Lucy Spraggan, Will X factor ruin her?

[Jamie585]

She has her own style, which i think is amazing, but i don't think she is versatile enough for the X factor, with all the different themes, will it ruin her?

[Roy Mars III]

never good in the first place

[Shaun]

she'll keep getting portrayed as the female Ed Sheeran and it'll annoy some people, but she has more (songwriting, guitar) than one talent (singing) which can't be said for many of the others.

[Locke.]

She can't get much worse to be honest

[Ninastar]

yes it will ruin her

[Black Dagger]

She'll get the 'you are a one trick pony' comments and go backwards.

This show is too predictable. LMAO.

[Lee.]

She's sh*te anyway...

[Mystic Mock]

The themes will kill her, shame though as I do like Lucy so far but she's just not versatile enough, just look at the autotuned performance on tonights episode she sounded really bad imo.

[Marc]

She's sh*te anyway...

:worship:

Agreed. Nothing special and without her guitar, she's even worse!

[Me. I Am Salman]

I think she's a bit overrated but I like her too at the same time ;s

[Jamie585]

She's sh*te anyway...
hmm, I think she is a brilliant song writer, but not as good at singing, she should stick to what she is good at.

[Jordan.]

Too good for the xfactor. She should have pulled out when Beer Fear was looking set to go #1

[joeysteele]

Yes,in my opinion, it to be fair spoils lots of acts chances really.

She needs to do her thing and the bulk of the songs they will be expected and given to sing on the live shows are likely going to be a world away from her comfort zone and style.

She did poor really at judges house stage and trying to make the often ridiculous songs they get at the live shows into a style that will suit her will not likely work for her or the song.

[realitytvsux]

I really like her. I think she is funny, sweet and talented. I don't think she should be on x factor at all - it's a crock of sh1t!

[billy123]

She has already won regardless of where she finishes.
It has launched her career something other "winners" can only dream of happening.

[King Gizzard]

She'll release one CD then never heard of again, like most of these quirky guitar solo artists

Don't think she's particulary suited to the show either, her voice will be a bit weak for some songs and they'll eventually get annoyed with her playing her guitar all the time, ask her to sing and dance, then she'll crumble and get voted out

[thesheriff443]

she is a cross between jasper carrot and victoria wood.
crap crap crap

[Gillian-73]

I really like her but BGT would have worked better for her i think!

[Z]

She's gonna be pigeon holed into the one trick pony role and crash out in Week 7 or 8 and be this year's Janet Devlin.