Who told Becky about her BMI problem?

[Sertius]

First of all the comment Luke made was about her and not to her and was to emphasise her lack of respect.

No one else in the house ever mentioned her BMI/weight/obesity although probably all of them had some thoughts about it.

No. The person who told her about her weight problem was her sister - face to face sort of.

Now either her sister:

1. Knew she was sensitive about her size but still wanted to hurt her feelings by telling her. She would have known how this would affect Becky and possibly ruin the rest of her time in there. Ergo her sister is not very nice towards her.

Or:

2. She knew it was of little importance to Becky and that she would not be overly offended by it but would milk the situation for all it is worth. Ergo no real offence only 'acting'.

You decide.......

[KingOfTheMods]

Has to be number two. Her little sister's hardly one to talk is she, she's a lump too. Admittedley not as big as two tonne tess.

[ammiestar]

Well said!!!

[Big Brother Cartoons uk]

Definately just giving Becks some ammo against Luke.

[Cherie]

No. 2...sis knew Becky would take it and run with it.

[the truth]

First of all the comment Luke made was about her and not to her and was to emphasise her lack of respect.

No one else in the house ever mentioned her BMI/weight/obesity although probably all of them had some thoughts about it.

No. The person who told her about her weight problem was her sister - face to face sort of.

Now either her sister:

1. Knew she was sensitive about her size but still wanted to hurt her feelings by telling her. She would have known how this would affect Becky and possibly ruin the rest of her time in there. Ergo her sister is not very nice towards her.

Or:

2. She knew it was of little importance to Becky and that she would not be overly offended by it but would milk the situation for all it is worth. Ergo no real offence only 'acting'.

You decide.......

brilliantly put, yet another woman who looks for every possible situation to milk false sympathy

[muchadoaboutnothing]

I can't help wondering if Becky actually knows what BMI means? And when I saw her sister on the screen I thought BB had accidentially shown the HMs a clip from the Jeremy Kyle show.

[saz2011]

i dont understand why she went off on one about if not for attention. she hides food, doesn't stop eating and has boasted on numerous occasions that she eats what shes likes when she likes. it wasn't a problem till she needed it to be.

[HBB1508]

Certainly number 2 - just to give her some ammo to throw at Luke A - but I think it will backfire on her given how she plays the "I'm a big fat bubbly girl" card all the time.

[Razor]

I also think number two. Oh and her sister looked like shreks love child.

[Marmalite]

Please - they've all watched BB before and knew F&F got to vote last year. I expect she colluded with her sister the minute she knew she was going into the house. I expect it was a case of "if you ever get the chance use my weight to get me sympathy votes".

Her so called bessie mates in there have constantly mocked her weight and her eating habits as does she to herself practically every day (and we only see a few minutes of her a day). Luke S and Conor constantly take the mick out of her by making her do exercises where she happens to get her tits out and then stand their giggling like a couple of gormless twits.

All the insiders F&F colluded together against the favourites Luke A and Deana and gave them all extra amunition to make their time there even more hell and to ostracise them even more than they have. Thank god for the failure of the white room task which got Luke and Conor out of the picture otherwise we'd never have heard the end of it!

Becky's sisters excuses were hypocritical especially since her sister has been one of the biggest loud mouthed bitches in the house this year who goes on about how she loves her body and weight and constantly shoves food down her throat even to the point of hiding it under her bed so she can scoff herself in secret!

[Livia]

Becky's fat. Becky's obese, in fact. This is not news. I don't see that referring to her BMI is that insulting I'm sure she realises she's enormous. What I did find insulting was her tirade against Deana last night - not to her face, of course, but behind her back. "She's actually disgusting, a disgusting person, I've never in all my life known such a disgusting person, she literally makes me feel physically sick". I'm paraphrasing of course, but you all must have heard it. I look forward to see her wobbling down the stairs on Friday.

[GiRTh]

Becky's fat. Becky's obese, in fact. This is not news. I don't see that referring to her BMI is that insulting I'm sure she realises she's enormous. What I did find insulting was her tirade against Deana last night - not to her face, of course, but behind her back. "She's actually disgusting, a disgusting person, I've never in all my life known such a disgusting person, she literally makes me feel physically sick". I'm paraphrasing of course, but you all must have heard it. I look forward to see her wobbling down the stairs on Friday.Agreed. Less than one day after she was outraged and offended by Luke A BMI comment she's ripping into Deana over an argument with Ashleigh that Becky wasn't even involved in. Becky's bitchiness knows no boundaries. Her and Ashleigh have to be two of the most un-self-aware people to have ever entered the house. Their double standards are incredible.

[Yayita]

Her sister was giving her the open door Becky had been looking for in order to use the Fat card. She had tried plenty of times but the HM's never gave her the leeway. In comes her sister to give her the perfect chance and ofcourse she is milking it, specially in a week where she is up for eviction.

[Nedusa]

First of all the comment Luke made was about her and not to her and was to emphasise her lack of respect.

No one else in the house ever mentioned her BMI/weight/obesity although probably all of them had some thoughts about it.

No. The person who told her about her weight problem was her sister - face to face sort of.

Now either her sister:

1. Knew she was sensitive about her size but still wanted to hurt her feelings by telling her. She would have known how this would affect Becky and possibly ruin the rest of her time in there. Ergo her sister is not very nice towards her.

Or:

2. She knew it was of little importance to Becky and that she would not be overly offended by it but would milk the situation for all it is worth. Ergo no real offence only 'acting'.

You decide.......

definitely the second one..... it was done for one reason and one reason only, to give Becky AMMO to use against Luke A. They obviously realised that no one in the house has up to now used the "Fat" card against Becky and this was their opportunity to give her loads of airtime crying and moaning about the "disgusting" Luke A and his blatent "Fattist" remarks.

[Audi]

Itll back fire. Bekky will be leaving.

[Ellen]

There would be no "Ammo" to use if he had not said it in the first place. Its easy to attack someone because of their appearance/ size etc etc. For a 31 year old articulate man to insult a young girl about her size is childish & very sad.

[Munchkins]

Number 2: her sister is as pathetic as her
Praying Becky leaves tomorrow..

[Kizzy]

There would be no "Ammo" to use if he had not said it in the first place. Its easy to attack someone because of their appearance/ size etc etc. For a 31 year old articulate man to insult a young girl about her size is childish & very sad.

For an adult to make a comment against another adult...yeah terrible

[Marmalite]

There would be no "Ammo" to use if he had not said it in the first place. Its easy to attack someone because of their appearance/ size etc etc. For a 31 year old articulate man to insult a young girl about her size is childish & very sad.


He didn't attack her. He simply stated a fact and something that she's had no problem in being mocked over by Ashleigh, Conor and Luke S before and also something which was one of her selling points of entering the house in the first place.

In fact after the way she treated him and the things she has said about him and many other HMs it was hardly anything to make a big song and dance about. My disappointment in that comment was that he didn't say it to her face.

What are your thoughts on the fact that she said she wanted to grow a dick and piss on him? Or her rant last night where she called Deana the most disgusting person she's ever met in her life, amongst other names, just because Ashleigh didn't like the way Deana spoke to her?

[Ellen]

For an adult to make a comment against another adult...yeah terrible

Adult male to young girl
Adult to Adult
Doesnt matter, he should know better. Like i say, he picked the easiest thing to target when he could have said numerous things. I stand by what i say, its childish & very sad.

[Livia]

There would be no "Ammo" to use if he had not said it in the first place. Its easy to attack someone because of their appearance/ size etc etc. For a 31 year old articulate man to insult a young girl about her size is childish & very sad.

Becky is a compulsive eater who send a very bad example of what it's like to have an eating disorder, gorges herself on sugar and saturated fat and thinks it's clever; smuggles food, steals it, hides it, eats it in secret... is at least six stones overweight because of her greediness. If she doesn't cut down her eating soon, in a few years she'll be a prisoner in her own room, sitting on a king-sized bed day in, day out, in a massive, sore-covered puddle of her own fat. But don't say anything... she might be offended.

[Ellen]

He didn't attack her. He simply stated a fact and something that she's had no problem in being mocked over by Ashleigh, Conor and Luke S before and also something which was one of her selling points of entering the house in the first place.

In fact after the way she treated him and the things she has said about him and many other HMs it was hardly anything to make a big song and dance about. My disappointment in that comment was that he didn't say it to her face.

What are your thoughts on the fact that she said she wanted to grow a dick and piss on him? Or her rant last night where she called Deana the most disgusting person she's ever met in her life, amongst other names, just because Ashleigh didn't like the way Deana spoke to her?

He did attack her, he said it on the back of a remark she made about respecting him.
Im not defending Becky on any other issues, i dont actually like her but when i think something is wrong i say so. I think he was out of order, he picked the easiest of things to have a pop at her & for an articulate man i thought it very childish & sad.

[calyman]

There would be no "Ammo" to use if he had not said it in the first place. Its easy to attack someone because of their appearance/ size etc etc. For a 31 year old articulate man to insult a young girl about her size is childish & very sad.
He stated a truism about a severely self indulgent, greedy, spoiled, nasty, backstabbing, obese and malignant adult, which incidentally, no one else complained about before mini me becky thought it was "wise" to upset her sister with.

[Livia]

He stated a truism about a severely self indulgent, greedy, spoiled, nasty, backstabbing, obese and malignant adult, which incidentally, no one else complained about before mini me becky thought it was "wise" to upset her sister with.

Agreeing with your post and loving your Klimt.

[Marc]

Number 2 without a doubt, why would her sister want to hurt her sister's feelings.

[Kizzy]

Adult male to young girl
Adult to Adult
Doesnt matter, he should know better. Like i say, he picked the easiest thing to target when he could have said numerous things. I stand by what i say, its childish & very sad.

If becky was not the sort of person who shoots her mouth of about anybody and everybody I may have an ounce of sympathy...But she isn't so I don't.

She is an adult as was caroline, just because they choose to act like adolescents the other adults in the house need not feel guilty for offending them, as they say what they like to others without any concience.

[calyman]

Agreeing with your post and loving your Klimt.
Thanks, he definitely had an eye for colour and shape, unlike Becky. "ahem"

[Marmalite]

He did attack her, he said it on the back of a remark she made about respecting him.
Im not defending Becky on any other issues, i dont actually like her but when i think something is wrong i say so. I think he was out of order, he picked the easiest of things to have a pop at her & for an articulate man i thought it very childish & sad.


Agreed - in the outside world in an everyday situation it would be considered childish and sad coming from a 30+ year old.

However, take away the outside world put the person into an enclosed house full of people he would not give the time of day to on the outside and an environment that has seen nothing but bitching, bullying, ganging up, ostracising, back stabbing, threats, name-calling etc, etc, etc move it along to over 30+ days of being in this environment where those you got along with and had fun with are now gone and you have a completely different scenario.

In fact, I take my hat off to him for that being the only bad, childish and possibly hurtful remark he's made. There's only so much a person can take before they finally break and I would have lost it a long time ago so fair do's to him I say!

[Marmalite]

He did attack her, he said it on the back of a remark she made about respecting him.


Oh and btw, he didn't attack her.

He said it behind her back not to her face. So how is that attacking her?

[calyman]

It's irrelevant to talk about the varying ages of adults and what they should or shouldn't be "allowed" to say. We are none of us the same. Nastiness is not age dependent, nor is maturity only within the province of "30+" adults.

What is relevant is whether a person is fundamentally decent or not. Luke A is, Becky is not.

[SuziBooo]

She has big piles of food under her bed! And doesn't share it which admitted it to and she wants to be big and bold! Her choice! So Becky, have your cake and eat it!

[Marcus.]

She has big piles of food under her bed! And doesn't share it which admitted it to and she wants to be big and bold! Her choice! So Becky, have your cake and eat it!

hear hear