie if Misha's vocals went to **** in the sing off.

That wouldnt matter, they would just use the 'who has more to give in the competition' reason to keep her :laugh:

This is why i think its pointless having the bottom 2 singing again...as they only go on the actual performances if it suits them

[Z]

It's a bit unfair on the contestants that Kelly's not there because Alexandra's decision may totally differ to what Kelly's decision would be in any bottom two scenario, and it's even tougher now that it's two of Kelly's category up there...

[Jordan.]

I think Alexandra prefers Sophie

She said Misha was her favourite last night :suspect:

[Locke.]

She said Misha was her favourite last night :suspect:

She has changed her mind after seeing that hair cut

[Brother Leon]

This happens when you throw a hissy fit and fly off to L.A lol.

[Harry!]

I just love how upset Alexandra is getting!

[spitfire]

Sophie is much better.

[Tom]

It's a bit unfair on the contestants that Kelly's not there because Alexandra's decision may totally differ to what Kelly's decision would be in any bottom two scenario, and it's even tougher now that it's two of Kelly's category up there...

Thats why it will go to deadlock. Louis & Tulisa will vote Misha off because they hate her anyway, Gary will vote off Sophie and Alexandra will take it to deadlock.

[Ramsay]

**** song

[spitfire]

I just love how upset Alexandra is getting!
It's pathetic.

[Maia]

Hope Sophie stays actually.

[GypsyGoth]

This might be close.

[Maia]

Don't think Pixie Lott's cover of this song will ever be beaten :wink:

[Locke.]

Neither have been great in this sing off

[Smithy]

well this is underwhelming...

[Vicky.]

Actually preferred Sophies singoff song...

[Black Dagger]

Would love it if Sophie stayed...

Misha will though, Sophie will go next week, Misha probably wouldn't.

[Ramsay]

Whats up with her hair

[Doogle]

Misha needs to change her attitude now when she stays, which she obviously will.

[Smithy]

Don't think Pixie Lott's cover of this song will ever be beaten :wink:

Kelly Clarksons Cover >> life itself

[Z]

Thats why it will go to deadlock. Louis & Tulisa will vote Misha off because they hate her anyway, Gary will vote off Sophie and Alexandra will take it to deadlock.

I reckon the judges are made well aware of the results in scenarios like this, heavily implied by some of the results last series (Mary v Cher; Katie v Treyc; Katie v Aiden) so I think if Sophie has more votes than Misha; then Gary, Tulisa and Louis will vote out Sophie and Alexandra won't have to vote and if it's the other way around then it'll go to deadlock to appear fair so that Sophie still goes home. I'm surprised Misha's there this early on in the competition, but I've said from the first live show that her terrible attitude won't endear her to the voting public so it's not a surprise that she's ended up there, just surprising that it's so soon IMO.

[Marc]

MASSIVE shame. :(

[Vicky.]

Ah kellys doing the vote

[Locke.]

Kelly's fake sick voice :joker:

[Jordan.]

LOL at Kelly

[Doogle]

LOL Kelly you mess

[Novo]

Kelly pretending to put on an ill voice

[Tom]

Kelly's sore throat voice quite obviously faked :laugh3:

[Ninastar]

OMFG aww kelly

[Maia]

Kelly Clarksons Cover >> life itself

She did a cover of it? :shocked:

[Jordan.]

Louis siding with the bully

[Vicky.]

I reckon the judges are made well aware of the results in scenarios like this, heavily implied by some of the results last series (Mary v Cher; Katie v Treyc; Katie v Aiden) so I think if Sophie has more votes than Misha; then Gary, Tulisa and Louis will vote out Sophie and Alexandra won't have to vote and if it's the other way around then it'll go to deadlock to appear fair so that Sophie still goes home. I'm surprised Misha's there this early on in the competition, but I've said from the first live show that her terrible attitude won't endear her to the voting public so it's not a surprise that she's ended up there, just surprising that it's so soon IMO.

Yup I agree. Always said that

[Harry!]

Kelly's fake sick voice :joker:

This.

[Marc]

I'm gutted :(

[spitfire]

Poor Kelly.:joker:

[Maia]

Send Misha home and make Sophie do an uptempo song next week.

[Smithy]

She did a cover of it? :shocked:

yeah, as a mash up of That I Would Be Good :love:

hYGMMmtb3mk

[Marc]

Kelly pretending to put on an ill voice

Lol 'I can't come in to work today'

[Vicky.]

Why kelly before gary? When they made Louis make the final decision when his two were in the bottom? :/

[Smithy]

:o you bitch!!!!

[Maia]

:( Poor Sophie

[Jordan.]

**** sake Kelly I hope your throat gets worse

[Harry!]

Yey Misha B is through!

[Marc]

**** off.

Frankie can go crawl under his rock and stay there

[Black Dagger]

My first favourite of the competition to leave..

Marcus, Johnny, Kitty, Janet or Little Mix for the win.

[Locke.]

Oh well. Misha has no chance of winning now anyway :)

[Doogle]

I expected her to go so far. Misha better be back in the Bottom 2 again soon.

[Brother Leon]

She was never gonna win...Kelly ****ed up taking her in the first place over Amelia.

[Tom]

Glad Sophie has gone, she was too desperate

[Z]

I don't like what I've seen of Kelly and Misha being all chummy with each other, brings back memories of Cheryl and Cher with Cheryl giving her preferential treatment, despite Rebecca being more popular with the public in the competition. Same thing's happening here IMO. Janet is Kelly's obvious winner material and yet she's trying so hard to push Misha forward as a better competitor. Not with that attitude on the X Factor!

[Doogle]

Misha and Frankie for next week's Bottom 2.

[Black Dagger]

Dermot only said JLS...

DON'T ****ING SAY MY FLORENCE DROPPED OUT...

[Smithy]

Misha and Frankie for next week's Bottom 2.

Frankie and Kitty

[Locke.]

Yeah, Kelly'd still have 3 left now if she'd have saved Amelia over Sophie

[Callum]

Flo can't be doing next week's show :(

[Black Dagger]

Yeah, Kelly'd still have 3 left now if she'd have saved Amelia over Sophie

Could have easily been Amelia vs Misha :p...

But yeah on the night Sophie was better than Amelia, in the long haul definitely not.

[Black Dagger]

Flo can't be doing next week's show :(

For crying out loud, I got my hopes up for her all week... :bawling:

[Locke.]

Amelia was a contender to win, Kelly's fault for giving her an awful song choice

[Black Dagger]

Amelia was a contender to win, Kelly's fault for giving her an awful song choice

True... Amelia was my favourite to be fair.

I warmed to Sophie though, hopefully Frankie will be sent packing next week.

And URGH, no Florence =(.

[Tom]

Amelia was a contender to win, Kelly's fault for giving her an awful song choice

She was the favourite to win and she would have walked it. Most of this years acts are good or likeable. None of them seem to have both

[Smithy]

second #1 on the way

not with this song http://i.imgur.com/RBmIo.png