Tulisa should be sacked for her decision tonight.

[Mystic Mock]

She's suppose to base it off the sing-off yet voted to send home Melanie over District3?:conf:

She's incompetent at her job and knows nothing about Music (i.e giving The Risk Crazy on Rock week last year) a useless judge.

[MTVN]

She went with her heart

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

Who was going to buy Melanies music anyway? :(

[Apple202]

Tulisa get's the blame for ****ing everything. It's ridiculous.

If she was a useless judge, then how would she win with the groups? And how is she the only mentor this series now not to have an act in the bottom 2?

[reece(:]

Off with her head, ****est series ever this is.

[Ramsay]

Not a chance of the 2nd best judge getting the sack Mock, stop with that nonsense

[Doogle]

Her heart is with an average boyband? Bet they promised her sexual favours if she kept them or something idk

[Locke.]

District3 are far more talented than Melanie

[Jordan.]

She made it painfully obvious how superior Nicole is to her in everyway tonight.

[Apple202]

eurgh this elimination is just giving people even more a chance too slag off tulisa

[GiRTh]

She made it painfully obvious how superior Nicole is to her in everyway tonight.:worship:

[Maia]

To think I actually quite liked her as well....dunno what the hell she was thinking of

[Mystic Mock]

Tulisa get's the blame for ****ing everything. It's ridiculous.

If she was a useless judge, then how would she win with the groups? And how is she the only mentor this series now not to have an act in the bottom 2?

Your giving her to much credit there, she did produce the worst group ever last year in Nu Vibe, and the producers always give her the trendy acts that people like you or me could win with, with the exception of Nu Vibe of course.

[Ninastar]

she's probs ****ing a producer for a place on the show anyway

[Doogle]

eurgh this elimination is just giving people even more a chance too slag off tulisa

Why are you defending her when she obviously made the wrong choice though? :suspect:

[Maia]

Off with her head, ****est series ever this is.

:worship:

[Mystic Mock]

eurgh this elimination is just giving people even more a chance too slag off tulisa

Well if she had made the correct decision and saved Melanie then she would infact have got mine and alot of other peoples respect.

[Vicky.]

Shes allowed her opinion...

Personally I dont see the point in having 2 boybands in the competition though, but I dont think Melanie was actually too good in the singoff either....I expected her to absolutely wipe the floor with district3, THEN I probably would have joined in the tulisa bashing if she sent her home. But she screwed up...and in the end the public got their choice. Cant complain really

[Apple202]

Why are you defending her when she obviously made the wrong choice though? :suspect:

She made the wrong decision, so what? The blame is not solely with her, what about Gary's poor song choice? Poor styling for Melanie? Tulisa is getting all the blame for something that she is only partially guilty in. It's giving people a chance too call her a slut and (I quote) hoping her to get run over by busses and it's just ridiculous.

[Me. I Am Salman]

She's dull as dishwater, which is probably what she used to bathe in as a child

[reece(:]

She should go back to doing what she does best.. and it's not the singing.

[Apple202]

Well if she had made the correct decision and saved Melanie then she would infact have got mine and alot of other peoples respect.

She made the right decision last week.. did she get any credit? Did she balls. She got a load of people blaming her for how she said 'that person' to Louis. She can't win.

[Apple202]

eurgh this elimination is just giving people even more a chance too slag off tulisa

She's dull as dishwater, which is probably what she used to bathe in as a child

She should go back to doing what she does best.. and it's not the singing.

point proven.

[Doogle]

She made the wrong decision, so what? The blame is not solely with her, what about Gary's poor song choice? Poor styling for Melanie? Tulisa is getting all the blame for something that she is only partially guilty in. It's giving people a chance too call her a slut and (I quote) hoping her to get run over by busses and it's just ridiculous.

But people always go "oh they had a bad week give them another chance" and Tulisa is the one to blame because Melanie would've survived otherwise, people aren't using it as an excuse to slag off Tulisa again, she deserves to be after making such a bad decision.

Plus she is a slut anyway so it's just stating facts.

[Jamie585]

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really :)

[Apple202]

But people always go "oh they had a bad week give them another chance" and Tulisa is the one to blame because Melanie would've survived otherwise, people aren't using it as an excuse to slag off Tulisa again, she deserves to be after making such a bad decision.

Plus she is a slut anyway so it's just stating facts.

You're whole post made invalid by one sentence. She gave her boyfriend a blowjob, the horror!!!!

And technically it wasn't her fault, it was the public's for not voting Melanie enough :)

[Me. I Am Salman]

point proven.

She's a skank with no morals

[Apple202]

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really :)

Jamie talking sense once again :worship:

[Doogle]

You're whole post made invalid by one sentence. She gave her boyfriend a blowjob, the horror!!!!

And technically it wasn't her fault, it was the public's for not voting Melanie enough :)

Blowjobs are sinful she will pay for what she did

[Mystic Mock]

Shes allowed her opinion...

Personally I dont see the point in having 2 boybands in the competition though, but I dont think Melanie was actually too good in the singoff either....I expected her to absolutely wipe the floor with district3, THEN I probably would have joined in the tulisa bashing if she sent her home. But she screwed up...and in the end the public got their choice. Cant complain really

Do you honestly think that was her opinion though? or was it just the fact that in future weeks Melanie would be more of a threat to win than The Backstreet Boys was ever going to be?

[Apple202]

She's a skank with no morals

Again, because she gave her boyfriend a blowjob? Get a grip.

[Apple202]

Do you honestly think that was her opinion though? or was it just the fact that in future weeks Melanie would be more of a threat to win than The Backstreet Boys was ever going to be?

Why would Melanie be more of a threat if she got less votes than District 3? :conf:

[Jamie585]

Love Tulisa.. Don't hate!! ;)

[Ramsay]

Not surprised people have lowered themselves to calling her a slut :bored:

[Mystic Mock]

Why would Melanie be more of a threat if she got less votes than District 3? :conf:

Because she got lost in the crowd of 12 contestants where as District3 are only gonna average about 5 to 7% each week.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Again, because she gave her boyfriend a blowjob? Get a grip.

No thanks I'll leave that to Tulisa :wink:

[Apple202]

Because she got lost in the crowd of 12 contestants where as District3 are only gonna average about 5 to 7% each week.

You can think of all the excuses you like, but seen as though Melanie had the least votes, she quite clearly was the smallest threat.

[Mystic Mock]

You can think of all the excuses you like, but seen as though Melanie had the least votes, she quite clearly was the smallest threat.

She wasn't as you will see when the voting results come out and District3 pull in the same percentages in every week, where as if Melanie was given more interesting song choices she would've been much higher in the votes.

[Apple202]

She wasn't as you will see when the voting results come out and District3 pull in the same percentages in every week, where as if Melanie was given more interesting song choices she would've been much higher in the votes.

You can't build your hate of someone on a presumption.

[Mystic Mock]

I can and especially when Melanie wiped the floor with The Backstreet Boys in the sing-off.

Although Carolynne wiped the floor with Rylan last week and yet Louis ****ed up, and Simon's decision to save Katie over Aiden a couple of years ago so I don't know why I am shocked anymore tbh.

[Raph]

Yeah like Rachel Adedeji was sent home over Lloyd. :bored:

[Vicky.]

Yeah like Rachel Adedeji was sent home over Lloyd. :bored:

And Lucie sent home over Jedward :bored:

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

[Ramsay]

Mock you're making an embarrassment of yourself

[Jamie585]

She's not going anywhere! her job is safe as houses!! :)

[Apple202]

Mock you're making an embarrassment of yourself

^

[Mystic Mock]

And Lucie sent home over Jedward :bored:

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

Yes but normally they are not in the first two weeks.

[Vicky.]

Yes but normally they are not in the first two weeks.
I think this week just seems worse because of all the controversy of last week...had it been a 'normal' elimination last week noone would really care this week.

I dont think a joke act has been in the bottom first before? With the exception of cocozza, but the group he was against were absolutely ****e. This is probably why it stands out more...coz carolyn was a decent singer. But they cant lose the characters early, people would lose interest with noone to hate so early on :joker:

[MTVN]

The two acts this series weren't really "sent home" considering it went to public vote though, in a way it's the fairest result

[Mystic Mock]

I think this week just seems worse because of all the controversy of last week...had it been a 'normal' elimination last week noone would really care this week.

I dont think a joke act has been in the bottom first before? With the exception of cocozza, but the group he was against were absolutely ****e. This is probably why it stands out more...coz carolyn was a decent singer. But they cant lose the characters early, people would lose interest with noone to hate so early on :joker:

But District3 aren't characters, they are just a very boring boyband and at best average vocalists (that's me being kind btw) noway should they have stayed tonight.

[Mystic Mock]

The two acts this series weren't really "sent home" considering it went to public vote though, in a way it's the fairest result

The judges are suppose to be there to amend any wrong results and they have failed in both weeks now, im wondering how they are gonna mess up next week tbh.

Will it be Kye losing to Christopher? anyone losing to District3? or Ella losing out to Rylan?

[Marcus.]

so far two act gone for joke acts

[Samuel.]

Watching people get over dramatic over X Factor is a lot more enjoyable than watching the show itself.

[Maia]

Mock is on fire tonight

[Vicky.]

But District3 aren't characters, they are just a very boring boyband and at best average vocalists (that's me being kind btw) noway should they have stayed tonight.

Yes Im quite well aware of that...

Just saying if there hadnt been such a 'shock' elimination last week (though it wasnt a shock really) I doubt anyone would be getting so worked up this week over the result. There HAD to be a 'shock' last week because of who the b2 were.

[Apple202]

Yes Im quite well aware of that...

Just saying if there hadnt been such a 'shock' elimination last week (though it wasnt a shock really) I doubt anyone would be getting so worked up this week over the result. There HAD to be a 'shock' last week because of who the b2 were.

Yeah, thinking about it outside of what happened last week it just seems like a standard elimination

[Black Dagger]

She's a stupid bitch.

But Melanie came last in the votes, so I can't really rage. :sad:

It was a fair enough decision.

[Mystic Mock]

Yeah, thinking about it outside of what happened last week it just seems like a standard elimination

How? Melanie was very good where as District3 sing out of tune with each other, even the teenage girls aren't voting for them fgs, they should have gone.

[Marcus.]

How? Melanie was very good where as District3 sing out of tune with each other, even the teenage girls aren't voting for them fgs, they should have gone.

Well said

[Vicky.]

I dont think Melanie was very good in the singoff if Im honest. I seriously expected her to wipe the floor with the boyband, but she just shouted her way through a song that I had never heard before. Gary made a horrible song choice for her yesterday too, same as he did with Carolyn last week. Melanie, if given the right songs, would have made it at least past the halfway point IMO.

[Black Dagger]

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really :)

She has good acts... (well those liked within the GBP anyway) if she mentored Carolynne/Melanie I'm sure they'd have still gone.

I don't see how this makes her superior to everybody else because she has 3 well liked acts who were never going to be B2 in the early weeks.

[Mystic Mock]

She's a stupid bitch.

But Melanie came last in the votes, so I can't really rage. :sad:

It was a fair enough decision.

So when Olly Murs came last over Jedward a few years ago should he have gone then? or these same people that are saying about Melanie came last in the votes tbf argument but in the same breath complain about Simon's decision to evict Lucie Jones over Jedward can't really have it both ways as tbf he sent it to deadlock and Lucie came bottom of the votes.

[Apple202]

How? Melanie was very good where as District3 sing out of tune with each other, even the teenage girls aren't voting for them fgs, they should have gone.

I know Melanie is very good, but I'm not going to hold this against Tulisa. I didn't with Louis and I'm not going to with Tulisa either. Besides, technically public vote is the best and fairest way of deciding who leaves.

[Jamie585]

tbh.. Melanie is great!! but she wouldn't get that far.. young viewers wouldn't spend money on her.. because there too busy getting wet over the 'boybands' haha

[Marcus.]

melaine was better the out of tune district3

[Jamie585]

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

[Doogle]

tbh.. Melanie is great!! but she wouldn't get that far.. young viewers wouldn't spend money on her.. because there too busy getting wet over the 'boybands' haha

But Matt and Rebecca managed to consistently get more votes than 1D, and I bet when we see the final results the boybands won't be anywhere near top of the votes, that's what I don't get. It was just an unlucky week for her I think.

[Vicky.]

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^:joker:

[Mystic Mock]

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

Because his got them in the Sweepstake I think.

[Jamie585]

Because his got them in the Sweepstake I think.

hmm.. still if you hate an act i wouldn't have them in my sig :laugh:

[Mystic Mock]

hmm.. still if you hate an act i wouldn't have them in my sig :laugh:

Neither would I but it's his very brave choice I suppose.:joker:

[Marcus.]

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

my sweepstake judge as soon as they are out the well gone

[Jake.]

so i take it the boy band stayed?

[Marcus.]

Neither would I but it's his very brave choice I suppose.:joker:

judge sweepstake that the only thing why it in mu sig as soon as they are out they gone

[Mystic Mock]

so i take it the boy band stayed?

Sadly yes.

[Marcus.]

so i take it the boy band stayed?

yes they are

[InOne]

You're all being Mocked good and proper.

[Marcus.]

You're all being Mocked good and proper.

:joker:

[Jack_]

What the **** is this thread? Tonight's elimination felt really flat and kinda predictable after last week and so the last thing I was expecting was for someone to be up in arms about it...I mean really? Aren't we just clutching at straws now?

I hate to break it to you but, um...she's entitled to her opinion. Now personally I wouldn't have cared who had stayed (although perhaps District3 going would've been better for Union J, but meh) but I can see why she sided with the guys - at the end of the day even if Melanie's vocal ability far exceeds District3's, she's never going to win and she isn't particularly commercially viable either. That's not to say the boy band are going to win but clearly they're more marketable so I can see her train of thought.

Honestly though? If she hadn't have gone this week she'd have gone soon...is it really that important?

[Apple202]

What the **** is this thread? Tonight's elimination felt really flat and kinda predictable after last week and so the last thing I was expecting was for someone to be up in arms about it...I mean really? Aren't we just clutching at straws now?

I hate to break it to you but, um...she's entitled to her opinion. Now personally I wouldn't have cared who had stayed (although perhaps District3 going would've been better for Union J, but meh) but I can see why she sided with the guys - at the end of the day even if Melanie's vocal ability far exceeds District3's, she's never going to win and she isn't particularly commercially viable either. That's not to say the boy band are going to win but clearly they're more marketable so I can see her train of thought.

Honestly though? If she hadn't have gone this week she'd have gone soon...is it really that important?

:worship:

some people just want an oppurtunity to slag off tulisa

[Mystic Mock]

What the **** is this thread? Tonight's elimination felt really flat and kinda predictable after last week and so the last thing I was expecting was for someone to be up in arms about it...I mean really? Aren't we just clutching at straws now?

I hate to break it to you but, um...she's entitled to her opinion. Now personally I wouldn't have cared who had stayed (although perhaps District3 going would've been better for Union J, but meh) but I can see why she sided with the guys - at the end of the day even if Melanie's vocal ability far exceeds District3's, she's never going to win and she isn't particularly commercially viable either. That's not to say the boy band are going to win but clearly they're more marketable so I can see her train of thought.

Honestly though? If she hadn't have gone this week she'd have gone soon...is it really that important?

Yes my ears can't take anymore of District3, Melanie just got lost in the crowd with a weird song choice which I thought she pulled off personally.

[Mystic Mock]

:worship:

some people just want an oppurtunity to slag off tulisa

Well you can say the same for Louis last week.

[reece(:]

:worship:

some people just want an oppurtunity to slag off tulisa
We were all slagging off Louis' wrong decision last week, so it's not really picking opportunities to target Tulisa.. she and Louis were both voting with their reproductive organs per respective week.

[Mystic Mock]

We were all slagging off Louis' wrong decision last week, so it's not really picking opportunities to target Tulisa.. she and Louis were both voting with their reproductive organs per respective week.

This.

[thesheriff443]

mock take yourself to one side and say these words,
do shape up.

[Mystic Mock]

mock take yourself to one side and say these words,
do shape up.

Why?:joker:

[Maia]

Mock is actually amazing tonight...hasn't stepped a foot out of line

[Mystic Mock]

Mock is actually amazing tonight...hasn't stepped a foot out of line

I try my best.:dance::joker:

[thesheriff443]

This.

if my cock had a say ,i would still be a virgin.

[Mystic Mock]

if my cock had a say ,i would still be a virgin.

:laugh3:

[thesheriff443]

Why?:joker:

its a joke:joker:
i was in a dart team once and the captain was a head case:joker:
he would take players to one side and say do shape up.

[joeysteele]

Well,I think I would have voted to send District 3 home even after the sing off but the judges are entitled to make the decision as they see fit to.

Personally,I was again, as I was last week, pleased to see it go to deadlock, it should be the people paying to vote who decide who goes out and again the blame lies more with Gary who has not in my view served his Female acts well at all.
Also, it was the public who voted Melanie and District 3 into the bottom 2 and it was also the public who gave Melanie the least votes cast.

I wish we had got more deadlocks last year too.The more the merrier for me, 2 of the judges votes are void anyway as they will usually vote for their own acts to stay obviously, so without an independent team of 3,4 or 5 people to decide who goes out then deadlock for me and the voting viewers deciding who does go suits me perfectly.

It seems Gary Barlow doesn't know what the voting viewers do really like and want after all.

[Mystic Mock]

its a joke:joker:
i was in a dart team once and the captain was a head case:joker:
he would take players to one side and say do shape up.

Yeah I know it's a joke but I didn't get it.:joker:

Thanks for explaining it anyway.

[Joelle.]

She should get back to babysitting Dappy and leave the judging to the professionals, considering she probably wouldn't even make it past the producers auditions herself.

Nicole >

[jet]

Neither Melanie or District 3 were/are going to win or even get in to the top 5 so what does it matter really?
It isn't as if Jahmine or Ella was sent packing - and Tulisa always favours the young uns anyway.

[jet]

She should get back to babysitting Dappy and leave the judging to the professionals, considering she probably wouldn't even make it past the producers auditions herself.

Nicole >

She was the winning judge last year, remember! :nono:
But I hope Nicole wins this year with Jahmine. Nicole is on FIRE! :dance:

[Raph]

And Lucie sent home over Jedward :bored:

So many bad decisions. But thats what keeps people talking about the show.

Lucie Jones! :bawling:

[Cherie]

Maybe she preferred District 3 to Melanie, I did?.... there should be no judges vote it should always be the public vote that decides who stays, whats the point in voting if your vote is going to be overruled by the judges?

[Marcus.]

What was fun that district3 was trending world wide then they where in the bottom 2 lol

[Marcus.]

What was fun that district3 was trending world wide then they where in the bottom 2 lol

[mizzy25]

melanie was not a pop star nor did she have the x factor. she should be in a west end muscial maybe but she would never win the x factor. i dont suppose district 3 will win either. after sat night james is the outright winner for me anyway and i was an ella fan until sat night

[Mystic Mock]

]Maybe she preferred District 3 to Melanie, I did[/B]?.... there should be no judges vote it should always be the public vote that decides who stays, whats the point in voting if your vote is going to be overruled by the judges?

It's ok you will be cured soon.:bawling:

And to respond in a serious manner what's the point of having a bottom two if they are just going to take it to deadlock?

[Roy Mars III]

sorry, Mock but District3 are more talented and have more to offer than Melanie. I do not like Tulisa, but she made the right choice here

[Marcus.]

sorry, Mock but District3 are more talented and have more to offer than Melanie. I do not like Tulisa, but she made the right choice here

what all they do is appeal to teenagers that it it

[Roy Mars III]

what all they do is appeal to teenagers that it it

they are more talented than Melaine as well

[Mystic Mock]

sorry, Mock but District3 are more talented and have more to offer than Melanie. I do not like Tulisa, but she made the right choice here

Good joke Roy, they are that bad that even the teenage girls didn't want to vote for them.

[Roy Mars III]

Melaine appeals to no one

[Marcus.]

they are more talented than Melaine as well

how

[Roy Mars III]

how

they are better singers

[Marcus.]

Melaine appeals to no one

maybe the older people

[Marcus.]

they are better singers

really

[Mystic Mock]

Melaine appeals to no one

Melanie got lost in the crowd and in this new format of voting it's not good to be on last anymore.

[Roy Mars III]

really

yes

[Mystic Mock]

they are better singers

:laugh3:

[Marcus.]

Melanie got lost in the crowd and in this new format of voting it's not good to be on last anymore.

yeah she had more to give

[Marcus.]

yes

:joker:

[Roy Mars III]

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/signaturepics/sigpic57780_22.gif

[Marcus.]

http://cdn.thisisbigbrother.com/signaturepics/sigpic57780_22.gif

What