Which current artists would fail on this show

[Marc]

Which famous, established singers/groups would just fail on The X Factor?

Just watched Ellie Goulding on tele and thought he wouldn't have stood a chance on TXF

Who else?

[King Gizzard]

Lil B

[Black Dagger]

Lots of artists tbh.

The Saturdays would go in week 1/2...

Now on the other hand, I reckon Ed Sheeran would walk this show... (as much as I dislike him)

[Smithy]

Rihanna
Katy Perry
Britney
Pixie Lott

loads tbh

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

gaga

[Marc]

Gaga would be like Katie Waissel or something, eccentricity would go against her

I think the likes of Emeli Sande and Ed Sherran would go far

[Jake.]

Anyone/band that isn't mainstream ****

[Rawrbear]

Katy Perry, Tulisa, Robbie Williams would be out so quick

Emile Sande, Ed Sheeran, Beyonce and what have you would do Well!

[Munchkins]

Tbh probably most acts today would do bad lol.

[Shaun]

most, if not all. it's such an irrelevant show to what's successful (not to mention what's art)

[Saph]

Tbh probably most acts today would do bad lol.

agree

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Tbh probably most acts today would do bad lol.

That's what I was going to say. Except Beyonce and Adele (even though i'm not a huge beyonce or adele fan. )

[Apple202]

Gaga stands out for this.

Adele, on the other hand, or Ed Sheeran, would walk it.