X Factor UK Needs a big judge

[samtheman]

Now The US X Factor Panel is confirmed X Factor UK needs a big name judge. Alesha dixon or Danni won't do. But the thing is can ITV afford it.

[Smithy]

Lily Allen plz

[Callum]

It'll be Katy Perry or Marina

[Jordan.]

Not another American who only sticks around for one series.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Lily Allen plz

It'll be Katy Perry or Marina

any of these would be :amazed:

but lily > marina > katy in that order

[Locke.]

Lily Allen :joker: As if

[2k9david2k10]

Beyonceeeee :dance: !

[Vanessa]

Katy Perry would be good. Or Danni Minogue. :blush:

[Black Dagger]

It'll be Alexandra Burke.

I'd bet on it.

[aj2463]

No Katy or Marina! :sleep: also they really should think about replacing Louis by now.

[rSlavenx]

They should bring Simon back and dump Louis, and I'd like to see Kelly Rowlands replacement be a high-profile female who will get the viewers really excited about the show.

[Marc]

Somebody like Beyonce would be incredible but it takes away the UK feel to the show.

I mean Tom Jones would be pretty good but the voice have him :(

[Vanessa]

Somebody like Beyonce would be incredible but it takes away the UK feel to the show.

I mean Tom Jones would be pretty good but the voice have him :(

I think Katy Perry would be amazing! She's brilliant! :dance:

[Marc]

Yeah but I dunno... I like UK mentors you know? I'm not being racist or rude to anybody else but its the X Factor UK isn't it so why not get our own talent to help mentor.

I like Gary as a judge and Tulisa at a push. I think Cheryl would have more standing now that she's become a bigger artist. But the links of Tom Jones or Adele would be outstanding :laugh:

[Marc]

(I laugh because Adele would never do it she's so big)

[MTVN]

The fat jokes are a bit below the belt Marc

[Marsh.]

Yeah but I dunno... I like UK mentors you know? I'm not being racist or rude to anybody else but its the X Factor UK isn't it so why not get our own talent to help mentor.

I like Gary as a judge and Tulisa at a push. I think Cheryl would have more standing now that she's become a bigger artist. But the links of Tom Jones or Adele would be outstanding :laugh:

She's in the same status she was when she left X Factor. Only just released her first single since leaving the show, so how do you calculate she's become a "bigger artist" in her absence?

[Smithy]

Cheryl's only really seen as more famous because her famous footballer husband cheated on her and Simon ditched her from XF US, not really something to be proud of

[Marc]

She's in the same status she was when she left X Factor. Only just released her first single since leaving the show, so how do you calculate she's become a "bigger artist" in her absence?

Well from when she started the X Factor in like season 5.

[Marsh.]

Well from when she started the X Factor in like season 5.

And she's still about as famous and as known as Girls Aloud was. Not much difference IMO.

[rSlavenx]

I don't see the big deal about Lilly Allen, she isn't that good, and I doubt she'd be as fiery as people would hope.

Katy Perry? She was a decent guest judge but can't see her being up to much full time, I agree with keeping it to UK mentors, they've got more passion about the show.

[Marc]

I personally think get rid of Louis and replace him with Shane from Westlife, he can do the groups.

Get Simon back, he knew what he was doing (most of the time)

Tom Jones for the overs

and Cheryl/Adele/Marina/a sugababe or somebody else from girls aloud for the girls.

They should just pre-set the categories with the judges.

[Marc]

And she's still about as famous and as known as Girls Aloud was. Not much difference IMO.

It's a good thing we're on a forum then, where we can discuss our own personal opinions :hugesmile:

[Smithy]

Girls aloud are reuniting this year anyway, i doubt any of them would have the time

[MTVN]

Sir Tom is a legend but the Voice has shown him to be crap at live shows

[Marc]

I don't think his song choices are THAT bad, but like I said if he's for the overs then he might have some good advice for them. That or pick Rod Stewart :joker: what a legend he is.

[Black Dagger]

Sir Tom is a legend but the Voice has shown him to be crap at live shows

He seems very awkward.

His song choices are good though. IMO.

[Vanessa]

I don't think his song choices are THAT bad, but like I said if he's for the overs then he might have some good advice for them. That or pick Rod Stewart :joker: what a legend he is.

Elton John would be better. :blush:

[Marc]

:shocked: Imagine Elton.

[Smithy]

Doesn't Elton hate the show :joker:

http://www.metro.co.uk/showbiz/844370-sir-elton-john-slates-boring-x-factor-during-music-rant

[MTVN]

I don't think his song choices are THAT bad, but like I said if he's for the overs then he might have some good advice for them. That or pick Rod Stewart :joker: what a legend he is.

Not really his song choices I just don't think he's very good live, like Lucas said he's really awkward and seems to find it hard to articulate himself

[Black Dagger]

The same Elton that slates the show if he gets the chance? :tongue:

[Marc]

Doesn't Elton hate the show :joker:

http://www.metro.co.uk/showbiz/844370-sir-elton-john-slates-boring-x-factor-during-music-rant

Yeah :blush2: we can win him over with millions and millions

Not really his song choices I just don't think he's very good live, like Lucas said he's really awkward and seems to find it hard to articulate himself

That's cos he's old :sad:

[Vanessa]

The same Elton that slates the show if he gets the chance? :tongue:

I think he'd be amazing as a judge! :amazed:

[MTVN]

That's cos he's old :sad:

That's no excuse :nono:

[Smithy]

They should have the 4 main judges, then a guest judge every week on the live show, who can give unbias criticism:amazed:

[lostalex]

New X-Factor UK line up:

Elton John, Paul McCartney, Mick Jagger, Adele


It's confirmed.

[Marc]

That would be sensational.

[Marc]

That's no excuse :nono:

You won't be saying that when your old mister!

[Black Dagger]

You won't be saying that when your old mister!

Niamh will give him pointers on how to deal with being old.

[Black Dagger]

And that line-up would be so stunning. No Gary *******ing Barlow.

[Marc]

-wonders what that c word is.-

[Vanessa]

New X-Factor UK line up:

Elton John, Paul McCartney, Mick Jagger, Adele


It's confirmed.

That would be amazing! :banana:

[Jordan.]

New X-Factor UK line up:

Elton John, Paul McCartney, Mick Jagger, Adele


It's confirmed.

No http://www.planetsmilies.com/smilies/scared/scared0005.gif

[Marc]

Wonder if Cher Lloyd would have got through if that was the case.

[Marsh.]

It's a good thing we're on a forum then, where we can discuss our own personal opinions :hugesmile:

You make it sound like I was saying your opinion was wrong. Coming across a bit passive aggressive.

[Black Dagger]

-wonders what that c word is.-

Cauliflower. x

[lostalex]

white noise

[Black Dagger]

Erm, yeah, cool.

[lostalex]

You make it sound like I was saying your opinion was wrong. Coming across a bit passive aggressive.

why are you making accusations? describing someone as passive aggressive is very passive aggressive.

[Braden]

I honestly think that Mel B should be on our version, instead of the Australian.

[lostalex]

I honestly think that Mel B should be on our version, instead of the Australian.

the least successful spice girl? really?

imo, Ginger aka Fatassbossyone aka Geri would be the only acceptable Spice Girl.

Geri made and ruined the Spice Girls imo.

[Braden]

the least successful spice girl? really?

imo, geri would be the only acceptable spice girl.

I wouldn't say she's the least successful, she's done quite well for herself. She has the best personality out of all five of them as well.

[lostalex]

I wouldn't say she's the least successful, she's done quite well for herself. She has the best personality out of all five of them as well.

i guess... if you consider *******ing eddie murphy succesful...

i'd take victoria over Mel B any day.

Let's be real, Victoria is the most successful at life, and Geri is the most succesful at music...

the other 3 are kinda non-entities. emma does so many shows she has no brand left, she's already sold it all away, Mel B is slowly catching up to emma in being a sell out, and Mel C, well, she may have her dignity, but she doesn't have a career.

[Patrick]

No, it just needs axed.

I'm fed up with them relying on the judges and the scandals behind them, I don't care. It's about the talent, and that's dead now too - it needs to ****** off already.

[Jack_]

I joked about it once before but they've left it so late now that they may as well opt for Pete Burns.

Just imagine him on a live show. Imagine the comments. I think the show would be on a three hour delay.

[Braden]

i guess... if you consider *******ing eddie murphy succesful...

i'd take victoria over Mel B any day.

Let's be real, Victoria is the most successful at life, and Geri is the most succesful at music...

the other 3 are kinda non-entities. emma does so many shows she has no brand left, she's already sold it all away, Mel B is slowly catching up to emma in being a sell out, and Mel C, well, she may have her dignity, but she doesn't have a career.

Mel B in terms of music is the least successful, your right. However I think that could be because it's pretty non- exsistant.

I just feel that she has a good personality to make it a bit more interesting and exciting, just my opinion. She's wasted by being put on the Australian version.

[Toxic]

Now The US X Factor Panel is confirmed X Factor UK needs a big name judge. Alesha dixon or Danni won't do. But the thing is can ITV afford it.

I agree, The US XF have done an amazing job getting Britney Spears to join the panel, she is a HUGE star and nobody can deny that.

Danni Minogue is apparently the 'fan favourite' to return (jesus knows why, most boring person on the panel) but she just doesn't have the star power.

[Callum]

I honestly think that Mel B should be on our version, instead of the Australian.

After this interview she did with Fabulous magazine last month, Mel B will be lucky to get any TV work in the UK again.

http://www.melaniebrown.com.br/en/2012/03/31/fabulous-magazine-interview/#more-1835

I really hope she is not the new judge. XF should stay well clear of her.

[Vanessa]

I like Danni. But i would prefer Katy Perry as a new judge. She''d be fab! :blush:

[Toxic]

Katy Perry would be a great addition...however I don't think she'd ever do it, her career is going great so she doesn't exactly need it does she?

[Vanessa]

Katy Perry would be a great addition...however I don't think she'd ever do it, her career is going great so she doesn't exactly need it does she?

A job on the X Factor would make her career even better. :blush:

[Z]

I think it's safe to say that if you're an active popstar and you land a role on the X Factor judging panel, you're guaranteed success through exposure. Particularly the female judges, who become style icons and get a lot of attention. I think the issue with Kelly Rowland is that her personality is too brash and American in nature. She's not like Katy Perry or Nicole Scherzinger who understand the British mindset (possibly because of their British boyfriends.) I think Tulisa's a great judge, I'm glad she's returning, but I hope whoever replaces Kelly has a personality to write home about. Adele would be fantastic but she wouldn't fit in with that glamour aspect of things. I'd hate to see Lily Allen do it and she wouldn't agree to it either I don't think. We don't need another nobody taking up the job, we need someone who's had a substantial career who's not really doing the whole music thing anymore. That's why Dannii Minogue was great for the job.

[Vanessa]

I think it's safe to say that if you're an active popstar and you land a role on the X Factor judging panel, you're guaranteed success through exposure. Particularly the female judges, who become style icons and get a lot of attention. I think the issue with Kelly Rowland is that her personality is too brash and American in nature. She's not like Katy Perry or Nicole Scherzinger who understand the British mindset (possibly because of their British boyfriends.) I think Tulisa's a great judge, I'm glad she's returning, but I hope whoever replaces Kelly has a personality to write home about. Adele would be fantastic but she wouldn't fit in with that glamour aspect of things. I'd hate to see Lily Allen do it and she wouldn't agree to it either I don't think. We don't need another nobody taking up the job, we need someone who's had a substantial career who's not really doing the whole music thing anymore. That's why Dannii Minogue was great for the job.

But she's busy with an australian show, isn't she? :blush:

[Marsh.]

After this interview she did with Fabulous magazine last month, Mel B will be lucky to get any TV work in the UK again.

http://www.melaniebrown.com.br/en/2012/03/31/fabulous-magazine-interview/#more-1835

I really hope she is not the new judge. XF should stay well clear of her.

Lol, she's proudly displayed that article on her personal website? :rolleyes:


I think it's safe to say that if you're an active popstar and you land a role on the X Factor judging panel, you're guaranteed success through exposure. Particularly the female judges, who become style icons and get a lot of attention. I think the issue with Kelly Rowland is that her personality is too brash and American in nature. She's not like Katy Perry or Nicole Scherzinger who understand the British mindset (possibly because of their British boyfriends.) I think Tulisa's a great judge, I'm glad she's returning, but I hope whoever replaces Kelly has a personality to write home about. Adele would be fantastic but she wouldn't fit in with that glamour aspect of things. I'd hate to see Lily Allen do it and she wouldn't agree to it either I don't think. We don't need another nobody taking up the job, we need someone who's had a substantial career who's not really doing the whole music thing anymore. That's why Dannii Minogue was great for the job.

I don't think it was that case at all. At least in Nicole's case, it was being very much like an LA airhead, nothing quite interesting to say and wanting to please everyone. Everything's awesome and she loves everyone with a soft, almost child-like tone to the voice. She was the same on US X Factor. I expect Britney will be much the same.

[Marsh.]

why are you making accusations? describing someone as passive aggressive is very passive aggressive.

I don't see what it has to do with you. I shall expand on my post if Marc wants me to.

[Marc]

Nah I'm cool :laugh:

[Marsh.]

:hugesmile:

[Callum]

Lol, she's proudly displayed that article on her personal website? :rolleyes:


It's a fansite, not her official website.

[lukee]

riri or nicki minaj would be prefect