Pathetic Judge.

[Jamie585]

HE is so bad. He didn't base his decision on the final showdown, which is what your suppose to do?? ABSOLUTE W*NKER.

[Locke.]

He has proven me wrong and turned into a great judge

[Jamie585]

He has proven me wrong and turned into a great judge

Delusional^

[Marc]

:rolleyes:

[Mystic Mock]

Tbf has any of the decisions been based off the sing-off this year away from Kye vs MK1?

[Vicky.]

You know, every week people have moaned that the judges 'copped out' and took it to deadlock, then the first week this doesnt happen theres still moaning about it. what on earth are they meant to do?

[reece(:]

He went awful after he sabotaged his best two acts.

[Brother Leon]

Bitter much?

[mizzy25]

I dont like him @ all but he based his desision on who he thinks will go further in the competition so i say good on him and he didnt take it to deadlock

[Jamie585]

You know, every week people have moaned that the judges 'copped out' and took it to deadlock, then the first week this doesnt happen theres still moaning about it. what on earth are they meant to do?

SAVE THE DECENT SINGERS!!!!!!! :nono: Their pathetic.

[MTVN]

You know, every week people have moaned that the judges 'copped out' and took it to deadlock, then the first week this doesnt happen theres still moaning about it. what on earth are they meant to do?

Exactly, about time one of them was decisive and stopped all this deadlock nonsense

[Doogle]

Annoyed Jade is gone, and don't agree with the decision, but for the first week he's done the right thing and I respect that. He made a valid point, Jade isn't that passionate, whereas the 4 other fails obviously care more.

[Josy]

Gary is the best judge.

[reece(:]

Exactly, about time one of them was decisive and stopped all this deadlock nonsense
It's not really nonsense if it's the actual fair result, even if it may be in some of our opinions a daft one.

[Apple202]

I cba let my anger out at him, I didn't with Louis when Carol went home and I didn't with Tulisa when Melanie went home. It was the producer's decision, not his.

[Mystic Mock]

You know, every week people have moaned that the judges 'copped out' and took it to deadlock, then the first week this doesnt happen theres still moaning about it. what on earth are they meant to do?

Vote properly and not save wannabe joke acts or boybands that teenage girls drop to dead last in the votes.

[MTVN]

It's not really nonsense if it's the actual fair result, even if it may be in some of our opinions a daft one.

If it had gone to deadlock Union J would have probably stayed anyway and everyone would be going mental that the Judges didn't send them home

[Marsh.]

All the judges are full of crap and hypocritical. Name of the game.

They all get on their high horse about what the decisions should be based on and then change their tune the week after.

Like Gary being so against Rylan, yet he was responsible for Frankie.

[Vicky.]

Vote properly and not save wannabe joke acts or boybands that teenage girls drop to dead last in the votes.

So in other words 'vote according to who I personally like'?

You realise not all viewers think the same as you...right? so they can never please everyone.

[Vicky.]

If it had gone to deadlock Union J would have probably stayed anyway and everyone would be going mental that the Judges didn't send them home

Well exactly. Deadlock...Jade still going. Cue the outrage at Nicole for voting UJ through instead of Jade instead.

Deadlock with union J going, cue outrage from Union J fans saying 'fix, they knew they were bottom of the vote and thats why it was deadlock'

Jade gets majority vote to stay. outrage from UJ fans 'Jade clearly had less votes than UJ and thats why it was the judges majority'

[Mystic Mock]

So in other words 'vote according to who I personally like'?

You realise not all viewers think the same as you...right? so they can never please everyone.

Yes I know about the British public but your on about the judges and they could clearly tell that Carolynne ripped Rylan apart in the sing-off, and the same for Melanie against District3, and tonight Jade sang the best that she has ever done in the live shows and Union J arguably sang the worst that they have ever done before, yet Nicole and Gary saved them? that doesn't even make sense, especially considering the public clearly preferred Jade.

[Marc]

He is the best judge

[GypsyGoth]

This show isn't a talent show, it's about making as much money as possible. The judges decisions are based on that, regardless of who sings better in the singoff.

[Vicky.]

Yes I know about the British public but your on about the judges and they could clearly tell that Carolynne ripped Rylan apart in the sing-off, and the same for Melanie against District3, and tonight Jade sang the best that she has ever done in the live shows and Union J arguably sang the worst that they have ever done before, yet Nicole and Gary saved them? that doesn't even make sense, especially considering the public clearly preferred Jade.

The singoff means nowt. That was established ages ago(waaay back when jedward were saved over lucie). However they sang tonight the result would have been the same I think.

Union J were (IMO anyway) a million times better than Jade LAST night. Last week too actually(but she was ill). Though I agree Jade was better tonight.

I cant make sense of the bolded bit. You dont know that until the voting results are shown to us.

[Mystic Mock]

Well exactly. Deadlock...Jade still going. Cue the outrage at Nicole for voting UJ through instead of Jade instead.

Deadlock with union J going, cue outrage from Union J fans saying 'fix, they knew they were bottom of the vote and thats why it was deadlock'

Jade gets majority vote to stay. outrage from UJ fans 'Jade clearly had less votes than UJ and thats why it was the judges majority'

Your right that they can't please everyone, but they should vote correctly and for the third time this series they voted well off the mark, I would've understood the decision more if it was based off last nights performances.

[Vicky.]

Your right that they can't please everyone, but they should vote correctly and for the third time this series they voted well off the mark, I would've understood the decision more if it was based off last nights performances.

Again, this assumes that the sing off means something. It doesnt.

[Mystic Mock]

The singoff means nowt. That was established ages ago(waaay back when jedward were saved over lucie). However they sang tonight the result would have been the same I think.

Union J were (IMO anyway) a million times better than Jade LAST night. Last week too actually(but she was ill). Though I agree Jade was better tonight.

I cant make sense of the bolded bit. You dont know that until the voting results are shown to us.

I know how this show works, that's how I know that Union J came last in the votes, now next week if they hit it again they will take it to deadlock, Union J will scrape second from bottom and they will use the argument of "well the public voted and Union J got more votes than such and such" (more than likely be Ella) but it's very obvious imo.

[Me. I Am Salman]

he's a hypocrite

[Mystic Mock]

Again, this assumes that the sing off means something. It doesnt.

Well then why have it if it's not going to mean anything? why not just have more guest performances to waste time instead?

[Maia]

Mock owning the thread as usual

[Vicky.]

Well then why have it if it's not going to mean anything? why not just have more guest performances to waste time instead?

Dunno.

I really really want them to change the format next year. keep the singoff, but without the judges votes. Sing off at the START of the sunday show...then open the lines for the 2 in the bottom. Then have the guest performers, then announce whos leaving from the public vote.

They wouldnt get their drama that way though, so I dont think it would happen.

[Marsh.]

Again, this assumes that the sing off means something. It doesnt.

This. The sing-off has long been a pointless add on.

[Apple202]

Dunno.

I really really want them to change the format next year. keep the singoff, but without the judges votes. Sing off at the START of the sunday show...then open the lines for the 2 in the bottom. Then have the guest performers, then announce whos leaving from the public vote.

They wouldnt get their drama that way though, so I dont think it would happen.

I want this too but you're right, it will never happen. Although it still probably wouldn't have saved Jade tonight

[Marsh.]

Gary clearly didn't want it more than Jade did considering he sent her home. Idiot.

[Jamie585]

If he based his decision on the sing off, He would of saved Jade.

[Roy Mars III]

He made the right choice

[Saph]

Gary's the second worst judge after Cole.

[Kizzy]

2 words... frankie cocozza.
Jade would have sang better if she had not been styled to look totally ridiculous!
She must have been so embarrassed, none of the other acts had bolts through their necks...
She was set up imo, shame she is a great singer.

[Jamie585]

He made the right choice

lol

[Cherie]

You know, every week people have moaned that the judges 'copped out' and took it to deadlock, then the first week this doesnt happen theres still moaning about it. what on earth are they meant to do?

This, and I really dont understand why people get so hot under the collar about it all...its supposed to be an entertainment show...its not going to change my life whoever stays or goes.